I got scammed out of $220, with clear evidence the buyer was lying, but it’s easy. A few examples:
- Buy an item, use it for up to 180 days (approx 6 months), break it and return for a full refund (you have 180 days if you use PayPal).
- If you break say item A you bought anywhere that you’ve owned for a long time, order another exactly like it on eBay, item B. When item B arrives, claim it was broken, return item A for a full refund (including shipping) and keep item B. Won’t work with unique items (serial number, very rare), but it can work with lots of everyday items.
There are other similar angles. Many eBay sellers just refund without even asking for the item to be returned, and unscrupulous buyers know that. Again, I’ve had 4% scam buyers, it’s a cost of doing business on eBay. I block those buyers from further purchases, but that just means they scam another seller.
If you want “revenge” the most you can do is insist the buyer return the broken item including all packaging so you can file a claim with USPS or whoever. They might not want to be bothered, but seems unlikely to me. And as you might imagine, filing a claim with USPS is a waste of time, probably because they have no way of separating legit damage from bogus damage.