Who Is Running This Choo-Choo Train?

[Eagle43]

Fred doesn't think much of Iraq war or of GWB? His reasoning is, as always, precise and eloquent.

Quote
The crumbling has begun, methinks.

Is this surprising? If I may risk repeating myself tiresomely, the way to defeat the American military is to avoiding giving it clear targets, keep the body bags flowing into Dover or Travis, and wait. It is that simple. The insurgents know this. They are doing it, and it is working. Five Marines today, three tomorrow, twelve GIs one week, nine another. On and on. So far we have killed 1700 of our soldiers, closing in on 2000. Sooner or later, even Middle America will notice.
....

What price nothing? A couple of thousand dead kids, countless cripples who will remain crippled when the current administration has been forgotten, a country wrecked, God knows how many dead Iraqis (I know, they don’t count), thousands of sisters and mothers remembering Bobby every Christmas and looking at his last year book from high school, a tremendous diminution in America’s influence and prestige as China rises, unforeseeable consequences in the Middle East. For what, Mr. Bush? For what?
Unquote

http://www.fredoneverything.net/FOE_Frame_Column.htm

[dex]

Originally Posted by Eagle43

Is this surprising? If I may risk repeating myself tiresomely, the way to defeat the American military is to avoiding giving it clear targets, keep the body bags flowing into Dover or Travis, and wait. It is that simple. The insurgents know this. They are doing it, and it is working. Five Marines today, three tomorrow, twelve GIs one week, nine another. On and on. So far we have killed 1700 of our soldiers, closing in on 2000. Sooner or later, even Middle America will notice.

http://www.fredoneverything.net/FOE_Frame_Column.htm

It is not the American military that gets defeated. It is the American people. They (we) lose the will to fight (this is not intended to be a coment of the value to start the war or continue being there). What you state is nothing that the insurgents do not know. 9/11 attack was based upon the same assumption. Since the Vietnam war and all actions up to and to some degree the first Gulf War (afraid of fighting in the streets of Bagdah) was perceived by the enemies of the USA that the US people are too soft and materilistic to make the sacrifices to fight a protracted action.

I think others in the USA (military and politicians) belive the USA will accept high casuality rates. This is why so much money is spent on long distance and high technology armaments.

So if what you say becomes reality then it does not portend peace. It would lead to more attacks by not only in the middle east but posability the likes of China, and N. Korea. A person may say - well they got what they wanted so why would they continue to attck? Two reasons - 1. Totalitarian regimes (and cults) need an outside enemy for their reason for being and legititamacy. 2. It is the culture and idea of the USA that is the real threat to the terrorists.

Yes the death toll in Iraq will reach 2,000. I think 2,500 US solders died on D day alone.

There is an article in the NY Sunday Times hinting that the US military is hinting that a draft may be needed. Now that will provide some interesting reading and will be very telling about the American public. If a draft were to start would there be all the exemptions there were in the past?

Every empire began its decline when it lost its will to fight. Since Egypt the lenght of time an empire existed has become shorter and shorter. Maybe the USA's reign will be the shortest. Was WWII the height?

Getting out of Iraq before a government is established may make us feel good in the short term but, it will sow the seeds of future attacks.

I don't know what will happen. I only know that the common good sense of the American public always seems to surprise me.

[laurence]

I think the problem is a clear mission. When you don't know who the bad guys are and a large contingent of the population doesn't want you in their country....the American people can stomach casualties for a cause they believe in. There has been very little to believe in the Iraq war.

I'm not ready to call then decline of empire, because this isn't an empire, and I hope it never becomes one. Previous empires declined and fell partly because they were "regimes" not democracies. Also, England made a relatively peaceful transition from Kingdom to democracy, and managed to avoid apocolyptic destruction/downfall for almost a thousand years now.

[TK]

Remember that the reason you can stand on your lily white soapbox is because of people prior to you and now ;are doing the hard work for liberty and freedom.

