Early Retirement & Financial Independence Community

Early Retirement & Financial Independence Community (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/)
-   FIRE and Money (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/f28/)
-   -   Investment nightmare (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/f28/investment-nightmare-109066.html)

Retireby45ish 04-29-2021 08:48 AM

Investment nightmare
 
A few years ago before finding this board I invested in a fund that did lending to small businesses.

Long and sad story short it went south after a few years of nice returns. it was a 900M fund that turned into a Ponzi scheme by the greedy founder.

My question is a bit complex.

I had invested taxable funds. Letís call the amt 200k to make the math easy.

I then withdrew those funds and deposited the same amount through an IRA. So withdrew 300k (100k gain after 5 years) and put in 300k of different IRA money account I had. These were not same funds but I did the swap at the same time.

So now, a month later, the fund goes under and loses like 80%. They are trying to get more back for investors.

So now I get a letter saying ďhey you banked a 100k profit so we want 50% of that back if you pay us in 30 days or else we will litigate for the full amtĒ. They said they treat IRA and my other account as separate entities (which is insane) so they do not offset even though they said tax id numbers would be used to aggregate those with multiple accounts. Iíve reached out to see why these accounts arenít treated as offsetting since Iím the holder of both. They are clawing back money from me to pay me in my other account. Thought of the 50k Iíll probably get less than a penny of that back on the other IRA side.

What should I do?
I worry that paying an attorney to fight it might cost me enough where itís worth just sending in 50k. I might ask for 25k settlement instead to see if they come down. But I doubt it.
Anyone know any lawyer that might give me some thoughts?

Thanks in advance for any help.

Lesson on diversification learned. This has been the saddest financial decision of my life. I didnít get to write off losses in IRA and I paid taxes on all gains.

tb001 04-29-2021 08:55 AM

Is your ira invested with the same entity? I don’t understand how you can withdraw $ and they have any recourse at this point?

Retireby45ish 04-29-2021 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tb001 (Post 2599438)
Is your ira invested with the same entity? I donít understand how you can withdraw $ and they have any recourse at this point?


The Ira was invested through a holding company (similar to fidelity) and the regular funds were just wired over normally.

Yes I agree, I donít see how they can come for it, yet they did :(

jazz4cash 04-29-2021 09:03 AM

I donít know but itís very interesting. I donít see how you could put these funds into an IRA. It seems to me you could be liable for a clawback. 50% is probably a decent offer if there is a legitimate case of fraud (e.g. Ponzi) vs. bad investment choices by the founder or bad behavior because itís not necessarily illegal. I donít know but others with better insight will weigh in.

ivinsfan 04-29-2021 09:08 AM

Explain how you put 300K into an IRA...how many years did that take you? ..this makes no sense.


I know you picked a round number for example, but how much money was actually involved.

pb4uski 04-29-2021 09:11 AM

+1 What the OP wrote doesn't make sense... you can't just pop in $300k from taxable account into an IRA... there must be more to the story.

But for now I'll assume that for some unknown reason what they OP said is true. If there is significant time between when the $300k taxable account was withdrawn and $300k deposited into the IRA then the their position might have some credence.

If it was at the same time then it is stupid to view it as two transactions. The OP invested $200k and lost most of it so there is no gain to be clawed back.

You could even make the same argument if there was some time between the $300k withdrawal and the $300k deposit... soup-to-nuts the OP invested $200k and lost most of it so there is no gain to be clawed back.

Marginal cost is $200k... marginal revenue is not much... therefore an economic loss. Unless the law says differently (and it may) then economics should prevail.

I would get a lawyer and send them a letter explaining why you don't owe anything and then ignore all other communication until they file a lawsuit against you.... then get the lawyer involved again.

Gallaher 04-29-2021 09:12 AM

Seems like you could withdraw draw your cash, fly to Vegas for a lost weekend....Ēsorry, lost itĒ. Now what are they gonna do?
If they have shown you they are scammers, be bold to their scams.
Sounds like their advantage is to intimidate you.
You get to decide how you respond

USGrant1962 04-29-2021 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivinsfan (Post 2599444)
Explain how you put 300K into an IRA...how many years did that take you? ..this makes no sense.


I know you picked a round number for example, but how much money was actually involved.

I read OP as re-buying into the investment with an existing IRA, not funding the IRA. Still, a strange transaction.

Retireby45ish 04-29-2021 09:16 AM

Investment nightmare
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by USGrant1962 (Post 2599447)
I read OP as re-buying into the investment with an existing IRA, not funding the IRA. Still, a strange transaction.


This is correct. I had an existing IRA account money that I used to buy it at the same time that I sold the taxable account. It wasnít the same money I took out.

I did so because the tax treatment on the gains was taxed as ordinary income so I wanted to make it more
Tax efficientÖhence the IrA holding it rather than regular taxable cash.

Retireby45ish 04-29-2021 09:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pb4uski (Post 2599445)
+1 you can't just pop in $300k from taxable account into an IRA... there must be more to the story.


