Yet another mortgate rate question...

Bimmerbill

Bimmerbill

Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
1,645
Heard on the radio about the big drop in rates yesterday. So I checked. My credit union is offering 5.375 on a 30 year. Have not checked USAA yet (thanks to work filtering their website!).

This rate is pretty dang low. I'm at 6.25 now. Maybe I'll run some numbers.

Good time to refinance? I need to free up cash for other purposes, otherwise I'd work on shortening the term (15 was 6.125, as was 10 year)...
 
About $2K in fees. Doesn't look like I'd save that much on a $120K balance. May be good to roll my $37K HELOC into it and get a good fixed rate tho.
 
Speaking of which! I was in WAMU yesterday doing some condominium association business, and they indicated they would be willing to drop .5% from your current rate (with lower closing costs) for existing customers.

I didn't pursue it, but food for thought for those with WAMU mortgages.

-- Rita
 
I'm holding out for a while yet. I think there will be a opening of floodgates and the rate will drop precipitously at some point. Of course I can't be sure, but you and I are both at rates where we're not leaving too much money on the table as it is, so there's much more upside potential to waiting than downside, IMHO.
 
Absolutely agree. I was encouraged to get the paperwork going now (intimating -- before the flood). I also think there may be more leverage available to get to a lower rate than .5% when the competition heats up -- especially for those with a FICO score of 700 or so.

-- Rita
 
Bimmerbill said:
About $2K in fees. Doesn't look like I'd save that much on a $120K balance. May be good to roll my $37K HELOC into it and get a good fixed rate tho.
Click to expand...

So a .75% savings is worth about $900 first year if you did a Penfed no fee 5.5% loan. They are very easy loans to do, or mine was last year...
$900. easy. just sayin.
 
If you dig around on the web, there is a guy called the mortgage professor who has quite sophisticated calculators that will help you figure out if it is worth it to refi. He is/was a Wharton finance professor, so I think the stuff is good.
 
If I can drop my P&I payment by 8% and keep same repayment period, then refinancing gets my attention.

8% drop means I save 1 mortgage payment per year.
Keeping same repayment date accounts for the principal I have already paid down.

I have a 5.75% mortgage (started in 2006), 30 yr fixed. Any refinance for me would have to have a 2036 repayment date and still save me 8% on the payment.

I think rates will stay low through May of 2009. There is a chance the economy will have started improving around then... so rates would head upward soon after that.
 
Youse guys are higher rollers than i. If i have a chance to save a couple hundred bucks a year for very little effort i take it - it's enough to make me change or get new credit cards. $900 gets my attention. Shoot, it's way more than we've made in the market this year....(wry emoticon)
 
calmloki said:
Youse guys are higher rollers than i. If i have a chance to save a couple hundred bucks a year for very little effort i take it - it's enough to make me change or get new credit cards. $900 gets my attention. Shoot, it's way more than we've made in the market this year....(wry emoticon)
Click to expand...

The cost to get the $900 and the impact it has on the budget are what I look at.

My last refi cost me around $2500 or $3000 (including points). The points dropped me from 6% to 5.75% in 2006.

If the refi saved me $900 that year, but cost me $3000, it would take 3 years to recoup just the closing costs. I prefer to break even sooner- so I want the refi to take my payment down lower before I consider pulling the trigger. For example my calculations show I need to see a 5.25% rate before a refi makes sense (on my current 30 yr fixed 5.75%). A 5.5% rate would lower my payment and save me around $1500/year, but it would cost me to close on the loan, and because of mortgage size, that cost is around 2k every place I look.
 
I'll be darned. NFCU has a 5.25% 30-year fixed loan for 1.875 points.

We've been tracking their mortgage rates for over four years and this is the first time a refinancing would have a decent payback. Considering the lost interest on the points & closing costs, we'd lower our payments by 4.5% and reset our 26 remaining years back to 30. But the effort would pay itself off in "just" nine years and give us a mortgage until I'm 78 years old.

Looks like USAA & PenFed are slightly higher.

NFCU's deal is more compelling if the points or the interest rate drop. We'll have to keep an eye on it. Happy Thanksgiving!
 
Nords I picked up Penfed last February at 4.625 15 year with no points you must have walked away from your computer during the six hours the rate was that low.:)
 
jIMOh said:
The cost to get the $900 and the impact it has on the budget are what I look at.

My last refi cost me around $2500 or $3000 (including points). The points dropped me from 6% to 5.75% in 2006.

If the refi saved me $900 that year, but cost me $3000, it would take 3 years to recoup just the closing costs. I prefer to break even sooner- so I want the refi to take my payment down lower before I consider pulling the trigger. For example my calculations show I need to see a 5.25% rate before a refi makes sense (on my current 30 yr fixed 5.75%). A 5.5% rate would lower my payment and save me around $1500/year, but it would cost me to close on the loan, and because of mortgage size, that cost is around 2k every place I look.
Click to expand...

fer sure fees make a big difference. That's why i liked the Penfed loan - no fees. right now this is what i see at their site - different than my earlier post, worth watching them.
30 Yr Fixed RateAPR

Points 5.750%


Looks like Bimmerbill would only save $600 at this time, rather than the $900 i thought i saw this morning.
5.750%




0.000
 
Darryl said:
Nords I picked up Penfed last February at 4.625 15 year with no points you must have walked away from your computer during the six hours the rate was that low.:)
Click to expand...
No way, that would actually raise my monthly payments. We're four years into a 30-year fixed at 5.375%. Besides it's a bit chancy to arb the investment of a 15-year mortgage, especially when the market is high. Doing it now might actually pay off.

The objective here is to get the lowest payments stretched out over the longest time. 40-year mortgages are still too new to offer much competition and they don't significantly lower the payment either.
 
Nords, a millisecond before I hit the enter key I knew what your response to 15 yr would be but I had too much momentum to stop my finger.
 
Getting an appraisal might be the big problem in any refi today. I have a neighbor who bought a couple of years ago via an ARM, and now it looks like his house won't appraise for enough to cover his original first. Our neighborhood has 170 houses, mostly different, but only five for sale. No house has sold for more than a year. Hard to get a good est. under these conditions.
 
Bimmerbill said:
Heard on the radio about the big drop in rates yesterday. So I checked. My credit union is offering 5.375 on a 30 year. Have not checked USAA yet (thanks to work filtering their website!).
Click to expand...
Why on earth would an employer place a filter on USAA?

Anyway, my CU recently dropped their no-points 30-year FRM from 6.25% to 5.375%.

Hopefully mortgage rates this low will convince some people on the sidelines waiting for a housing bottom to get in now while rates are very low...
 
Darryl said:
Nords I picked up Penfed last February at 4.625 15 year with no points you must have walked away from your computer during the six hours the rate was that low.:)
Click to expand...

Darryl,

We locked the day before rates hit 4.625, and wound up with 4.875. Oh well, can't complain too much.

--nickel
 
Down to 5.25 with no points. Lower rates available with points, also 20 and 25 year mortgages. I may do it... 1% drop in my mortgage rate... Mortgage professor calculator crashed on my work pc with an error, I'll check around to see if I can find another.

Can't find another that will work to show break even if I finance HELOC as well. Can anyone run my numbers:

1st $118K at 6.25%, 24 years remaining
HELOC $37K at 3.75 VARIABLE, 10 years left, doing int only payments
New: 5.25, no points, 30 year term, $2000 closing costs (approx)

OK looks like I'd save $72 per month, so payback is just over 2 years. Will cost more in int, but I'm working to reduce monthly bills.
 
PenFed is offering 15 yr @ 5.00 with .125 points. I was gonna pull the trigger today, but since the yield on the 10yr is still dropping, I'm waiting.
 
locked in with countrywide today at 5.375% for my co-op. even going to take some cash out and they don't care.

going there in a few days to drop off the documentation and look at the loan docs to verify the numbers

i think the 10 year note has some more downside on the yield, but not going to take a chance on it or spreads going wider
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

L
61 y/o in Atlanta, mostly retired
2
Replies
43
Views
2K
pacergal
P
M
Any McDonald's Shareholders?
Replies
10
Views
692
MichealKnight
M
Tranquility Base
Bonds/Fixed Income and Asset Location
2 3
Replies
53
Views
6K
jldavid47
jldavid47
P
After FI: late 30-something wondering what her purpose is
Replies
14
Views
890
LateToFIRE
L
S
Portfolio Alternatives Advice? Single fund vs 17 ETFS? Annuities?
Replies
22
Views
2K
OldShooter
OldShooter

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom