Early Retirement & Financial Independence Community

Early Retirement & Financial Independence Community (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/)
-   Life after FIRE (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/f29/)
-   -   Golf Talk Tuesdays 2015-2020 (https://www.early-retirement.org/forums/f29/golf-talk-tuesdays-2015-2020-a-78866.html)

garyt 03-17-2020 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jkern (Post 2389723)
I believe the old system did benefit the higher handicap player. I use to play in an annual two day tournament with about 40 players. My handicap ranged from 4 to 6 and I didn't have a chance in h*ll against the 20 to 30 handicap crowd. Each year I would have had to shoot 72 to 74 each day in order to win. Only twice did a player win with a low handicap over 10 years.

I always felt like it worked fine ,especially one on one. But in any tournament there's likely to be more high hdcp golfers than low ones and it only takes one to have a good round and that's it they're going to win. It's a lot easier for a 20 hdcp to shoot in the 80's than a scratch golfer shooting 64. I would think if you had a tournament with 100 players 50/50 high and low hdcps, while a high hdcp would likely win, more low cap guys would be in the top 20. Especially if the tournament is more than one round.

Big_Hitter 03-17-2020 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Music Lover (Post 2389914)
Sandbagging aside, it's generally easier for a higher handicap to go lower than a more consistent low handicap. I don't track my handicap but I'd guess I'm somewhere around 14. I have a good swing but I'm inconsistent. The bulk of my games are around 88 - 90 with 2- 4 triples, sometimes as high as 100 on a bad day. But on a good day I'll break 80.

Last fall in an informal work tournament I shot 83 on a very hard course (with an 8 on an easy par 4) and the winner (4 handicap) won with an 80. The previous day I shot 96 on a much easier course.

i played golds again today and started out with 2 doubles, all terrible short game shots - then I birdied two holes in a row finished with 3 birdies and a 40

back 9 I had a good side going to I decided to hit an iron off the tee on the last 4 holes - finished 6 over on the last 4 for a 44 with 3 penalty strokes

that 84 converted into a 17 index or something on GHIN

jkern 03-18-2020 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Music Lover (Post 2389914)
Sandbagging aside, it's generally easier for a higher handicap to go lower than a more consistent low handicap. I don't track my handicap but I'd guess I'm somewhere around 14. I have a good swing but I'm inconsistent. The bulk of my games are around 88 - 90 with 2- 4 triples, sometimes as high as 100 on a bad day. But on a good day I'll break 80.

Last fall in an informal work tournament I shot 83 on a very hard course (with an 8 on an easy par 4) and the winner (4 handicap) won with an 80. The previous day I shot 96 on a much easier course.

Breaking 80 as a 14 handicap is pretty good. I never broke 80 until I reached about a 10.

Midpack 03-18-2020 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Music Lover (Post 2389914)
Sandbagging aside, it's generally easier for a higher handicap to go lower than a more consistent low handicap. I don't track my handicap but I'd guess I'm somewhere around 14. I have a good swing but I'm inconsistent. The bulk of my games are around 88 - 90 with 2- 4 triples, sometimes as high as 100 on a bad day. But on a good day I'll break 80.

Last fall in an informal work tournament I shot 83 on a very hard course (with an 8 on an easy par 4) and the winner (4 handicap) won with an 80. The previous day I shot 96 on a much easier course.
Quote:

Originally Posted by jkern (Post 2390565)
Breaking 80 as a 14 handicap is pretty good. I never broke 80 until I reached about a 10.


But the stars do align every once in a while. My 12-15 HI is about the same as Music's guestimate and my recent history breaking 80 is:
  • 2017- twice 77 & 79
  • 2018- zip
  • 2019- once 79
  • 2020- not yet (two 82's so far...)
Reminds me of a fav golf quote I heard Paul Goydos share - I'm too inconsistent to be bad all the time.

garyt 03-18-2020 11:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jkern (Post 2390565)
Breaking 80 as a 14 handicap is pretty good. I never broke 80 until I reached about a 10.

So many different type players in a certain hdcp range. You have the guy who has a solid game but just can't putt (raises hand), if he has a lucky putting day he can go low for his hdcp. Other guys who maybe spray it a lot. Since they maybe play a tight course their hdcp is high. Put them on a wide open links course and they can score. And on and on.

zinger1457 03-18-2020 11:57 AM

The score by itself is not a good comparison unless you also include the course rating from the tees being played. There can easily be a >7 stroke difference on most golf courses when playing from the forward tees and the tips. At my home course the tips are 7200yds but they also have a way forward tee of 4500yds, a 12 stroke difference in the course rating. I would look at an 84 from the tips as a better score than a 75 from the forward tees.

jkern 03-18-2020 12:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zinger1457 (Post 2390719)
The score by itself is not a good comparison unless you also include the course rating from the tees being played. There can easily be a >7 stroke difference on most golf courses when playing from the forward tees and the tips. At my home course the tips are 7200yds but they also have a way forward tee of 4500yds, a 12 stroke difference in the course rating. I would look at an 84 from the tips as a better score than a 75 from the forward tees.

So true, 100% dependent on course and tees. For me, I remember in 2012 after hardly playing for about two years due to an elbow injury my average index was 11.8 and my average score was 14.1 and I never broke 80 that year.

Music Lover 03-18-2020 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by garyt (Post 2390704)
So many different type players in a certain hdcp range. You have the guy who has a solid game but just can't putt (raises hand), if he has a lucky putting day he can go low for his hdcp. Other guys who maybe spray it a lot. Since they maybe play a tight course their hdcp is high. Put them on a wide open links course and they can score. And on and on.

I've taken a few lessons...my instructor claims that my good swings are "very good". Most rounds I'll land 2 or 3 full iron shots inside 10 feet. I usually string 5 - 6 holes at even par every round. What does me in are a few wild shots, chunked chips, and occasional inconsistent putting.

It's quite common for me to play 6 holes 1 over par, then go 3 off the tee, miss the green, chunk a chip, then 3 putt for a quad. Then make a couple doubles. Then play the next 3 holes even followed by a triple, etc...

zinger1457 03-25-2020 07:25 AM

Has your golfing been impacted by the virus? Not much change at my course except closing down the 19th hole, I always walk but now they don't insist that riders pair up in golf carts, seems like play has sped up a little.

jcretire77 03-25-2020 07:36 AM

The club I play at the majority of the time is still open and trying to do all the right things. My only limitation is a knee injury that is finally feeling better.

Boise has two public courses and I saw yesterday that they had reopened one. I do not know why only one. The course that is still closed is the more interesting of the two and five minutes from my house. Dang it.

Popeye 03-25-2020 07:45 AM

The governors have shut everything down in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. No golf for me. A quick golf now search yields one course open for walking in Delaware.

Big_Hitter 03-25-2020 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jcretire77 (Post 2396367)
The club I play at the majority of the time is still open and trying to do all the right things. My only limitation is a knee injury that is finally feeling better.

Boise has two public courses and I saw yesterday that they had reopened one. I do not know why only one. The course that is still closed is the more interesting of the two and five minutes from my house. Dang it.

probably because quail is much more difficult than warm dump lol

the senior group has me walking and carrying my clubs again - I think i've lost 20 pounds?

jollystomper 03-25-2020 07:58 AM

Courses in Maryland are closed, but they are still open in Virginia.

f35phixer 03-25-2020 08:15 AM

Course in county closed, the one on base is still open. What they have done is put pieces of swim noodles around pin so ball goes in ~ 1/2 inch, easy to get out and no touching pins, Took all rakes away, smooth bunker with feet and told not to use ball washers... Blowing like a hurricane last Sunday and broke 80 (78) for first time in long time!!! Played really good, 10 1 putts , 2 birds and penalty for hitting one in water... So this Sunday i'll go out with EXPECTATIONS, that will kill me and i'll be back to low 80's again !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

garyt 03-25-2020 08:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zinger1457 (Post 2396355)
Has your golfing been impacted by the virus? Not much change at my course except closing down the 19th hole, I always walk but now they don't insist that riders pair up in golf carts, seems like play has sped up a little.

Courses are closed here in Mi.

jkern 03-25-2020 09:16 AM

Courses are all closed here in California.

I was already in the middle of a 5 week rest plan due to severe elbow pain. Rest 3 weeks, cortisone shot, rest another 2 weeks. My time is up and I'm ready to go, but now no golf courses.

Midpack 03-25-2020 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zinger1457 (Post 2396355)
Has your golfing been impacted by the virus? Not much change at my course except closing down the 19th hole, I always walk but now they don't insist that riders pair up in golf carts, seems like play has sped up a little.

Im jealous. My regular club closed completely Monday before last (3/16), no reopen date. I miss golf, thought Id be able to continue since social distancing is largely built in. And I just got a new driver shaft Im dying to try out!

pb4uski 03-25-2020 12:24 PM

Four of us played today... first time ever with a separate cart for each guy... we played in 3:28. Cups were down where we play today but where I played a couple days ago at a different course and the cups were 1/2" above the level of the green. Some courses have taken out ball washers, others not. Some still have water on the course, others not.
All have removed rakes.

jcretire77 03-25-2020 05:06 PM

And now we are closed with the Idaho governor's stay at home edict for the next 21 days. Bummer for golf. Bigger bummer for all those whose jobs are hurt.

Dawg52 03-25-2020 05:14 PM

Played 9 today with my neighbor(separate carts). If our course remains open I plan to play with him or by myself for the next few weeks. Will miss my big golfing group but going to safe.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.