Worse: Sugar or Salt?

Regarding salt & sugar, I just aim for the "middle of the road". If I had a real blood pressure problem I'd be inclined to keep the salt to a minimum ... just in case.

But I do like my salt and sodium and take great pleasure in indulging moderately. :)
 
This, from the Arizona Dept. of Health Services - Eat Less Salt - The Difference Between Salt and Sodium

It kind of contradicts the last post on salt vs. sodium. I'm definitely no chemist, so I may be mis-interpreting things. I always thought there was a very close relationship between salt & sodium.

Salt is one source of sodium, but not the only source. In baked goods in particular, you'll find baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) and baking powder (30% sodium bicarbonate, 5-12% monocalcium phosphate, and 21-26% sodium aluminium sulfate.)

Both are great sources of sodium. That Panera Wild Blueberry scone? 900 mg of sodium, over half the recommended sodium intake for folks over 50. (Most scone mixes rely on baking powder to rise.)
 
Table salt is made of equal proportions of sodium and chlorine, both of which are very poisonous. I wish a chemist would explain why we are supposed to worry about the sodium, but not the chlorine. ;)

Amethyst


Table salt is sodium ion and chloride ion. Both are found in our body. Chloride ion is not chlorine gas, which is poisonous, because when chlorine gas is combined with water (as in our lungs), it reacts and turns into hypochlorite and hydrochloride acid. The acid damages lung tissue.

Sodium as an element is not readily found in nature, and when combined with water, produced sodium hydroxide and hydrogen gas and heat (in other words, it explodes).

However, these elements exist in ionized form and are crucial for cell functioning, along with potassium, calcium, magnesium and others ions.

We need a certain amount of sodium, potassium, and chloride ions as well as a pH of 7.4 in for our body and its cells to function . The 0.9% saline solution described earlier is actually too much sodium. It is helpful in shock and dehydration as it can quickly improve blood pressure. But if your problem is congestive heart failure or high blood pressure, it can make the problem worse.

Our average sodium intake per day is over 3 grams. (Too much!) It should be less than two grams. Table salt is sodium chloride. Part of its mass comes from the sodium, part from the chloride. The atomic wt of chloride is the heavier of the two ions, therefore 6 gm of table salt is about 2.3 gm of sodium ion and about 3.6 gm of chloride ion.

Hope you don't mind the mini lecture. I'm a biochemistry major and physician.


Sent from my iPhone using Early Retirement Forum
 
Not only do I not "mind" it, I appreciate it very much. I enjoy learning about scientific topics - especially those with immediate practical value.

Amethyst

Hope you don't mind the mini lecture. I'm a biochemistry major and physician.


Sent from my iPhone using Early Retirement Forum
 
Not only do I not "mind" it, I appreciate it very much. I enjoy learning about scientific topics - especially those with immediate practical value.

Amethyst

Same here, it's good to hear this stuff explained credibly.

My doc told me I have low sodium (I assume he meant low sodium chloride) but didn't seem concerned or suggest I do anything about it so I don't restrain myself with the salt shaker.
 
Salt vs Sugar? Lets get ready to Rumble!

I bought into the low salt thing about 20 years ago and avoided salt. Developed a variety of aches and pains that were resolved when I added salt to my diet. Happened several times. Salt is an important nutrient so I consume it in moderation. As I eat few processed foods, I freely salt my steaks, corn and cantaloupe.

Sugar is a broad term that needs to be broken down.
Lactose is a sugar from milk and is problematic to those allergic to it (like me). I avoid milk and normal ice cream, but freely consume cheese and yogurt.

Glucose is a sugar that is processed in most (if not all) cells of the body. Its a fine nutrient until you consume too much. (Insulin spike, obesity and all that)

Fructose is the bad player for the human body. It is damn near a poison... which is why it is only processed in the liver (just like alcohol). The by products of Fructose consumption are triglycerides and SDLDL... which are major contributors to heart disease.

My diet is of the high fat- low carb variety. When I am active, I don't hesitate to eat corn and potatoes (glucose based starches). I try to keep my daily fructose consumption below 10gms daily.

So, Salt vs Sugar is a tie... Fructose gets the TKO for the win!
 
.....
Our average sodium intake per day is over 3 grams. (Too much!) It should be less than two grams. Table salt is sodium chloride. Part of its mass comes from the sodium, part from the chloride. The atomic wt of chloride is the heavier of the two ions, therefore 6 gm of table salt is about 2.3 gm of sodium ion and about 3.6 gm of chloride ion.

Hope you don't mind the mini lecture. I'm a biochemistry major and physician.


Sent from my iPhone using Early Retirement Forum

Thanks for the explanation.

I found a converter to figure rough volume for table salt. According to that 6 grams is roughly equal to .35 Tablespoon or 1.05 teaspoon.

That is a picture I can understand.

THe curious question is why when people are cautioned on too much sodium, the story is not presented in total salt volume? Most folks are clueless about sodium and chloride ratios in tablesalt. I know I was until read the previously quoted discussion and EastWestGal's description.

Table salt amounts converter | Convert to units and culinary measures.
 
Fructose is the bad player for the human body.

I'm sure you know this, but many don't. The evil and ubiquitous High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) is very similar to common table sugar.

Table sugar (sucrose) is 50% glucose and 50% fructose.

HFCS has some water in it, but is mainly a combination of the same two sugars. The most common formulation is HFCS 55, which is 55% fructose and 42% glucose. The other most common type is HFCS 42, which is 42% fructose and 53% glucose.

So there really isn't a big different between sugar and HFCS.

I'm another fan of the LCHF diet, so I would agree that large amounts of any sugar are more harmful than most common nutrients, but it's helpful to know what you're actually eating.
 
Salt is needed by your body to produce stomach acid and if the acid is not strong enough you will get acid reflux. Anti-acids destroy the digestion system and also the acid inhibitors. if you take them for a time you will be B12 deficient. Salt you food to taste.
 
...
I found a converter to figure rough volume for table salt. According to that 6 grams is roughly equal to .35 Tablespoon or 1.05 teaspoon.

That is a picture I can understand.

THe curious question is why when people are cautioned on too much sodium, the story is not presented in total salt volume? Most folks are clueless about sodium and chloride ratios in tablesalt. I know I was until read the previously quoted discussion and EastWestGal's description.
...
Good example that I might even remember -- 1 teaspoon of salt is the max. I guess the emphasis on "sodium" is because that is what is on labeled packages (not salt equivalents).

But when I lightly salt my food I would never be putting anything like 1 teaspoon on the food even in all 3 daily meals. But there is all those sodium atoms added in prep and naturally occurring I guess. For instance, I've been putting some salted mixed nuts in my morning cereal, only a small amount though.
 
So what is a good substitute for one's coffee? Brown sugar? Honey?

Don't get trapped into the good sugar/bad sugar game. Use whatever you like (personally, I put Splenda in my coffee).

Honey is essentially the same kind of sugar as table sugar (glucose and fructose in equal parts). Brown sugar is usually just table sugar with molasses added.
 
Thanks, I'll probably stick with the moderate amount of white sugar I use. I'm not in any high risk group as I eat very moderate healthy stuff and am not overweight and exercise like a fiend. :)
 
>> So there really isn't a big different between sugar and HFCS.

That's why I specifically differentiate sugar, glucose, fructose and lactose (common dietary sugars).

Its also why I avoid sugar and HFCS.

What's interesting is the fructose in HFCS is made from glucose... specifically to create a sweetener with a better insulin response. In some respects, HFCS is healthier than table sugar. Sweeter and small insulin spike. Somewhat better for people with diabetes and obesity problems.

But, fructose is a bad player because of CVD. So, I have learned to live without the sugar of any kind. For instance, My chocolate bar is the 100% cocoa Ghiradeli baking bar. I have a 1/4 bar every day. 100% cocoa and all fat. Recommended!
 
I think I can feel excess sugar in my body as I eat the stuff in chocolates and other sweets. At some point I just don't want any more. Usually I can stop.
 
>> So what is a good substitute for one's coffee? Brown sugar? Honey?

Espresso... Straight up!

If you must add something, try fat. Half and Half or heavy cream might work. It will work once you adapt to it.

Honey and agave are like HFCS with 55% fructose. Brown Sugar is just less processed but still 50-50 like table sugar.

Glucose is a sweetener... Its just not very sweet, so you need a lot of it.
 
Thanks, I'll probably stick with the moderate amount of white sugar I use. I'm not in any high risk group as I eat very moderate healthy stuff and am not overweight and exercise like a fiend. :)

The common metrics used today are pretty useless. Total cholesterol is meaningless. LDL and HDL are also not useful predictors for CVD.

The best info available today involves APO-B and the LDL composition. Just as Total Cholesterol is composed of TG, LDL and HDL, it turns out that LDL is composed of SD-LDL and Large Buoyant LDL.

SD-LDL is the bad actor here and yes, its presence(quantity) is influenced by fructose.

My brother is like you... not in a risk group, is an exercise fiend and is very fit. But he eats a lot of sugar and has been watching the plaque grow in his arteries for several years.

He has cut back on the sugar consumption and seen improvements in his lipid profile, but he just cannot reduce his sugar consumption to where it needs to be.
 
Good example that I might even remember -- 1 teaspoon of salt is the max. I guess the emphasis on "sodium" is because that is what is on labeled packages (not salt equivalents).

But when I lightly salt my food I would never be putting anything like 1 teaspoon on the food even in all 3 daily meals. But there is all those sodium atoms added in prep and naturally occurring I guess. For instance, I've been putting some salted mixed nuts in my morning cereal, only a small amount though.

I got to the point that I was putting 1/2 tsp salt each morning in my oats! I just kept adding more as my palate got used to it. I no longer add salt but use ground white pepper which seems to do the trick for me. I also add spices to pretty much everything. It is amazing how fast you get accustomed to salt and need more.
 
o why are we not advise to eat six grams of salt a day? I have no idea.
I can tell you, and it is very simple. It is thought that the sodium ion, not the chloride ion is the miscreant in high BP, congestive heart failure, etc. There are sources of sodium other than salt in the diet-MSG, baking soda, etc.

Also, every processed food in the united states has a label which states how much sodium is in the product, per ounce or cup or whatever. So if a person can read and use a calculator or do simple arithmetic, they can control their sodium intake.

It has become very fashionable among "alternative" medical purveyors to recommend lots of salt, and there are certainly situations where this is important, and people to whom this advice is perhaps good or at least not harmful. But years of research and clinical experience have shown that overall, in large populations, blood pressure is proportional to sodium intake. If your grandma has a bit of congestive heart failure, eating a dill pickle or a ham sandwich can put her right back in the ER muy pronto.

Ha
 
Thanks for the comment, Ha.

Continuing with my curiosity of salt and the ingredients of it, particularly interested in how much is metabolized and how much is retained, did some more internet chasing and found the following:

During a Russian study of diet for a Martian mission simulation, where salt intake is highly controlled by the pre packaged food system, they found that the sodium component is stored, seemingly much of it in the skin. AND how much of it is dumped in urine.

The most interesting finding is that sodium levels in the body are cycling on a 7 day and monthly schedule. Thus debunking the conventional long held science of sodium levels in the body are directly related to salt and or sodium intake on a daily bases.

Martian metabolism: The rise and fall of salt - Ezine - spectroscopyNOW.com

"
Titze and his colleagues organized the food for the mission, which would all be consumed and collected their urine each day. The team studied twelve men: six for the full 105-day phase of the program, and six for the first 205 days of the 520-day phase.
"It was the participants’ stamina to precisely adhere to the daily menu plans and to accurately collect their urine for months that allowed scientific discovery," Titze explains. This allowed them to reveal that 95 percent of the ingested salt was excreted in the urine, but not on a daily basis. Instead, at constant salt intake, sodium excretion fluctuated with a weekly rhythm, resulting in sodium storage. The levels of the hormones aldosterone (a regulator of sodium excretion) and cortisol (no known major role in sodium balance but a well-known stress hormone) also fluctuated weekly."

"Cyclic sodium


Titze and colleagues also found that total body sodium levels fluctuated on monthly and longer cycles, with this longer-term storage process seemingly independent of salt intake and not linked to weight gain that would be associated with water retention. The results have one rather immediate implication for medical research and diagnostics: they suggest that current medical practice, which utilises 24-hour urine samples to determine salt intake, might paint a wholly inaccurate picture of a person's salt balance.
"We understand now that there are 7-day and monthly sodium clocks that are ticking, so a one-day snapshot shouldn't be used to determine salt intake," Titze asserts. The team suspects that the same genes that control our circadian rhythms, the so-called body clock may also underpin the sodium storage and release cycles. "We find these long rhythms of sodium storage in the body particularly intriguing," Titze explains. "The observations open up entirely new avenues for research." "

Edit Add: The other interesting bit, though not expressed in this research, is that most likely all function of the body are controlled by hormones. So my wild a$$ guess is that in case hormones are haywire, everything else will be off kilter. Now onto the magic of endocrinology. But I am too old to start medical school now ;)
 
Last edited:
So what is a good substitute for one's coffee? Brown sugar? Honey?

I have heard that stevia is the lesser of the evils when it comes to sweeteners. But there is no universal agreement. I try to limit the amount of all kinds of sweeteners.
 
Another bit of info on salt. I do not have subscription so only abstract is read.

From Long Term Space Flight Simulation.
"
Highlights


  • Increased salt intake lowers urinary aldosterone but increases cortisol excretion
  • At constant salt intake, urinary Na+ excretion exhibits a circaseptan pattern
  • Total body Na+ exhibits a far-longer infradian rhythm, not related to body water
  • Na+ can be stored in the body independent of water or blood pressure
http://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/abstract/S1550-4131(12)00491-3
 
Stop arguing. It seems that in Nigeria they saved many Ebola victims by giving them a hydration solution made up of salt and sugar. Apparently, their success rate was about two out of three victims. Not bad. Nigeria has now been declared Ebola free.

Water laced with salt and sugar, and gallons of the nasty-tasting stuff. Doctors who survived Ebola in Nigeria credited heavy doses of fluids with saving their lives as the World Health Organization declared the country Ebola-free Monday,

Hydration helps Nigeria beat Ebola outbreak | Dallas Morning News
http://www.dallasnews.com/news/metro/20141020-hydration-helps-nigeria-beat-ebola-outbreak.ece
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom