Commodity Prices and Fund Failures

Interesting, especially this:

"But Philip Gotthelf of New Jersey trading firm Equidex says the commodities selloff could just be beginning, given how many investors rushed headlong into the sector during the past year or two. He tells Bloomberg television the price of crude oil could be on its way to $50 a barrel from a recent $108."

Where was he 3 months ago to tell us about this impinging drop to $50 per barrel? It would have been nice about $40 per barrel ago! Darn those analysts.
 
Not going to shed one tear for those who made money on the run up of oil and other commodities prices.

They made money while the high prices sapped the economy for everyone else.
 
Oil, gold and other commodities still have a way to go. Six more months of gut wrenching drops.

Really unfortunate for the folks who just piled into commodity funds thinking they were as safe as CD's, only with better returns.
 
Diversification! Most of the model portfolios (for small investors) that I studied that had some allocation to commodities in some way (through some sort of fund) only allocated 5%-10%.

If people stuck with that approach, they should not be hurt too much. But people who gambled big... are going to feel it.
 
explanade said:
Not going to shed one tear for those who made money on the run up of oil and other commodities prices.

They made money while the high prices sapped the economy for everyone else.
Click to expand...
The government needs to step and help them, like bear sterns, like the
homeowners with bad loans, like fannies!! :eek:
TJ
 
In my portfolio, only bonds and small-caps are up ytd, with PCRIX just barely negative. Everything else is dramatically lower...

So diversification works; some things are less worse than others. :p
 
HFWR said:
In my portfolio, only bonds and small-caps are up ytd, with PCRIX just barely negative. Everything else is dramatically lower...

So diversification works; some things are less worse than others. :p
Click to expand...
Your small caps are up? Are these individual stocks, ETFs or mutual funds?

Right now, nothing works except cash. That is a major difference between this bear market and the one in 2000-2002. In the previous bear market, several asset classes still did very well even as domestic large caps tanked. And I think that's why this one feels worse to asset allocators even though in terms of U.S. large cap it's not nearly as bad as the previous bear.
 
I have an institutional small-cap fund in my 401k, based on the Russell 2000. It's actually down 6.5%, though rebalancing had me slightly positive until today...
 
Last edited:
My small caps (Vanguard tax managed small cap) are up about 10% last I checked. I did, however, rebalance in to them at a very opportune time. But that's the beauty of rebalancing - I picked an asset class that had dropped to a low and that I needed to bring back up a few percent.

(edited to add - small caps I rebalanced into are up more like 8.5% as of 9/3/08 close of business)
 
FUEGO said:
My small caps (Vanguard tax managed small cap) are up about 10% last I checked. I did, however, rebalance in to them at a very opportune time. But that's the beauty of rebalancing - I picked an asset class that had dropped to a low and that I needed to bring back up a few percent.
Click to expand...

Did you mean to say, "That is the beauty of market timing?" Is not that what rebalancing at a very opportune time is?

Ha
 
I have actually stayed slightly positive. OTOH, that is only because I keep dumping new cash into my account :D.

I also moved 5% of my portfolio last week from bonds to equities, and plan to move 15% more over the next three months (5% a month), with the plan to go from 50-50 to 70-30 right before the elections. While my rational mind tells me this will pay off in the long run, the irrational part of me is on edge.
 
haha said:
Did you mean to say, "That is the beauty of market timing?" Is not that what rebalancing at a very opportune time is?
Click to expand...

Nah, it is called rebalancing when I do it. I don't care what you call it when you do it! The time proved to be opportune only in hindsight, by the way.

I also "rebalanced" into international investments. That hasn't turned out so well. But it is about time to rebalance some more into international pretty soon.

Edited to add: I did "market time" into a financials ETF within a day of the low point. I will call that market timing since it does not fit into my asset allocation policy. Maybe 20% market timing and 80% dumb luck...
 
chinaco said:
Diversification! Most of the model portfolios (for small investors) that I studied that had some allocation to commodities in some way (through some sort of fund) only allocated 5%-10%.

If people stuck with that approach, they should not be hurt too much. But people who gambled big... are going to feel it.
Click to expand...

Quite true, but even that's a bit of a problem when that allocation is added at the top, as is surely the case for most. How many really had commodities as an asset class in their portfolio before the recent extreme run up?

Of course they're still much better off than those who run with all their eggs to the latest hot thing!
 
I've had a relatively big position in commodities funds (10-20% of portfolio depending on how you slice them), mostly accumulated starting 2003-2005. Probably could have sold some this year, but I'm an adamant buy-and-holder, plus don't need to be paying any extra taxes now while I'm still w*rking. I don't know much about the current speculation/bubble, but my long-term view FWIW is that commodities can only go up. Given the US public debt situation, plus growth across the globe, I see inflation+scarcity as facts of future life.
 
Ah, but the market can stay irrational longer than we can stay solvent. Or something like that..
 
With somewhere around 10% in PCRIX, I'm holding on for the diversification. I'm still heavily into cash (35%?) and still looking for a bottom. It may be timing at it's worst, but it helps me sleep at night.
 
Yeah I just came into a bunch of cash and I'm not thinking this is the time to put it into the market.

Not even into something like Wellesley Admiral. I notice 23% of its holdings are in financials, which are still leading the market down to triple-digit declines.
 
FUEGO said:
Nah, it is called rebalancing when I do it. I don't care what you call it when you do it! The time proved to be opportune only in hindsight, by the way.

I also "rebalanced" into international investments. That hasn't turned out so well. But it is about time to rebalance some more into international pretty soon.

Edited to add: I did "market time" into a financials ETF within a day of the low point. I will call that market timing since it does not fit into my asset allocation policy. Maybe 20% market timing and 80% dumb luck...
Click to expand...

After you rebalanced was your asset allocation the same as before you rebalanced. It certainly doesn't sound like it, which means a shift in asset classes which means .....

If looks like it and smells like it then it probably is it :D
 
For those looking for someone calling oil going down to 60 bucks about the time it was at 130, read John Hussman's site.His HSGRX is the bright spot in my portfolio along with the GIC's and cash. You may not like his style but his weekly commentary on Monday morning is a good read.
 
I made about the same call on this very web site for free a couple of months ago.

Anyone want to buy my newsletter yet? ;)
 
cute fuzzy bunny said:
I made about the same call on this very web site for free a couple of months ago.

Anyone want to buy my newsletter yet? ;)
Click to expand...

me, me, me!
I have been waiting since last year to add some commodities to my low correlation portfolio so I sure would love to know when to finally get in! When will we reach the bottom oh wise one? The check's on its way...;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

K
asset location and allocation
Replies
13
Views
894
Montecfo
M
R
Withdrawal Strategies
2 3 4
Replies
77
Views
9K
reneeh63
R
Tranquility Base
Borrowing Against Investment Portfolio For Home Purchase
Replies
15
Views
464
pb4uski
pb4uski
GravitySucks
Retire and Retire Again
Replies
5
Views
1K
USGrant1962
USGrant1962
M
leveraged risk parity portfolios
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
mathjak107
M

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom