Bathroom remodel tips?

I agree with that. We've had one for 9 years, used it maybe twice when DGD came to visit. For most people I think it would be a huge waste of resources.


+1... 10 years old installed new, and used 3 times... I bet I have cleaned the thing 100 times... When I renovate mine, there is a still a shower/tub combo in hallway bathroom if needed... But I doubt that since it hasnt been used much either.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
I do everything myself, so for what its worth, here are my comments:

TILE - Don't lay tile over tile. If this is over a concrete slab, you have a perfect tile base, so use it. After old tile is taken up, if the previous tile was laid with (eek!) adhesive from a bucket instead of mortar, the old adhesive needs to be scraped/ground off. Then after cleaning floor with just water, let it dry. Specify that Red Gard be used over the concrete slab before tiling. It is a roll-on decoupling membrane, and will reduce the chances of any cracking with foundation movement. It goes on fast, and takes overnight to cure. Directions must be followed to get a thick enough film. If the tiling is not going to occur soon after, then cardboard should be laid over it to keep the Red Gard layer clean and undamaged.
Use only Porcelain tile. Porcelain tile is a vastly superior product for many reasons. And is not that all much more than the garden variety "ceramic tile", which is just a glaze layer over crappy base tile clay.
Don't tile around anything. Pull the vanity, so the vanity will go back over the new floor tile.
Use thin-set mortar, Flexbond is a good one. Do NOT use an adhesive! Adhesive is popular, because: It's cheaper, it's faster, it requires less skill, and its crappy. Water infusion over time can loosen adhesive, and then you've got a real $ mess to try to fix. All those historic sites in the old world where fancy tile has lasted for thousands of years did NOT use adhesive!
Do not (and I see this all over!) grout up to a wall, tub, etc. Use matching color silicone caulk there instead. This avoids the inevitable cracking that will occur due to movement between surfaces. Done properly, the color-matched silicone will look just like the grout. The same problem exists in shower stalls between wall and floor, and wall to wall.

Heated Tile - If this is over a concrete slab, don't waste the $$$. It will not work well. The concrete slab is a giant thermal sink, and will be difficult to heat to any reasonable/worthwhile temp rise in a reasonable time. Sure, you could have a wall timer that automatically starts the floor heater cables up 6 hrs. before you may use the shower, but why?

Toilet - To each his own. The human body was not designed to sit at "chair height" for #2. It was a squat. In many parts of the world, you will find the Porcelain tray... I think the whole "chair height" is a gimmick to sell more fixtures and installation services. If in a wheelchair, I can see its advantages. We all ain't in wheelchairs, that's for sure. Maybe some are just so out of shape (read "too big") to handle a bit of flexing for a regular height toilet. Like I said up top, to each his own. I won't install them. Only regular.

Remember that a contractor will be there only for the job - he or she will not be living with the work year after year like you will. A lot of corner-cutting goes on to make the job quicker and cheaper, and competitive with others who look for a low price.

Well, I've probably done enough damage here, so I'll go away now :)
 
I read this thread with interest - over the last two weeks, we had three contractors come out to give us estimates to redo our master bathroom (fairly large, 15 years old). They estimated $20-30K!


Yikes. We're now thinking of plan B - deciding if we can cheap out and just replace the shower and tiles, and keep the vanity/counters and tub. Ugh.
 
Tailgate - looks like a fun project. You've got a good start with your list. Put together a written scope of work to include the items in your list, and specify materials, etc. There are probably some good examples online. Submit your plan to contractors for bids. Request written bids and go from there. Houzz and Pinterest are great paces to see photos, etc.

Good Luck!
 
We're almost done with our master bath remodel. DH did all the work himself - which was good for the budget, but bad for the timeline.

Ours was a down to the studs redo - some plumbing was moved as well. It also included replacing a window and some mold remediation where water had gotten inside the wall below the window. Since the space is smaller than public rooms, we splurged on a few higher end finishes (and chose less expensive things in other spots.) For example, we went with a gorgeous basketweave marble for the floor. Porcelain tile would have been cheaper but we love the floor.

