LRAO said:
How do you figure out how much you can convert "up to the top of the 15% bracket"?
Assuming that you meet the initial conditions for a conversion, there are two ways.
1. The "Easy Button". Ask a tax preparer or a CPA to figure it out for you. They'll figure it out from Forms 1040 and 8606. Or, if you're a do-it-yourselfer,
2. Admittedly this is a method that only an engineer could enjoy. If your situation deviates from mine (e.g., collectibles sales or commodities trading or selling real estate or some unusual deduction) then my advice is worth what you paid for it.
Estimate your AGI for the year (including interest & non-qualified dividends) by filling out the front page of Form 1040. Subtract whatever's taxed separately (like your long-term cap gains, your 28% cap gains, & your qualified dividends). Subtract your deductions (or the standard deduction) and then subtract your exemption. Take the resulting number and subtract it from the top of the 15% bracket to see how much of a taxable portion of your IRA you can convert. We'll call this the "taxable amount", and let's say that it's $30K. (Hey, you have a big mortgage interest deduction.)
If you've made only deductible IRA contributions and never had to fill out Form 8606 in your entire life, then congratulations-- you're done! That taxable amount is the same as the conversion amount, so that's how much you can convert to stay within the 15% bracket.
If, like the rest of America's taxpayers, you've made non-deductible IRA contributions and have a basis in your conventional IRA, then you may want to push the limits. If that's the case then take a clean copy of Form 8606, a pencil, and (unless you do your sudokus in pen) a big eraser. Fill it out through line 7 using the IRA's basis (from your last Form 8606 plus this year's non-deductible contributions) and the latest value of all your conventional (non-Roth) IRAs.
Line 10, the non-taxable fraction of your IRA, is determined by dividing the Line 5 IRA basis by its Line 9 total current value. Let's say that fraction is 0.250, indicating that 25% of the amount of your IRA conversion is not subject to tax (and 75%
is subject to tax). The total amount of your conversion becomes the taxable amount divided by the value of (1 - non-taxable fraction) or (1 - 0.250). For a taxable amount of $30,000 your total amount converted would be $30K/(1 - 0.25) = $40,000.
This calculation assumes that your IRA is going to stay flat during the rest of the year. If it rises in value, more of your conversion will be subject to taxes and that may push you over the 15% line.
BTW Form 8606 lines 7 & 8 track other distributions or conversions that you've already made that year. I've assumed those numbers are "zero", but if they're not then you may want to consult a tax pro.
mathjak107 said:
just curious,,,how many people are actually in higher tax bracket retired then when they were working and earning a pay check?
not many i bet
My tax bracket when I'd have to take RMDs will be about the same tax bracket as my working years, but you're asking the wrong question.
When you're ER'd and not taking RMDs or SS, and maybe not even a pension, your tax bracket is about as low as it's ever going to get during your life. The time before those income streams start is the time to convert from a conventional IRA to a Roth. Once the RMDs start, no matter what bracket you're in, it's all too easy to lose SS to taxation. I'm not aware of any IRA conversion calculators that address this ER situation, and most of them don't even address the SS taxation issue.
mathjak107 said:
i could never see taxes being higher ,not income tax anyway....
why anyone would want to pay taxes now for a remote chance they may be higher when they arent working is not great odds in that direction in my opinion.....
I've been paying taxes since 1977 and I don't think that today's brackets have ever been lower.
But good luck with that, my friend. Gotta do your own math for your own situation.