Yikes! what would be considered a high deductible in your area? Is this problem unique to New Orleans given its recent claims or is the insurance situation similar all along the coasts in the U.S.?
Well, when I wrote "high deductible" I was just thinking of 5% since that is what I am forced to take with Allstate. But really, when I think of a high deductible I think of something higher than that, maybe twice that.
I didn't have the mandatory 5% until after Katrina. Still, having observed what happened then, if I had not been forced to increase my deductible I probably would have requested it. Insurance companies mostly did not make settlements for years and if you began repairs first, you wouldn't get your money. So, since I'd want to repair what I could afford to repair during the first year, I'd rather have at least a 5% deductible or higher and "self insure" for amounts under that. As it was, I had some damage (under $5000 worth) but didn't make a claim. If you have made more than 2 claims in, um, I think it is six years, they can drop your policy. Otherwise state law has it that they can't. So, making a claim is serious business around here.
From what I have heard from others in the New Orleans area, I REALLY lucked out. My insurance is not that much higher than it was before Katrina (though the deductible is). Most locals are paying a lot more than I am. No claims, perfect payment record, stellar credit, being a long time customer, and keeping my car insurance with them as well, probably all helped. Well, plus the fact that my house has never flooded, though my neighbors' houses flooded a foot or two or four after Katrina (there but for the grace of G*d go I). I suspect that in a year or two, assuming there is no "Katrina II", Allstate will loosen up a bit and my rates and/or deductible will go down, and other insurers will do the same and will start writing new policies again. Then people will be able to afford housing more easily, so some of the backlogged housing inventory here should start to be snapped up.
I have no idea about insurance in other states.
I can complain about insurance, but my post-Katrina property taxes have been only four hundred something bucks (the Parish gave everybody a break since most people had damage and were financially strapped). This year they revert to 2005 levels so I am expecting maybe a $1200 tax bill when I get it this December. That's really not so bad, compared with the $20K taxes cited for somebody near Philadelphia in another post.