Katsmeow
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2009
- Messages
- 5,308
Has anyone used a Precor Elliptical, particularly, but not necessarily, the EFX 5.33 or 5.37?
I am interested in any feedback on the motion of a Precor Elliptical. I am trying to compare it to other brands (the other elliptical I'm considering is the Life Fitness X1 or X3).
The Precor that I'm looking at (the 5.37 which I have an opportunity to buy at a very discounted price), has an incline that goes from 15% to 40%. That is, it is never flat. It has a rear drive and the wheels move in a track. So, you move in an ellipse, but you go up and down a bit more than in the Life Fitness. The Life Fitness is a much flatter motion.
I really liked the Precor when I tried it out but I curious if anyone has tried it for any length of time and whether or not you had any knee problems from it.
Due to my lack of cartilage in my knee cap, my orthopedic surgeon has suggested that instead of me walking in my hilly neighborhood that I swim, cycle or use an elliptical. I prefer to do a weight bearing exercise so am looking at the ellipticals.
My biggest fear is to buy this elliptical and then find out after a month or two that my knee can't tolerate it. It is a very expensive purchase to then have to sell it. But, if I don't buy this one now, I will not buy a Precor as the undiscounted price is way more than I would ordinarily spend.
I liked the Life Fitness, but it is not as well made and it has a much flatter motion and doesn't have the incline. With the Precor you change the incline in order to focus on different muscles in the leg. I liked that.
I'm leaning toward the Precor, but am curious if anyone with knee problems has used a Precor. Most of the Precors have a similar incline so I would be interested in any experience with a Precor, even using one in a gym.
I am interested in any feedback on the motion of a Precor Elliptical. I am trying to compare it to other brands (the other elliptical I'm considering is the Life Fitness X1 or X3).
The Precor that I'm looking at (the 5.37 which I have an opportunity to buy at a very discounted price), has an incline that goes from 15% to 40%. That is, it is never flat. It has a rear drive and the wheels move in a track. So, you move in an ellipse, but you go up and down a bit more than in the Life Fitness. The Life Fitness is a much flatter motion.
I really liked the Precor when I tried it out but I curious if anyone has tried it for any length of time and whether or not you had any knee problems from it.
Due to my lack of cartilage in my knee cap, my orthopedic surgeon has suggested that instead of me walking in my hilly neighborhood that I swim, cycle or use an elliptical. I prefer to do a weight bearing exercise so am looking at the ellipticals.
My biggest fear is to buy this elliptical and then find out after a month or two that my knee can't tolerate it. It is a very expensive purchase to then have to sell it. But, if I don't buy this one now, I will not buy a Precor as the undiscounted price is way more than I would ordinarily spend.
I liked the Life Fitness, but it is not as well made and it has a much flatter motion and doesn't have the incline. With the Precor you change the incline in order to focus on different muscles in the leg. I liked that.
I'm leaning toward the Precor, but am curious if anyone with knee problems has used a Precor. Most of the Precors have a similar incline so I would be interested in any experience with a Precor, even using one in a gym.