Quoting the one sided media and slanted websites does not account for the good we are doing. Are we perfect heck no. But you and I both have chose to live in this the best country in the world.

When was the last time people wanted to sneak into France? or Germany or Russia? Or immigrate to China?

God Bless our soldiers, law enforcement, and government officials.

I support your right to object but take the responsiblity to appreciate what we are and the responsibility that it comes with.

It is to easy to complain.... Do something to help the effort.

[TK]

Oh yeah and by the way ...

WE haven't killed any of our soldiers ...

The bad guys do the killing - duh !!!

[JPatrick]

Originally Posted by TK

Remember that the reason you can stand on your lily white soapbox is because of people prior to you and now ;are doing the hard work for liberty and freedom.

Quoting the one sided media and slanted websites does not account for the good we are doing.* Are we perfect heck no.* But you and I both have chose to live in this the best country in the world.

When was the last time people wanted to sneak into France? or Germany or Russia?* Or immigrate to China?

God Bless our soldiers, law enforcement, and government officials.

I support your right to object but take the responsiblity to appreciate what we are and the responsibility that it comes with.

It is to easy to complain.... Do something to help the effort.

Right on TK 8)

[73ss454]

TK
What about Tillman

[laurence]

If you stepped in front of a train TK, you would know what was going to happen. Bush sent troops there knowing they would die, he felt it was worth it. I thought playing with semantics was Clinton's game.

I'm chuckling at some one accusing Eagle43 of being a lib on his lily white soap box. Fox News, Rush Limbaugh, G. Gordon Liddy, yep, one sided news. But what did your comments do to further this debate?

France and Germany are dealing with immigration problems of their own, Cina has north koreans crossing the border all the time, and your really scraping bottom to use Russia for comparison. Next.

Absolutely, God bless them all, but where in the above posts did people attack our soldiers? I missed the accusation of "baby killer" somewhere. It's the genius of Karl Rove that somehow if you attack Bush - who never served in a combat zone- you somehow don't support the troops, or you hate America.

Some would say objecting to the death of our soldiers fighting in a country that didn't attack us, wasting billions, and all the while eroding the rights given us in our constitution rather than sitting by and doing nothing IS doing something. Saddam had an election where 100% of the population voted for him. Let's not go there.

[Nords]

Originally Posted by Eagle43

Sooner or later, even Middle America will notice.

Uhm, everyone remembers that sailors & airmen have been dying in the Persian Gulf since the First Gulf War ended in 1991, right? It was called Operation SOUTHERN WATCH, with a few unexpected bonus deliveries like DESERT FOX.

As much as all the aviators appreciated the flight hours & combat pay, it was well past time to end this.

And now it's time to implement that exit strategy. Can someone post a link to the exit strategy and its timeline? We do have one, right?

As for the draft, speaking for all those currently on active duty, "no way." Two-year enlistments were a miserable failure and those people were volunteers. I can only imagine how the coerced conscripts would perform. Go ask guys like Dan Inouye, Randy Cunningham, John McCain, & John Kerry (I'm sure I missed a few due to my lack of knowledge) how they feel about a draft.

[cute fuzzy bunny]

Every empire began its decline when it lost its will to fight.

Actually every empire declined when the people became fat and the huns attacked. The huns dont play by the prescribed rules of engagement. The huns sacking rome, the minute men shooting the brits from behind trees instead of marching in lines, terrorists picking off who they want from a structured army.

I'm not ready to call then decline of empire, because this isn't an empire, and I hope it never becomes one.

We're an imperial republic. We're a republic, not a democracy by specific definition. Look it up. A 'true democracy' is almost impossible to make work in a large society, our forefathers knew that, and its reflected both in their writings and in how our country is structured. Imperial because we have overtly and covertly imposed our will on many countries and cultures over a long period of time, creating ill will in the process.

We havent transitioned from imperial republic to empire either because we still want to look like the good guys and the public wouldnt allow it, or because we're only doing the least we can do to maintain our quality of life and maintain the stability of the world...former or latter depending on your perspective.

But the fact remains that we were an anti-communist empire for some time, and that has transitioned to an oil control empire. And we're fat. And the huns are coming.

[HFWR]

I believe that a draft should only be implemented if there is a declaration of war.

[cute fuzzy bunny]

Originally Posted by Nords

And now it's time to implement that exit strategy. Can someone post a link to the exit strategy and its timeline? We do have one, right?

Tricky, tricky. You see, the reason why we didnt take out saddam in the first gulf war is that we needed him. He was not a muslim nutcase and stomped out any insurgency or religious fiddle faddle in his country, and he sat square between Iran (and other muslim extremists), turkey, and our friends saudi arabia and israel. We needed him there but we needed to keep him on a short leash and weak enough to not be aggressive, hence the periodic golf-course creation via bombers. (if nobody gets that, golf courses are flat open areas with lots of little holes in them).

When he got so weak he realized his neighbors were getting restless, he made noises about chemical, biological and nuclear weapons just to keep them guessing and at arms length. We realized he wasnt going to be able to hang in there a lot longer, any attempts to softly create a new regime wouldnt work because the muslims would grab power and turn iran/iraq into a composite muslim extremist state parked right on top of and next to the majority of the worlds oil.

So we used saddams empty threats as a reason to park 150,000 soldiers there until we can remake the government back into a reasonable buffer. That'll take 5-10 years. Thats our exit strategy: when a stable government with a stable military thats friendly to the US, the saudis and the israelis is able to stand alone, we'll pull out. But probably keep several bases in place just to be sure.

And that 2000 will turn into 30-40,000 between now and then, including the couple of minor civil wars we'll call insurgency activity and maybe even a little showdown with iran.

[cute fuzzy bunny]

Originally Posted by Have Funds, Will Retire

I believe that a draft should only be implemented if there is a declaration of war.

Funny part is, if you read the constitution we're not even supposed to HAVE a standing army, but to create one in time of need to address threats to our national security, then disband it again. The founding fathers wanted no part of the US maintaining a large standing army, both due to cost and the desire to use what you have.

[Nords]

Originally Posted by Notth

We havent transitioned from imperial republic to empire either because we still want to look like the good guys and the public wouldnt allow it...

... of course they wouldn't. They all saw what happened to Darth Vader when his republic turned into an empire!

[cute fuzzy bunny]

Yeah, but the good news is they wouldnt have to roshambo for who wears the big black helmet...cheney would volunteer in a heartbeat. Plus he could use that breathing apparatus...

[HFWR]

Originally Posted by Notth

Funny part is, if you read the constitution we're not even supposed to HAVE a standing army, but to create one in time of need to address threats to our national security, then disband it again.* The founding fathers wanted no part of the US maintaining a large standing army, both due to cost and the desire to use what you have.

I think this approach is somewhat impractical in the modern world; however, as Eisenhower warned, the military-industrial complex is self-replicating and self-serving. And, many of the arms we've spread throughout the world, for one expedient reason or another, have eventually been used against us...

[laurence]

TH, ya, ya, I know we're actually a republic, I was saving time and using the more general term. Thank God we aren't a true democracy. As it is, all this ballot initiative stuff in CA is getting way out of hand!

So from what I'm reading, when can I expect those 14 senators to corner Bush and stab him in dramatic fashion, the last being McCain with Bush saying, "eh tu, John?"?

I just get a little heated when people start implying any critisizm of the current administration means you hate America and should be put in an internment camp. Especially since most of these same people spent 8 years trying to tear down the last administration.

[cute fuzzy bunny]

Yep...nothing like getting "dixie chicked".

You complain about the bushies and you're a lib and a traitor scumbag.

Good job by the administration of spinning dissenters into that hole full of sharp sticks. Keeps most peoples mouths shut.

The biggest problem I have is the guys on video tape saying "blah blah blah", then another clip of them a year later saying "I *never* said 'blah blah blah". Its insulting to my intelligence.