The choices I looked at ran even higher. So my answer, if appropriate for your situation: Let your wife have first choice.
The faucet might be a simple functional device, but I view it as jewelry for my kitchen. The faucet is the accent to the sink, often a focal area of the room since sinks are often under windows. So, unlike say... the faucet in the laundry, or the 2nd bathroom, this is a good place to BTD. If your home has an open layout, you might even be able to see a high mounted style faucet from the living room or dining room.
And the higher end ones typically come with lifetime warranty, and they mean it.
If you have the existing holes... do you want a matching sprayer (you do, makes cleaning the sink so much easier). Matching soap dispenser?
Ours is a Danze, they were bought a couple of years ago but maintain the line I believe. Ferguson is a good place for a specialty showroom if you don't find what you like at a big box.