explanade
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
- Joined
- May 10, 2008
- Messages
- 7,442
1) If you have a bond fund with holdings in more than one state and you choose more than one state in TT, it makes all the dividends from that fund taxable, at least for CA.
But actually, after doing some research, it appears that CA will tax all the dividends from a multi-state bond fund (such as VWIUX) unless at least 50% of that bond fund's holdings are from CA bonds.
So it may have calculated it correctly but TT should tell you the CA law/rule.
2) TT tells you that you will get a bigger tax benefit if you use the foreign taxes paid by funds as a tax credit rather than a tax deduction but the default appears to be to apply them to Schedule A as itemized deductions rather than tax credits.
Only later, it shows the option and the advice to take the credit.
3) The way it treats nondeductible IRA is ridiculous.
First the interview asks about the IRA basis as of 12/31/2012. Then it asks for your 2013 contributions.
In my case, I contributed in Feb 2013 for TY 2012 and contributed again in Dec 2013 for TY 2013 (followed by conversion of the tIRA to Roth about a week later).
Well TT thinks I have $6000 excess contribution for 2013.
They really need to have a table to enter your contributions each year, with the date of the contribution (to validate that it was made in time).
Googling around, I've seen other complaints on the turbotax.intuit.com site about how it handles this, particularly in cases where people are converting to ROTH.
One of the questions it asks is your tIRA balance on 12/31/2013. Well if you converted to ROTH in a given tax year, it's likely to be zero at the end of the year. Not sure how it uses this figure but it has a worksheet which should have more transparent fields for entering data. Like I said, I had to enter the two contributions that I made in CY 2013 in a single field (though it lets you break up the figure you enter).
But actually, after doing some research, it appears that CA will tax all the dividends from a multi-state bond fund (such as VWIUX) unless at least 50% of that bond fund's holdings are from CA bonds.
So it may have calculated it correctly but TT should tell you the CA law/rule.
2) TT tells you that you will get a bigger tax benefit if you use the foreign taxes paid by funds as a tax credit rather than a tax deduction but the default appears to be to apply them to Schedule A as itemized deductions rather than tax credits.
Only later, it shows the option and the advice to take the credit.
3) The way it treats nondeductible IRA is ridiculous.
First the interview asks about the IRA basis as of 12/31/2012. Then it asks for your 2013 contributions.
In my case, I contributed in Feb 2013 for TY 2012 and contributed again in Dec 2013 for TY 2013 (followed by conversion of the tIRA to Roth about a week later).
Well TT thinks I have $6000 excess contribution for 2013.
They really need to have a table to enter your contributions each year, with the date of the contribution (to validate that it was made in time).
Googling around, I've seen other complaints on the turbotax.intuit.com site about how it handles this, particularly in cases where people are converting to ROTH.
One of the questions it asks is your tIRA balance on 12/31/2013. Well if you converted to ROTH in a given tax year, it's likely to be zero at the end of the year. Not sure how it uses this figure but it has a worksheet which should have more transparent fields for entering data. Like I said, I had to enter the two contributions that I made in CY 2013 in a single field (though it lets you break up the figure you enter).