Motorhome purchase? Pros/Cons!

G

greenhm

Recycles dryer sheets
Joined
May 6, 2005
Messages
55
Ever owned a motorhome?

I cannot find ANY reason how a motorhome can save money. With the price of gas, repairs, maintenance, RV parks prices etc, it seems much cheaper to rent by the month in a location you want to visit.

Yet, I am drawn to owning one.

I love road trips, but what are the benefits or alternative to Motorhome ownership?
 
No I have never owned one. The DW thinks it would be fun. I have my doubts.

Think about buying a lightly used one. The depreciation on RV's will knock your socks off.

Alternatives: Take that big expensive RV payment and fly (or drive your car) somewhere and stay in a hotel. Just maybe you'll save money.
 
I idly looked into this and found that you probably would have to rent 12 or more times a year to come out ahead financially owning a home.  However, I have seen a place that will rent your motorhome on consignment while you are not using it, which could take away some of the financial pain.

The big difference between owning and renting is that you can be a lot more spontaneous about your trips if you own.  But you pay up for the privelege.
 
My ER in-laws are permanent travelers in a fifth wheel.
They definitely recommend truck/fifth wheel combo over a motorhome.
They mostly do dry-camping, meaning without hookups, which is frequently free or costs nominal amount of money (like Arizona state permit which is I believe $160 per year)
They have solar panels on the roof for electricity, but would run their small honda generator if they need air conditioning.
Internet over verizon cellphone, but they are considering a satellite, since they came down in price.
They have a mailbox and street address in South Dakota, since this is one of the most tax friendly states.
 
I'm kind of the same way...economically I simply can not justify owning a motorhome, yet I'm still attracted to the danged things! Have been, ever since I was a kid. Back then, my grandparents had a 1976 GMC crew cab pickup with a slide-in truck camper. They took me on lots of camping trips as a kid, and in the campgrounds I'd always admire the big Travcos, Winnebagos, Airstreams, and other rigs.

I envisioned being able to just drive your home anywhere, at a moment's notice, and just being free to explore the countryside at your own pace. But then I grew up, realized I'd have to work for a living, and just wouldn't have the time to enjoy a motorhome. Also, the reality of being 6'3" really sunk in. I have to duck under the roof a/c unit of most motorhomes, and I just feel hemmed in. And most of them have a really horrible driving position. It's like driving a bus.

Still, I want one! I'd definitely go used though, because they do take a steep depreciation hit. I remember in 2000 I looked at a 32 foot or so motorhome that was 10 years old, on a dealer's lot. It was really nice, low mileage, and well-equipped. I think they wanted $20K for it, and I'm sure they would've bargained. I'm sure a brand-new 32 foot Class-A motorhome would run you close to $100K for a halfway decent one, and the really nice, quality ones can easily top $500K. Especially if you get into bus-based ones.

Also in 2000, I almost bought a 1974 Travco 220 (Class-A motorhome, but in a tidy 22' length). Now that might be going back TOO far, but it had a rebuilt Industrial 440, and the guy only wanted $2900 for it! :D
 
A nice used one has crossed my path again, and though I am not ready for one yet, the price is quite nice.

Having it sit for most of a year has gotta hurt, and I need to convince myself that other deals will come around, if/when I/we decide to give it a try.

We have done much rough/hobo travel in the past, and it can get abit smelly after a week or so, and a nice RV would sure feel good.

But then, I figure, when we road/hobo travel, we could hotel it a couple times a week, but then it works out to ($100 x 2 days / week) x 4 weeks a month = $800 a month for a shower and warm bed a couple times a week. Ouch. But then, thats what a RV park would cost, or monthly rate apartment, or RV tranny repair.

The RV thing is ONLY good in North America also. It won't help off shore or south of Mexico. Basically, Canada, US and Mexico.

oh, the delemma
 
We recently bought an old class C motorhome that's in good shape. The guy we bought it from was a fanatic about maintaining it, so hopefully, our repairs won't be as much.

Can it be cost justified?  I don't think so. However, in our situation, there were a few things that made it easier:

We have 3 drivers in our family because our oldest daughter is driving now. However, we only have 2 cars and the motor home. I work at home and don't do much driving, but in a pinch, I can drive the motorhome if need be, so instead of paying for a 3rd car, we pay for the motorhome.

Surprisingly, the cost to insure the motorhome is cheap if you go through a company that specializes in motorhome insurance.

But like you said, the real reason we bought one is that we just wanted one.
 
John L, that was one of my justifications for the little Travco I was interested in. I figured that I could drive it on occasion as a spare vehicle, and something 22 feet long wouldn't be TOO cumbersome! I have a 1979 Chrysler that's 18 1/2 feet long, so how much worse could it be? :D

I imagine an industrial 440 moving 4+ tons of motorhome would make the Chrysler look downright economical, though. :-\
 
In 1986 I bought a 1976 Class C RV for a very low price. I kept it for 12 years and sold it for a very, very low price. In that time I only averaged 2K miles a year. It did get some use but mostly we had an annual trip up the California coast and a few weekends to nearby beach spots. One trip to near by Mexico. But my son born just after getting it and it was nice to have a heater, stove and bathroom. The biggest problem was 9 MPG and it was possible but difficult to use as a third car.

Now we have a 1985 VW Westfalia camper. Better MPG and much easier to drive, we are putting more like 4K miles a year on it but it gets used as a van to cart things from Home Depot and it will carry my 16 year old Mohawk haired rock drummer son's drums easily. He really wants this van for his own.

If you are going to use an RV for a second or third car then I would recommend a Class B unit.

My in laws full timed in a 30 something 5th wheel and they had other large RVs in different days. The 5th wheel is great for extended travel although a Class A with tow car would probably work as well. Throw in enough money and you can have an RV with all modern comforts. They saved money only in the sense that they did not have a house through this period. It was a good life style choice for them. I would expect there are ways to economize with an RV, staying at free sites, cooking your own food but it is designed for recreation more than economy.
 
We bought a '84 mini-Winnie a couple of years ago.  DW & I use it 8 to 12 times a year.  Paid about 8K for it and have replaced the fridge and A/C over the years.  We took it to the tip of Nova Scotia (Cape Breton) on a 21 day trip one year.  Fabulous!
We also use it to go to concerts, football games and bluegrass festivals.  It's real convenient to have a refrigerator and bathroom before and after the event.  Just crank the A/C and some tunes and sip one while the traffic clears...
Our Goldens like it too and get all excited when they see us packin' for a "Road Trip!"
 
Renman:

That's about what I would like to pay for a RV.

My question for you is - With an older RV are you concerned about having mechanical problems if you took it somewhere remotely located and sparsely (if at all) populated, ie. - away from it all ?

What is your contingency plan in such a situation ?
 
yakers said:
He really wants this van for his own.
Click to expand...
Sounds like a cheap & excellent solution to the baby boomerang problem!
 
MasterBlaster said:
Renman:

That's about what I would like to pay for a RV.

My question for you is - With an older RV are you concerned about having mechanical problems if you took it somewhere remotely located and sparsely (if at all) populated, ie. - away from it all ?

What is your contingency plan in such a situation ?
Click to expand...

Hmmm, if you look at the vagabonders supreme link, he seems not to have any real problems running around in remote arreas in an older RV. I suppose that its like any vehicle: maintain it well and you are much less likely to have problems.
 
gReeNy said:
Ever owned a motorhome?
I love road trips, but what are the benefits or alternative to Motorhome ownership?
Click to expand...
gReeNy
We took the plunge and made our first RV purchase last Spring.  Went to many many RV shows, read all the boards (rv.net is a great resource) and rented one for a vacation.  Ended up with a 29' Itasca gasser.

You can find some economics that support rving being a less expensive form of traveling when your family size gets over 4 and you need multiple motel rooms and the dining racks up some significant bill.