Sorry for not explaining it well. I clarified in post above.
This was an existing IRA account I had with funds. And at same time as removing cash I invested through my IRA (but not the same money).

jazz4cash 04-29-2021 09:24 AM

50% gain in 5 yrs is a decent return but I have no clue on the risk. Obviously it has turned out to be huge.

pb4uski 04-29-2021 09:24 AM

Ah.. ok. So in your taxable account you sold $300k at a $100k gain... and in your taxable account you used $300k of cash to reinvest.

Was the sale and reinvestment done at the same time? If not, what was the time difference between the two transactions? Hours? Days? Weeks? Months?

tulak 04-29-2021 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by USGrant1962 (Post 2599447)
I read OP as re-buying into the investment with an existing IRA, not funding the IRA. Still, a strange transaction.


Could be, but in that case the OP should say he bought/sold the fund in taxable/IRA accounts. Using withdraw/deposit implies that money was transferred between accounts, which in this case is confusing.

Iím wondering who is asking for the money? Is this a government entity?

It sounds like a tough situation. I suspect youíd get something back for the 300k in losses, but that probably wonít happen until all the funds have been retrieved to determine how much can be given back to investors?

pb4uski 04-29-2021 09:28 AM

It is probably a trustee asking for the money.... like the guys that chased down Bernie Madoff's assets for the investors. It isn't uncommon to try to claw back gains... for example if the OP hadn't done the IRA piece then he would have clearly been $100k to the good and the trustee would try to clawback some of those gains for the other investors... same thing happened with Madoff.

Quote:

... Mr. Picard won a key legal victory in August 2011, when the Second Circuit upheld the method he and his team devised to determine how to handle claims. Madoff investors who took out more money from the fund than they deposited would have no claim, and would instead be liable to return their Ponzi-inflated gains. Only net losers would receive payments from money recovered by the trustee.

ivinsfan 04-29-2021 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by USGrant1962 (Post 2599447)
I read OP as re-buying into the investment with an existing IRA, not funding the IRA. Still, a strange transaction.


Yes it could be that , that's the only logical answer. This just confuses the story because the fact he put in an IRA has no bearing. It's the buy, sell, buy they are looking at. However the fact he put all the money back into the same fund means he still had the same risk...so how did he bank a 100K in profit?

jazz4cash 04-29-2021 09:41 AM

Yeah. The OP leaves a lot of open issues so itís tough to offer helpful responses. To be fair I missed many details that were provided. If I got this right you booked a 50% LT gain of $100k over 5 yrs. You swapped that out for an 80% loss of (.8*300k=) $240k that you cannot deduct. Losing 80% in such a short period sounds like speculation to say the least. Is there a class action?

Sunset 04-29-2021 09:47 AM

If I read OP's post correctly, OP put 200K into investment, then cashed out $300K and put back in $300K into the investment.

Since OP didn't cash out , OP could argue there was no profit, the receiver probably does not connect the two different funding sources.

I think OP should reply there is no profit, and show the investment of the $300K IRA money. Since the investment lost 80%, OP's net profit is really $ - 160K , so they owe OP money. (the $300K was originally $200K ignoring source of funding, which is how I derive OP is out $160K (plus taxes paid on the original now absent fake profit of $100K).

I wonder what the limits are on clawbacks, lots of investors over years are innocently making profits and being taxed on it.

RunningBum 04-29-2021 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Retireby45ish (Post 2599436)

So now I get a letter saying ďhey you banked a 100k profit so we want 50% of that back if you pay us in 30 days or else we will litigate for the full amtĒ. They said they treat IRA and my other account as separate entities (which is insane) so they do not offset even though they said tax id numbers would be used to aggregate those with multiple accounts.

What should I do?

I would document the 80% loss on the $300K you invested with your IRA account. Point out that even though you made $100K in taxable, you lost $240K in your IRA and don't feel you should have money clawed back when you lost $140K overall between the two accounts.

disneysteve 04-29-2021 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunset (Post 2599482)
If I read OP's post correctly, OP put 200K into investment, then cashed out $300K and put back in $300K into the investment.

Since OP didn't cash out , OP could argue there was no profit, the receiver probably does not connect the two different funding sources.

That's how I would read this as well. OP may need an attorney to sort it out though.

ivinsfan 04-29-2021 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunset (Post 2599482)
If I read OP's post correctly, OP put 200K into investment, then cashed out $300K and put back in $300K into the investment.

Since OP didn't cash out , OP could argue there was no profit, the receiver probably does not connect the two different funding sources.

I think OP should reply there is no profit, and show the investment of the $300K IRA money. Since the investment lost 80%, OP's net profit is really $ - 160K , so they owe OP money. (the $300K was originally $200K ignoring source of funding, which is how I derive OP is out $160K (plus taxes paid on the original now absent fake profit of $100K).

I wonder what the limits are on clawbacks, lots of investors over years are innocently making profits and being taxed on it.


We don't know the time gap between the sell/buy but yes the math doesn't add up...apparently they told him the funds don't offset, he should get some clawback money on the extra 100K in profits whenever that happens. (or if it happens) I find it interesting they gave him a 50% discount which would lead me to doubt how much he would get paid out on the clawback settlement.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:14 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.