Materials were $7k all in. That's everything from the new window, new subfloors, marble floors, new shower pan, tile for the shower, fixtures, custom vanity countertop w/ integrated sinks, etc. DH built the vanity and storage cabinet/shelves himself.... it was the only way to get it fit to the space exactly how we wanted.

He's almost done - 10 months in... but we were travelling for 2 of those months. The key is it's fully functional now (working sinks, toilet, shower)... it was tough when those weren't working.

He did put in grab bars in the shower and the toilet room. Just thinking long term. We also put in lots of storage so I don't have to schlep down to the garage to get more toilet paper.
 
We're almost done with our master bath remodel. DH did all the work himself - which was good for the budget, but bad for the timeline.

I have a friend who's very handy and did his entire kitchen.

I think it took over a year and was a bit tough on the marriage.......hey, golf takes priority!
 
thanks..yes, grab bars are a must..hadn't thought about the taller toilets-good idea.
I totally agree that the current setup is nice enough, however the garden tub is useless to us. The glass framed shower is clouded up pretty bad by hard water spots that we can't remove. It would cost me about 1k to replace the shower frame and glass, but DW is intent on her dream bathroom and she puts up with my crap, so that entitles her. :LOL:
Tailgate,
Our bathroom is similar to your picture although yours looks nicer. We too are considering a remodel for the two biggest reasons you describe. We would like to get rid of our glass enclosed shower and have a walk-in stone or tile shower. And our garden tub is useless except as a dirty clothes collector so I'd rather have that space for a large shower. But here is the question holding us back.

Does not having a tub in your master bath kill resale? We hear it does. Even though everyone I know thinks its useless. Is this a concern for you? Even if you have no current plans of moving I hate to kill resale potential. Interested in your thoughts since our baths look so identical.

Good luck with your remodel.

Muir
 
I fully understand getting rid of the tub and concentrating on building a useful and enjoyable shower. Did just that when we redid the master bath - removed whirlpool tub that was rarely used and yanked the fiberglass showerstall that had developed cracks in the floor. Built a large showerstall with wall mounted body spray (rarely used), rainfall shower head (normal use), and a handheld spray head. DW and I both have both been very appreciative of the handheld and built in corner seating when convalescing from surgeries. Our shower is built with three walls covered with tile, ceiling is also tiled as is the floor of course. Fourth wall is fixed glass and door. Had replaced the water softener so hard water stains are a problem no more.

One thing I had not thought of, and electrician suggested about half an hour before tile installer showed up, was to install can lighting inside shower stall - darn glad he mentioned it, as he had materials on hand to do it and it would be a dark cave if we had not gone ahead with it. Definitely something to think about if enclosing the shower space with floor to ceiling walls.

And we've never missed the tub, although I've still got it tucked into my shop - thought about using it as a hot tub and building a frame to mount it on the deck.
 
One thing I had not thought of, and electrician suggested about half an hour before tile installer showed up, was to install can lighting inside shower stall - darn glad he mentioned it, as he had materials on hand to do it and it would be a dark cave if we had not gone ahead with it. Definitely something to think about if enclosing the shower space with floor to ceiling walls.

"My" bathroom has a big shower with a bench in it - definitely get a light in there!
 
Let me suggest terazzo for the shower base. We put it in ours and it looks and feels really nice.
 
Last edited:
after spending a lot of time on The University Of Youtube researching, we tried everything that was recommended..and Barkeeper's Friend was the very top suggested product... didn't make a dent. Spots are etched into the glass. Glass company said 'it happens'... they highly recommended using the full strength RainX on all the shower glass every 3 months or so...still need to squeegee some, but not as much and the minerals supposedly won't 'set'.
I think the condition of the glass is what turned DW into the full blown remodel...she wants a walk-in shower with no glass. She didn't discourage me from buying a boat a couple of years ago, so the bathroom is ok with me (as soon as I sell the boat..LOL)

We're just finishing a gut remodel of our master bath, one hall bath and the laundry room. Haven't had a chance to try it out, but we did do the underfloor heating. We ripped out an oversized, never used, jacuzzi tub and put in a no door walk in shower, 5' x 5' in its place.