Biggest single expense in any RV is the depreciation--you pay it, no matter if it is in your driveway or on the road--same as a boat when you do not use it.

Like a boat, RVing is a lifestyle choice.  It offers independence, convenience, a form of security in case of emergencies (move in when you loose power or have things such as hurricanes, etc), and many RVers claim as one the greatest benefits over hotels, they know who was in their bed last. And you have all your stuff where you want and never have to unpack and repack.  Depending on your travel plans, you can live for less than $40k/yr pretty easily--lots of RV sites out there have living budgets.

To your later question, yes you can always find a deal.  Key is to really know what your requirements are and to stay focused on those units and try to not get caught buying a unit because the deal is "so good".  You will just end up not haing a good experience.    Buy new only if you can stand the depreciation.  Also watch out for units that have too low of mileage--sitting is really tough on the mechanical side of a RV.  Ideally, not less than 4k/year.  Tires are big cost items and they typically aged out before they wear out.  Any tire over 4 years old is considered ready for replacement regardless of tread--so add 250/tire to the price.
PM me if I can be of any assistance
nwsteve
 
Now we have a 1985 VW Westfalia camper. Better MPG and much easier to drive, we are putting more like 4K miles a year on it but it gets used as a van to cart things from Home Depot and it will carry my 16 year old Mohawk haired rock drummer son's drums easily. He really wants this van for his own.
Click to expand...

Hey Yakers, I thought a VW camper van would be a wise choice also, as it is cheaper on gas, smaller to get about, but, I have always been under the assumption that they are not very reliable. I'd love your comments and experiences with one of these...
 
My inlaws have a huge diesel pusher. Basically their rationale is they take lots (and I mean LOTS) of trips in california, nevada and new mexico to visit family and friends. They want to take a lot of their stuff, and they usually take kids and grandkids with them. I still doubt they're saving any money or seeing any convenience after you take out the aggravations of maintaining and paying for the thing.

Consider it a vacation home on wheels. If you have the money, will get some enjoyment out of it, and the enjoyment wont be negated by the associated aggravation, get it. But there arent many cost savings or benefits analyses that hold water.
 
I thought a VW camper van would be a wise choice also, as it is cheaper on gas, smaller to get about, but, I have always been under the assumption that they are not very reliable. I'd love your comments and experiences with one of these...
Click to expand...

I've got a VW camper and have used it quite a bit...including to Alaska and back from Arizona. We love it for camping, with some major caveats.

Strengths:
>Good gas mileage
>small, and drive around and park easily
>efficient interior design, with stove, sink, fridge, sleeping for 4 (if very friendly), etc.

Weaknesses:
>No toilet. Not a problem in established campgrounds, obviously.
>AC is weak, something an Arizonan is sensitive to.
>VW reliability...meaning I hope that you are an amateur mechanic. It's quite a contrast compared to, for example, owning a Toyota. I seem to always have something that needs fixing or is on the edge of repair, although we did go to Alaska and back (10k miles) with only the need for an oil change and one stop on an Alaskan beach (with brisk wind to dispel mosquitoes) to tighten a v-belt.
 
gReeNy said:
Hey Yakers, I thought a VW camper van would be a wise choice also, as it is cheaper on gas, smaller to get about, but, I have always been under the assumption that they are not very reliable. I'd love your comments and experiences with one of these...
Click to expand...

