DMIL paid about $10,000 up front for a car lease to lower the monthly payments. She died about a year and a half into the lease.
The leasing company told us that we could return the car now and the lease payments would stop, but there would be no refund of any of the $10,000 up front payment.
We ended up keeping the car throughout the lease and actually purchased it in the end. It was very low mileage.
DMIL was also in Michigan FWIW.
Your story doesn't surprise me from our experience.
-gauss
Never put any money down on a vehicle lease.
Roll everything possible into the monthly payment.
Why?
Because you will never get any lump sum paid upfront back in the event of:
1. death as above but more commonly:
2. an accident where the vehicle is unrepairable & totaled by the insurance company...given this you also need gap insurance, which covers the difference between the insurance payout & what you still owe the leasing company, though it's often included in a lease nowadays.
Sometimes you luck out, of course...my truck lease ended last summer & I bought it out.
Because of COVID craziness it's worth several thousand bucks more than the contract residual (plus tax on the residual) that I paid.
BTW, it seems rare for a one-pay lease to be a good deal...I've only seen a handful, primarily for pure EVs in limited markets (usually CA) over on leasehackr [sic] dot com where there was enough of a discount to make paying everything (including taxes & fees) upfront worth it.
And IIRC, in those cases those who jumped on the lease confirmed there was pro-rata refund language in the lease contract.