frayne
Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
I copied this from another forum and thought it was worth sharing.
"Getting Rich: The Poor Man's Guide" Community Watch
stinger96 | 05-19-06| 07:17 PM| Total Replies: 8
I received this today by email and had to reply via email. It seemed like such a disservice to the general public, especially since I usually agree with John Stossel's segments on 20/20. I'll post any reply I receive. I am an active reader (ok lurker) here and have read all the recommended books and more. Great site and thanks to the active participants. His email is in quotes below with my response following it.
"Hello.
This week's "20/20" is an hour we call "Getting Rich: The Poor Man's Guide."
Robert Kiyosaki, author of the best selling "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" empire, works with three wannabe entrepreneurs to see if he can show them how to make money.
Financial expert David Bach discusses the theme of his new book, "The Automatic Millionaire: Homeowner."
Billionaire parents can give their kids everything but how do they instill drive? Elizabeth Vargas sits down with Ivanka and Don Trump, Donald Trump's two older children, to talk about what their parents did right.
Is the brain of a millionaire entrepreneur different from the brain of a middle manager? Dr. Brian Knutson, one of few researchers in the new field of neuro-finance, is working on that.
Also you'll meet Farrah Gray, a 21-year-old entrepreneur who made his first million at age 14."
Hey John,
I love your work and first book. I usually agree with you as I am a libertarian. I have to take issue with you using 20/20 to promote a documented liar and scam artist such as Robert Kiyosaki to show people how to "get rich". http://johntreed.com/Kiyosaki.html And as for David Bach, isn't it a little late to be promoting the "hot thing" (real estate) right now? This is called "Financial Porn" (nice to look at but no redeeming value).
Why not have a serious finance program that would help the average individual outperform 95% of the current population while avoiding the Wall Street rip off? A show that exposes myths of finance that the industry puts out, such as:
1) Active funds can outperform their respective indices over the long term
2) Fund managers add value
3) Brokers have your best interest at heart
4) Individuals can outperform the market through smart stock picking
5) Young individuals have no need to hold bonds or bond mutual funds
6) It is possible to time the stock market
7) Morningstar Five Star Rated mutual funds outperform lower-rated funds going forward
8) Real estate has been a good long-term investment
9) Expense Ratios do not matter if you have a good fund
10) Diversification is not defined by holding 10-30 stocks
I realize these topics are over the head of the common man and perhaps not appropriate for a short program with a wide audience. However, I am sure they could be reworked to better suit the everyday Joe and would certainly do him more justice. At the very least it will get people thinking a bit more about their finances.
This would truly help people and it is based on academic finance studies--not unlike your usual logical way of presenting information backed up by research rather than slick marketing. How about including individuals such as John Bogle (founder of Vanguard); academics (some Nobel Prize winners) such as Fama, French, Thaler, William Sharpe, Harry Markowitz, and Burton Malkiel; and credible writers such as William Bernstein, Larry Swedroe, Jonathan Clements (WSJ) and Rick Ferri. A great resource on the internet is found at http://www.diehards.org.
Thanks for all your past and continued great work.
"Getting Rich: The Poor Man's Guide" Community Watch
stinger96 | 05-19-06| 07:17 PM| Total Replies: 8
I received this today by email and had to reply via email. It seemed like such a disservice to the general public, especially since I usually agree with John Stossel's segments on 20/20. I'll post any reply I receive. I am an active reader (ok lurker) here and have read all the recommended books and more. Great site and thanks to the active participants. His email is in quotes below with my response following it.
"Hello.
This week's "20/20" is an hour we call "Getting Rich: The Poor Man's Guide."
Robert Kiyosaki, author of the best selling "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" empire, works with three wannabe entrepreneurs to see if he can show them how to make money.
Financial expert David Bach discusses the theme of his new book, "The Automatic Millionaire: Homeowner."
Billionaire parents can give their kids everything but how do they instill drive? Elizabeth Vargas sits down with Ivanka and Don Trump, Donald Trump's two older children, to talk about what their parents did right.
Is the brain of a millionaire entrepreneur different from the brain of a middle manager? Dr. Brian Knutson, one of few researchers in the new field of neuro-finance, is working on that.
Also you'll meet Farrah Gray, a 21-year-old entrepreneur who made his first million at age 14."
Hey John,
I love your work and first book. I usually agree with you as I am a libertarian. I have to take issue with you using 20/20 to promote a documented liar and scam artist such as Robert Kiyosaki to show people how to "get rich". http://johntreed.com/Kiyosaki.html And as for David Bach, isn't it a little late to be promoting the "hot thing" (real estate) right now? This is called "Financial Porn" (nice to look at but no redeeming value).
Why not have a serious finance program that would help the average individual outperform 95% of the current population while avoiding the Wall Street rip off? A show that exposes myths of finance that the industry puts out, such as:
1) Active funds can outperform their respective indices over the long term
2) Fund managers add value
3) Brokers have your best interest at heart
4) Individuals can outperform the market through smart stock picking
5) Young individuals have no need to hold bonds or bond mutual funds
6) It is possible to time the stock market
7) Morningstar Five Star Rated mutual funds outperform lower-rated funds going forward
8) Real estate has been a good long-term investment
9) Expense Ratios do not matter if you have a good fund
10) Diversification is not defined by holding 10-30 stocks
I realize these topics are over the head of the common man and perhaps not appropriate for a short program with a wide audience. However, I am sure they could be reworked to better suit the everyday Joe and would certainly do him more justice. At the very least it will get people thinking a bit more about their finances.
This would truly help people and it is based on academic finance studies--not unlike your usual logical way of presenting information backed up by research rather than slick marketing. How about including individuals such as John Bogle (founder of Vanguard); academics (some Nobel Prize winners) such as Fama, French, Thaler, William Sharpe, Harry Markowitz, and Burton Malkiel; and credible writers such as William Bernstein, Larry Swedroe, Jonathan Clements (WSJ) and Rick Ferri. A great resource on the internet is found at http://www.diehards.org.
Thanks for all your past and continued great work.