Well, I have had the VW camper for about 5 years now. At first I had some problems with the original VW mechanicals. To "solve" this I had a Subaru engine installed. It is more reliable and more powerful and smog legal in California. The original wiring is still a weakness left over from the VW design and it came with an aftermarket alarm which keeps the remote in my hand whenever a door is openned, whether it has been turned on or not it seems to activate. Life with an old, odd vehicel.
But the positive sides are substantial. It camping kit is efficient. Hauls my wife & I & our younger son around whenever we want. It does not have the AC currently working but we have added a porta potty for use at remore camping sites. My son badly wants it and my wife loves it. They hated the Class C. It is very drivable. When we had a accident in 04 that killed our car we did not hesitate to take it on a 1k mi round trip drive. Its interior is cavernous, it is not a "mini" van, it is full sized. It is also an emotional thing, we just love it. It came with the Free Tibet sticker, which was standard on the 85 and optional on later models ;)
 
I have owned 2 motorhomes and now own a truck and trailer. We are lucky to be able to use them for 6 or 7 trips per year. When I was younger with little children we ran a little class C Winnie into the ground going on family vacations. Looking back my only regret is not spending more time and money on trips with the family. I was able to earn more money but those days are gone now.

I love RVing and will always try to keep some type of an RV going, it is not something you do to save money. It is a hobby and/or a lifestyle. Some people RV fulltime and are able to live economically, but if you factor in the depreciation of their rigs vs. the appreciation of real property they are not coming out ahead. Regardless of the price there is nothing I enjoy more than a sunset by the Lake/River/Sea/Mountains of my choice while sleeping in my own little rolling home.

Rent first, try a week at a time for a couple of trips. You will know pretty quickly if you are an RV or a hotel person. I know plenty of both and everyone has valid reasons for their decision.

JP
 
plattj1 said:
I have owned 2 motorhomes and now own a truck and trailer. We are lucky to be able to use them for 6 or 7 trips per year. When I was younger with little children we ran a little class C Winnie into the ground going on family vacations. Looking back my only regret is not spending more time and money on trips with the family. I was able to earn more money but those days are gone now.

I love RVing and will always try to keep some type of an RV going, it is not something you do to save money. It is a hobby and/or a lifestyle. Some people RV fulltime and are able to live economically, but if you factor in the depreciation of their rigs vs. the appreciation of real property they are not coming out ahead. Regardless of the price there is nothing I enjoy more than a sunset by the Lake/River/Sea/Mountains of my choice while sleeping in my own little rolling home.

Rent first, try a week at a time for a couple of trips. You will know pretty quickly if you are an RV or a hotel person. I know plenty of both and everyone has valid reasons for their decision.

JP
Click to expand...

How was it RVing with kids? Claustraphobic at all? I think I have seen Class C floorplans that have a bed over the cab (for the kids) and another bed that could be closed off from the rest of the cabin.
 
The VW campervan does seem like a great comprimise... but is there anything out there that compares... perhaps made by toyota etc.

I see that you can rent these little 4 cyl campers in Australia and parts of Europe. They are nothing that I have seen here in North America. Anyone know or have any experiences with these also?
 
gReeNy said:
The VW campervan does seem like a great comprimise... but is there anything out there that compares... perhaps made by toyota etc.

I see that you can rent these little 4 cyl campers in Australia and parts of Europe. They are nothing that I have seen here in North America. Anyone know or have any experiences with these also?
Click to expand...

You can rent VW campers in Hawaii, maybe some other parts of the US (Berkley?). If you want to rent something n that size check the usual RV rental places and ask if they have Class B typr RVs for rent.

As to space for camping with kids, we only had two kids with enough time between them that we only camped with one at a time. The Class C had lots of room, and even the VW camper had "enough". Its part of the experience to be close. What seems like a pain at the time, being cooped up in a storm, can be remembered fondly.(Although I do remember one wind storm in the desert that kept me up all night and I still remember unfondly.) Most of yur time is spent outside the camper, at least the way we did it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N
Wisdom needed- Downsizing Renting vs Buying
Replies
15
Views
794
meleana
M
R
Factoring opportunity cost into major purchases?
2 3
Replies
57
Views
3K
TickTock
T
street
Option offer for land purchase
Replies
22
Views
1K
38Chevy454
38Chevy454
T
Retired 10 years today!
Replies
18
Views
1K
Koolau
Koolau
S
Year 0 update
Replies
9
Views
1K
Calico
Calico

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom