Anti-piracy on a cruise ship

omni550

Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
Joined
Mar 7, 2004
Messages
3,433
I just got back from a 15-day cruise with my German cousins in the Middle East on a German cruise line (Mein Schiff 4). Ship stopped at Dubai, Oman, Jordan, Egypt, Cyprus, and Crete.

We had 6 sea days from Muscat, Oman to Aqaba, Jordan, rounding the Arabian Peninsula.

About the 2nd or 3rd sea day, I noticed a guy about 40-years-old in a black golf shirt with "Operation Safe Haven" stitched on it having a meal in the cafeteria by himself. It didn't dawn on me until later that he was likely an American. (This was a 99.9% German cruise. AFAIK I was the only American passenger on board.) I wish I'd spoken to him.

Later that morning, there was a mandatory muster in the theater for about 30 minutes. Since it was in German (all communications onboard were in German), I can't tell you much, other than the captain spoke about pirates, and introduced a half-dozen black-shirted guys affiliated with Operation Safe Haven (which he kept saying as Safe Heaven.). They told us that for 2 nights, (when we would be closest to the 'pinch point' (south end of the Red Sea) at the spot where Africa and Asia are the closest to each other, there was a possibility of pirates and we were requested to close our balcony doors and keep the drapes closed to minimize light.

On those 2 nights, there was a marked presence of uniformed staff with "Security" written across the backs of their uniforms around the perimeter of the ship. I noticed that the outside upper decks (pools, hot tubs, stages, etc.) were not all lit up like they usually were. The outdoor upper deck bars and seating areas were still open (and serving) but were lit with low-wattage red lights. It felt odd and gave me a slight sense of how it may have been in England during the era of WWII bombing raids.

AFAIK, we did not encounter any pirates, and I never saw the Operation Safe Haven guys again.

So now I have questions/thoughts. Here are a few. Wondering if anyone here has any input/insight/experiences?

1. There's a lot of ship traffic through this area. (Cruises as well as container ships, oil transport, etc). Do these Operation Safe Haven guys get on & off ships just in this relatively small area? (If so, how?...our ship never stopped or changed speed).

2. Does OSH only work with cruise ships...or all ships?

3. I'm unclear on how these OSH guys would protect against determined and armed pirates? Any idea?

4. Other than taking hostages, it doesn't seem like a cruise ship would be nearly as valuable as capturing a cargo ship. Or am I missing something?

omni
 
There was a lot of discussion of pirates around the southern end of the Red Sea a few years ago, due to the collapse of law and order in Somalia. At one point it was reported a Russian cruise line was running trips for people to actively try and shoot pirates from the decks. (There were, again according to the story, ex-special forces people on board, presumably told to fire when the paying guests did so that they would appear to be scoring some hits.)

A cruise ship would be a tempting terrorist target generally (cf. Achille Lauro). On the Norwegian Cruise Line ship we went on in the Caribbean, there were a dozen retired Gurkhas (Nepalese citizens who serve with the British Army; you don't mess with these guys) and the head of security was a former British officer. They manned the going-on-board security checks in all the ports except one, where there was airport-style security at the harbour entrance. I'm guessing that they probably had access to some fairly impressive weapons if necessary, although in practice the worst that happened was that someone tried to bring a bottle of contraband rum on board.
 
Kabillions (ok... "a lot") of videos on youtube of mercenary companies ("private security") hired to guard cargo ships.
How they got on: ships pilots come on board every time a ship enters a harbor without the ship stopping. Mercs get on and off the same way hijackers do only with the assistance of the crew rather than resistance.
If the cruise was to have a higher concentration of a demographic targeted by terrorists in a given area, it not be surprising if the cruise ship picked up low-key mercs before sailing through the higher risk areas.
 
Hafen German, haven Dutch - means harbor. Odd that he would have pronounced it like “heaven”.
 
Those sonic defenses are pretty impressive, if you read up on them.
 
FWIW, Captain was Norwegian, although he spoke German.

omni

Well it’s havn in Norwegian, pronounced the same as the other two languages with the a pronounced as in father.

Must be difficulty with the English ‘a’ in this case pronounced like hey-ven.
 
Just another good reason why I won't be taking a cruise anytime soon. ;)

I'm not a fan of cruising, but I'm sure there are plenty of safe ones. My opinion is that if the vacation requires anti-piracy measures, armed guards, or is a high risk of some sort of attack, then it's not worth visiting.
 
I'm not a fan of cruising, but I'm sure there are plenty of safe ones. My opinion is that if the vacation requires anti-piracy measures, armed guards, or is a high risk of some sort of attack, then it's not worth visiting.

I would think that "anti-piracy measures, armed guards, or is a high risk of some sort of attack" would cost more, like an adventure vacation. :cool:
 
I am guessing that most people don’t know about the pirate risk in advance.
 
Yikes I love cruises but I would have been freaked out.
 
My son and his wife are graduates of Cal Maritime, both sailed tankers for a few years. My son told me that pirates are still a problem and not just in the area you mentioned. He commented about areas of the South Pacific around the Philipines and Indonesia.

Merchant seaman do not carry firearms aboard ship. That was likely the reason why your Captain hired security staff for the part of the voyage where he had concerns.

My son said that the only nation with comparable Deck Officer training to the US is Norway. I used to comment on the rough water in the North Atlantic, my son told me that the North Pacific is just as challenging. [My grandfather was Norwegian so I have a bias.]
 
We are going on a luxury cruise up the Amazon river next month. Ther are only 16 staterooms on the ship. Due to piracy in the past the ship is equipped with some hitech gear which alerts the Captain if any item of more than 150 lbs approaches the ship and sends out a distress call to the ship owner. They also have 5 armed guards on the ship at all times in rotating shifts. Lastly, my BIL is a Lieutenant Colonel in the Peruvian armed forces stationed in Iquitos and he tells me that the Coast Guard also "shadows" this ship.
 
There is a region that is protected/patrolled by a coalition of countries interested in keeping shipping running, they use military forces including helicopters. However the region is extremely large and help could be far away.

I read of an incident, where the cruise ship outran the 2 pirate boats, as cruise ships can go pretty fast.
 
Interestingly enough, our recent Princess Cruise out of San Francisco had two Coast Guard Zodiacs escort us from the cruise ship terminal until we passed under the Golden Gate Bridge and hit the open ocean.
 
Interestingly enough, our recent Princess Cruise out of San Francisco had two Coast Guard Zodiacs escort us from the cruise ship terminal until we passed under the Golden Gate Bridge and hit the open ocean.

I have seen the before in places, I always figured it was to make sure some stupid boater didn't try to cross in front of the cruise ship as a shortcut.
 
It's a four game series

Interestingly enough, our recent Princess Cruise out of San Francisco had two Coast Guard Zodiacs escort us from the cruise ship terminal until we passed under the Golden Gate Bridge and hit the open ocean.

You're safe for the rest of the summer. There won't be Pirates in SF again until September 6th.
 
Back
Top Bottom