Wrt to shower glass, glass is porous and that clouding is etched into the glass and will never ever come out. We have elected to pay (~$90/sq ft IIRC) for a product called Diamond Fusion. It's applied once by the glass folks and makes the glass much less porous. We put in a pony wall, but still have some glass on the upper part. You still need to clean it, but not like regular glass...we'll see.

We also installed grab bars...google 'designer grab bars' for some that don't look like grab bars.

Good luck. Our kitchen and downstairs bath get gutted on the 24th!
 
Tailgate,
Our bathroom is similar to your picture although yours looks nicer. We too are considering a remodel for the two biggest reasons you describe. We would like to get rid of our glass enclosed shower and have a walk-in stone or tile shower. And our garden tub is useless except as a dirty clothes collector so I'd rather have that space for a large shower. But here is the question holding us back.

Does not having a tub in your master bath kill resale? We hear it does. Even though everyone I know thinks its useless. Is this a concern for you? Even if you have no current plans of moving I hate to kill resale potential. Interested in your thoughts since our baths look so identical.

Good luck with your remodel.

Muir

Good question Muir... we live in a retirement community 55+ ages, so I think resale here is not an issue (there is a generic tub in the guest bath). I think the tub issue applies to families with kids where the tub is very important. The only times we've used the garden tub is to bathe the dogs.
 
Tailgate,
... ...Does not having a tub in your master bath kill resale? We hear it does. Even though everyone I know thinks its useless. Is this a concern for you? Even if you have no current plans of moving I hate to kill resale potential. Interested in your thoughts since our baths look so identical.

Good luck with your remodel.

Muir

We did a lot of research on this as not only did we remove the master jacuzzi tub, but will also convert the downstairs bathroom's tub into a shower, leaving one tub in the upstairs bath.

Consensus is that you really only need one tub in the house (in our area anyway).
 
It sure seems like the big shower minus the tub is the "in thing" now. Hopefully it will last too since I am headed that way. Then again my problems begin because jet tubs where the "in thing" when I had my house built. :(


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
I've got 4.5 bathrooms - (his) one with a huge shower, (hers) one with a jacuzzi tub and a separate shower, and two with single tubs (guests)


I don't fit in the Jacuzzi very well
 
I have a friend who's very handy and did his entire kitchen.

I think it took over a year and was a bit tough on the marriage.......hey, golf takes priority!

We already did the kitchen. 3 years! But the price was right and everything is exactly how I wanted it and custom to the space. In his defense - the kitchen was only non-functional for 3 days when the old sink/counter were removed until the new stainless counters were installed and another 2 days when we'd removed the old cooktop for the new bertazoni oven/range. That was an advantage of keeping most of the cabinets - just refinishing them. He built custom additions to the cabinets as well.
 
And we've never missed the tub, although I've still got it tucked into my shop - thought about using it as a hot tub and building a frame to mount it on the deck.

Or get a second one and do whatever those people are doing in the Cialis commercial!
 
Consider a heated tile floor. They are great.

Sent from my XT1575 using Early Retirement Forum mobile app
 
Go to the GardenWeb forums now at Houzz to ask bathroom remodeling questions:

That Home Site! Forums - GardenWeb

(It is also a great forum for kitchen remodels and for house buying/selling).

One thing to do is possibly talk to a designer and get ideas. For example it might make sense to move some stuff around, that kind of thing. Also post a sketch or your picture on gardenweb and get ideas.

If you are replacing countertops you might want to replace dated sinks and faucets and possibly lighting. Since you are taking out a large tub (which I agree with), if you don't have adequate storage in your bathroom, you might have room for a built in large linen cabinet or some other storage or built in hampers, that kind of thing.

If you are replacing with a larger shower some other options include:

1. Rain shower head (on the ceiling).

2. Possibly making it a 2 person shower with 2 sets of shower heads.

3. Built in bench.

4. Also maybe a shower massage panel.

Oh, another thing. If replacing countertops, look carefully at your cabinets. Do they need to be replaced? Are they laid out how you want them? Now is the time to change them if there is anything you want different. If the cabs are painted do you want to change color? Same thing with your mirror. If you want to change anything now is the time.
 
