Gatordoc50
Full time employment: Posting here.
There seems to be conflicting opinions on whether insurance should be purchased on rentals. Any thoughts?
daylatedollarshort said:I think for all the cards we own we have to decline the rental company's insurance in order for it to be valid.
Our personal car insurance covers rentals in the U.S. but not Europe. Our credit card insurance covers the car in Europe but not loss of use or liability.
We had a rental car damaged in the UK and the insurance from our credit card covered it. It was interesting because the rental car agency charged us something like $600 for a minor rock chip. We argued over the amount but what can you do when they have your credit card number and you have a plane to catch? We contacted the credit card company when we got home. They had their adjuster contact the rental car company. The amount was reduced to ~$100 and the credit card company covered it under their insurance.
However if I had to do it over again in Europe I'd get the rental car insurance because our car insurance policy doesn't cover us there and our credit card insurance is limited in what they will cover. In the U.S. we decline the rental car insurance because we are covered between our car policy and the credit card company policy. I think we might be subject to the loss of use but I figure we save money over the long term by self insuring on that front.
I have always rejected it but after doing some research I found that the Rental companies charge administrative and loss of use fees that sometimes exceed what your insurance will cover. I will continue to reject it and take my chances but am wondering if that is wise for those with limited resources.
Credit card's insurance is similar - some won't even cover a SUV or 4x4..........
On another forum I saw where a renter caused $11K in damage to a parking structure with a moving truck, and the renter's car insurance didn't cover the truck rental because it was over a certain weight limit. I mentally filed that as something to check into next time we need to rent a truck.
As for credit cards, Visa is said by travel experts to be more generous when it comes to paying loss-of-use charges than MasterCard and Discover. American Express takes such things on a case-by-case basis.