Best "value" in a luxury car

[gerntz]

I was looking for something "luxury"-ish...but then I remembered I have boats I have to pull around. So I bought a '15 Highlander. It feels luxurious to me! Maybe that's because it's replacing a 15 year old pick-up truck.
I like the ride, and the seat is comfy for me, something that has become a major issue as I age, along with the ease of getting in and out.

Now that's a valid SUV reason & a High isn't that massive.

 

[Danmar]

I also drive BMW and BMW has advanced technology and love have color heads up display as well as all the other features you do not find on a lot of other sports sedans ( I have the 328 xi with M sport package) consumer reports recommends it and it has good reliability per consumer reports.....

Agree the 3 series are great cars.

 

[Danmar]

I keep thinking I will get over driving sporty cars. But so far I just can't bring myself to drive American or Japanese "mush". Not saying they aren't good value or meet most people's needs, I just like a more engaging ride. I drive mostly for fun and I just don't find main stream cars much fun.

 

[John Galt III]

My luxury car is my 88 Firebird Trans Am GTA 350 with leather seats, which I keep in the garage and drive once in a while. Bought it used in 96. Reliability has been very good with the exception of having a pinched ignition wire which took me forever to track down, and also had to get a new ECU once. My ideal luxury car would be a 70's or 80's V8 whale (if only they still made them new!).

 

[audreyh1]

There are so many BMWs around here it's incredible!!!

 

[cyber888]

Audi - nice balance between luxurious ride and driving fun, has quattro, and new Audis have stellar technology. It is also more reliable than the BMWs. I've had 4 Audis. The A6/S6 for a luxurious ride, and S5 for a sporty ride. If you can afford $110K, get the RS7.

BMW - a driver's car. you stick to the road and can feel the road. It's comfy, as long as it's not the sports suspension. Bimmers usually have electrical problems - that's what mine had. I've test driven the 4 series and love it. The 4 Series Grand Coupe has more luggage space due to its Liftback design. The M3 and M4 are pretty fast and can cause you whiplash

Mercedes - it's ok, but the controls are kinda old fashion. I rented one last summer to drive around Scotland and it performed well. The new Mercedes looks good outside, but I still prefer the interior of the Audis. For fast Benz, get the AMG version.

 

[Sunset]

This was my dream car, but they stopped making them to soon.

 

[HFWR]

With a custom sound system...

 

[HadEnuff]

Audi - nice balance between luxurious ride and driving fun, has quattro, and new Audis have stellar technology. It is also more reliable than the BMWs. I've had 4 Audis. The A6/S6 for a luxurious ride, and S5 for a sporty ride. If you can afford $110K, get the RS7.

BMW - a driver's car. you stick to the road and can feel the road. It's comfy, as long as it's not the sports suspension. Bimmers usually have electrical problems - that's what mine had. I've test driven the 4 series and love it. The 4 Series Grand Coupe has more luggage space due to its Liftback design. The M3 and M4 are pretty fast and can cause you whiplash

Mercedes - it's ok, but the controls are kinda old fashion. I rented one last summer to drive around Scotland and it performed well. The new Mercedes looks good outside, but I still prefer the interior of the Audis. For fast Benz, get the AMG version.

This from the one whose signature says "no to consumerism etc"

 

[marko]

This, there are so many "unfriendly" people in the world we have no desire to draw attention to ourselves.

Well, the comment the guy made was in admiration. When you're told your car is "bad ass" it's generally an extreme compliment.

But your comment does remind me of my great-uncle who wouldn't smoke cigars in public because he didn't want anyone to think he was wealthy. Of course, he was fairly famous for being wealthy--and lived in the biggest house in town-- so I'm not sure what exactly he was aiming at.

 

[cyber888]

I stand by that motto. Just because I know about these cars does not mean I will buy all of them. I've had these brands in the past when I was younger. Right now, I have one car - the one I need. When I said I had a couple of these brands, that was over a span of 20 years (I didn't buy all of them at the same time).

This from the one whose signature says "no to consumerism etc"

 

[G8tr]

Thank you to everyone who replied. Based on several great suggestions, I think it's time to do some test driving.


Sent from my iPad using Early Retirement Forum

 

[aja8888]

There are so many BMWs around here it's incredible!!!

Same in our town!

The BMW dealer expanded to the point where they built an entire new dealership for the Mini right next to the new Mercedes dealer. I see more BMW SUV's here than Honda's. It seems like the "white BMW SUV" is becoming the choice of the female daytime tennis and county club crowd in town and the high school daughter gets blessed with a 3 series convertible for her 16th birthday!

 

[eytonxav]

Same in our town!

It seems like the "white BMW SUV" is becoming the choice of the female daytime tennis and county club crowd in town and the high school daughter gets blessed with a 3 series convertible for her 16th birthday!

This reminded me of when my kids were in high school, and there were a few kids who brought their Vipers and Hummers to school. We had way too many with affluenza in my previous community, before we downsized.

 

[Ian S]

Both Hyundai and its sister brand Kia now make decent luxury cars that are good values. The Hyundai Genesis and Kia Cadenza are both highly ranked by the latest Consumer Reports. The warranty for both is unmatched: 5yr/60,000 mi basic and 10 yr/100,000 mile powertrain. I've also had great service on my Hyundai from two different dealers.

 

[HadEnuff]

I stand by that motto. Just because I know about these cars does not mean I will buy all of them. I've had these brands in the past when I was younger. Right now, I have one car - the one I need. When I said I had a couple of these brands, that was over a span of 20 years (I didn't buy all of them at the same time).

I'm just jealous...they are sweet.

 

[Bamaman]

Audi - nice balance between luxurious ride and driving fun, has quattro, and new Audis have stellar technology. It is also more reliable than the BMWs.
BMW - a driver's car. you stick to the road and can feel the road. It's comfy, as long as it's not the sports suspension. Bimmers usually have electrical problems - that's what mine had.
Mercedes - it's ok, but the controls are kinda old fashion. I rented one last summer to drive around Scotland and it performed well. The new Mercedes looks good outside, but I still prefer the interior of the Audis.

My family owns a major luxury car dealership. My observations are:

Audi's are essentially luxury VW's, and all VW's are strange machines mechanically. Few independent service shops have the tools, knowledge or mechanics to work on them. Dealerships are few and far between--just in larger cities. I don't want to have to drive 2 hrs. to get service or parts.

BMW's are fine drivers' cars, but they're a nightmare of electrical problems. They've had to add full maintenance and long warranties to the sale--or customers would be in a heap of trouble. I wouldn't want to keep one past the full maintenance and warranty period. (I keep cars much longer than that presently.)

Mercedes--Many problems are experienced on Mercs., including brakes and a/c evaporator problems. Many dealers are hesitant to trade for Mercedes because there seems to be something wrong with the majority of trades taken in. Many car dealers have a wholesaler that buys all of their Mercedes--and they don't carry them on their used car lot.

All of the above vehicles are extremely expensive to fix even minor problems on. My Jaguar has over 17 modules on it, many of which communicate with each other thru CAN/BUS wires that are like computer wires. Each module costs about $1K, and they do go bad. My new Explorer is even more complicated with over 100 fuses and many, many relays. I would love to have a simple automobile without all the bells and whistles--like in the Good Ole Days..

 

[LOL!]

Best value depends on where one lives. In my area, a Lexus is a beater car. If one comes to an intersection with 4-way stop signs, there will often be 5 Lexus vehicles at the intersection.

This means that if one wants the best value in my area, a used Lexus is going to be the best value. Lots of folks seem to use a 3-year lease, so there are hundreds of Lexus SUVs and cars coming off lease that are 3 years old. Generally, they are thousands of dollars less than a Mercedes, Acura, or Audi of the same age. And the sellers will negotiate because you have so many to choose from. That's the sweet spot.

So what's the sweet spot in your area?

 

[HadEnuff]

This reminded me of when my kids were in high school, and there were a few kids who brought their Vipers and Hummers to school. We had way too many with affluenza in my previous community, before we downsized.

I remember hearing a comedian(forget who) on the radio relating a story about how he was asked, after achieving a modicum of success, to address the current student body at his old high school.
He said he told a story about how in 1983 when he was in that very high school, sitting in that very auditorium he had a dream. It was to own an '83 Trans Am...so he set about to earn it. Worked every day on his craft. Had his "ups" and had his "downs" but after 15 years of working his plan, he achieved it. He went on to explain that only the day before he took out a loan on an '83 Trans Am.
"See...dreams DO come true"...

 

[travelover]

............So what's the sweet spot in your area?

Living in Metro Detroit, everyone buys at an employee and family discount, so used American cars are deeply discounted, as opposed to imports.

 

[aja8888]

So what's the sweet spot in your area?

I'm in your area and if you haven't noticed, BMW's are multiplying like jackrabbits.

But, I have to agree, a used Lexus around here is the new Toyota Camry in numbers.

 

[G8tr]

Best value depends on where one lives. In my area, a Lexus is a beater car. If one comes to an intersection with 4-way stop signs, there will often be 5 Lexus vehicles at the intersection.

This means that if one wants the best value in my area, a used Lexus is going to be the best value. Lots of folks seem to use a 3-year lease, so there are hundreds of Lexus SUVs and cars coming off lease that are 3 years old. Generally, they are thousands of dollars less than a Mercedes, Acura, or Audi of the same age. And the sellers will negotiate because you have so many to choose from. That's the sweet spot.

So what's the sweet spot in your area?

Pretty wide range of luxury cars in my area, though BMWs and Lexuses (Lexi?) seem dominant. As I noted in my original post, I've been a Honda guy for years. At this point in my life, I'm inclined strongly to buy what I want, not just what I need. Luxury nameplates don't really impress anyone around here, but not driving a luxury car will draw negative attention in certain circles. If I had the garage space (i.e. 3-car garage), I would buy a classic luxury car for fun/appearances and another Honda for a daily driver. Unfortunately, I don't, so combining the two is my only practical option.


Sent from my iPad using Early Retirement Forum

 

[Texas Proud]

Pretty wide range of luxury cars in my area, though BMWs and Lexuses (Lexi?) seem dominant. As I noted in my original post, I've been a Honda guy for years. At this point in my life, I'm inclined strongly to buy what I want, not just what I need. Luxury nameplates don't really impress anyone around here, but not driving a luxury car will draw negative attention in certain circles. If I had the garage space (i.e. 3-car garage), I would buy a classic luxury car for fun/appearances and another Honda for a daily driver. Unfortunately, I don't, so combining the two is my only practical option.


Sent from my iPad using Early Retirement Forum

Just my opinion, but a top of the line Honda or Toyota is more luxurious than a bottom Acura or Lexus.... (I am talking similar cars, not big vs small)....

 

[G8tr]

Just my opinion, but a top of the line Honda or Toyota is more luxurious than a bottom Acura or Lexus.... (I am talking similar cars, not big vs small)....

I don't disagree with this, but it depends on how you characterize top of the line. Much of the in-car (interior) technology for which people are paying top dollar to have in cars will be (or already is) in your phone. I'd rather buy a luxury car that offers safety and/or performance features that aren't on Hondas. Then again, those will also become standard on lower tier, non luxury cars 3-5 years later (hence the trickle down of Acura tech into Hondas).


Sent from my iPad using Early Retirement Forum

 

[audreyh1]

Same in our town!

The BMW dealer expanded to the point where they built an entire new dealership for the Mini right next to the new Mercedes dealer. I see more BMW SUV's here than Honda's. It seems like the "white BMW SUV" is becoming the choice of the female daytime tennis and county club crowd in town and the high school daughter gets blessed with a 3 series convertible for her 16th birthday!

We're not an affluent area like the Woodlands. Nevertheless, there seem to be plenty of affluent drivers, and BMWs dominate. That's one brand you don't have to worry about being noticed here.