Sorry to once again shill for Dr. Pfau. Seems like every article gets posted here.
I thought this gave a nice checklist of things to think about when deciding whether to hire an advisor or DIY. Mostly a summary of Vanguard and Morningstar papers, with some numbers on the investment return values of certain actions.
I thought this gave a nice checklist of things to think about when deciding whether to hire an advisor or DIY. Mostly a summary of Vanguard and Morningstar papers, with some numbers on the investment return values of certain actions.
(1) Build a customized investment plan aimed at achieving goals and meeting constraints for risk tolerance and risk capacity
> 0% suitable asset allocation with broadly diversified investments
0.45% focus on low-cost investments (low expense ratios)
0 – 0.75% locating assets properly in taxable and tax-advantaged accounts
>0% focusing on total returns investment instead of income investing
(2) Minimize risks and tax impacts
0.35% rebalancing to the strategic asset allocation
0 – 0.70% deciding where to draw assets from (tax-deferred or taxable) to meet spending
(3) Behavioral coaching
> 1.5% providing support to stay the course in times of market stress
Overall net impact of good advice: about 3%
Can an advisor charging a 1% fee provide enough value to justify the fee? It depends on the answers to two questions:
(a) Do you have the time, energy, interest, knowledge, and desire to implement all of these decisions on your own?
(b) Are you working with a comprehensive financial planner who does more than just manage investment portfolios and is capable of implementing good financial planning decisions?
If you have the time, interest, energy, knowledge, and desire to do this on your own, then you would make an excellent advisor. If your advisor is less than capable, you might be better off saving yourself the 1% or taking your business elsewhere.