Amethyst
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2008
- Messages
- 12,668
When paying extra on your mortgage principal, should it make any difference whether you a) add the extra payment to your regular monthly payment or b) remit the extra payment separately?
My amortization spreadsheet says the 2 should result in the exact same rate of paydown.
However, my credit union informed me that if I include the extra payment within my regular payment, all I am doing is "pushing off your next payment." [As of now, my next payment isn't due till June 2010]. They said I needed to call a customer service rep every month, and have the rep make a transfer from another of my accounts, if I want to get credit for an extra principal payment. The credit union people kind of mumbled when I asked for the math. The attitude was basically, "That's the way it is and we're only trying to help."
Based on their records, my balance is indeed being lowered at a slighly lesser rate than my spreadsheet says it should be. The difference is only ~$10 per month, yet over several years, that adds up. Also it's a nuisance to have to transfer funds every month to my credit union, then call them to make the extra principal payment for me.
Thoughts?
My amortization spreadsheet says the 2 should result in the exact same rate of paydown.
However, my credit union informed me that if I include the extra payment within my regular payment, all I am doing is "pushing off your next payment." [As of now, my next payment isn't due till June 2010]. They said I needed to call a customer service rep every month, and have the rep make a transfer from another of my accounts, if I want to get credit for an extra principal payment. The credit union people kind of mumbled when I asked for the math. The attitude was basically, "That's the way it is and we're only trying to help."
Based on their records, my balance is indeed being lowered at a slighly lesser rate than my spreadsheet says it should be. The difference is only ~$10 per month, yet over several years, that adds up. Also it's a nuisance to have to transfer funds every month to my credit union, then call them to make the extra principal payment for me.
Thoughts?