Wow - those are pretty long time frames for the DIY remodels! I did our bathroom in about 5 weeks. Phase 1 was removing soffits, doing electrical/lighting/exhaust fan work, and drywalling where the soffits used to be. Took about a week and a half. Phase 2 was removing tile and walls from shower, removing old (cast iron) tub, installing new tub, walls, and tile. Took about 2 weeks. Phase 3 was floor, vanity, toilet, etc. Took about a week.
 
We decided against a heated tile floor because I wanted instant heat. We ended up installing one of those ceiling light, vent, heater combos and it works great in our fairly small 12' x 5' bathroom. I love it most during those cold trips to the bathroom in the middle of the night. Now I just have to make sure I don't fall asleep on the toilet because I am so warm & toasty.
 
I did two upstairs bath remodels a little over a year or so ago. One was the original master (prior to a downstairs master addition over 17 years ago) and one was the children's bath. So one was a decent size (10 x 12ish), and the children's bath was small (5 X 8).
For the old Master, it was a total gut job. Goal was to get a larger shower in there but still have a tub although a smaller one. Cost was $16,373. That included porcelain tile on floors and walls up to the window sills, new double sink counter, granite counter tops, granite tub surround (did not want grout lines and it is on same wall and tied into the counter so it flowed better), new smaller tub, new faucets and shower fixtures including hand held, frameless shower door with knee wall, new taller toilet, etc.

The smaller bath was also a total gut. Goal was to get a larger shower. I removed the Aquaglass acrylic tub shower and went back with just a shower (3 X 5) . Same porcelain tile on floors and walls, granite on new single sink counter, new toilet, new fixtures. Total cost was $10,253.

I had a quote from a Kitchen/Bath Remodeling company for the smaller 6 x 8 ft second bath which exceeded $20,000 and was more than I had paid for the larger bath. So I opted to do it the same way I did the first bath which
was :

I had a contractor …sort of…but not a contract or even a proposal. He was a friend of my brother's but is a Class A contractor that builds homes. I say sort of because I ended up doing a lot of the running around and scheduling of the other subs…which saved some money since my "sort of" contractor didn't do it. It's not for everyone and it is why I almost had the other company do the second one until I heard the price. Since he was using my jobs as filler jobs it took way longer than I had hoped. Months and months! It's also why I have not yet done the downstairs Master, although that is not in as bad shape as these upstairs baths were in. I'll get to it …one day!

In addition to all the helpful hints others have given you, if you are going to do this, I recommend going with the taller cabinet height (34 inch to 35 inch with counter top) if you replace the cabinet. I did this in my downstairs master and loved not having to bend over as far.

Instead of the traditional mud pan, I ended up going with a contractor (my brothers friend) who installed the Schulter System for tiled showers as I was convinced it is the best way to keep moisture from cracking shower floors and having moisture problems later with any of the tiles in the shower.
Shower System | schluter.com

All of that said, as others have said, your bath looks nice as is!
 
Last edited:
DW and I are planning a master bath remodel later this year after we both retire (will try to some of the work myself). Like many others commenting in this thread, we're considering eliminating the Jacuzzi tub and going with just one big shower. But, we do worry that the lack of a tub in the master bath could impact resale value. Any thoughts on this?


Sent from my iPad using Early Retirement Forum
 
Wow - those are pretty long time frames for the DIY remodels!

Tell me about it. LOL.

His excuse - hey - he's retired too.... Mañana is good enough.
 
I feel your pain, moving into a new place in 3 weeks so haven't been able to price it out but saw online someone putting out an "all-in" price of $8900 for standard bathroom remodel tub to shower conversion, new vanity, double sink, new floor, but I'm sure that means no changes in plumbing.

For me, no shower is complete without seat, niches for the goodies, double shower head so you have the handheld just in case you break your leg (seat/handleheld come in handy). I prefer the prefab floors, I've had a few friends complain about the tiled showers being difficult ot clean and not necessarily comfortable on the feet. One put in pebble floor and ended up with a mat in the shower because it was painful to his feet.
 
Back
Top Bottom