Discussing finance with family and friends seems fruitless

It would be interesting to know exactly how you phrased the "financial questions." I'm not assuming anything, just pointing out that the precise way it is phrased could make all the difference in others' receptiveness.
One general question I've asked my friends who are my age (58) is, "Have you started thinking about when you will be retiring?" The general response has been, "I'll probably retire when I'm 65ish" - which seems to be the generic retirement age assumption. No follow-up questions or discussions ensued.
 
Now that we are old enough to be normal retirees, people don't ask, but in our earlier days, when asked how we could retire, we usually just said "we never had children". That has the benefit of being both true and non-threatening/angst provoking, even if it's not the full story.
 
One general question I've asked my friends who are my age (58) is, "Have you started thinking about when you will be retiring?" The general response has been, "I'll probably retire when I'm 65ish" - which seems to be the generic retirement age assumption. No follow-up questions or discussions ensued.
I (62) probably would have given the same answer. Until the last few years, I had no idea there was such a thing as a "FIRE movement," and that a significant and growing number of people retired earlier than 65-ish. Except for the occasional oddball who played the stock market as a hobby, none of my friends or colleagues ever mentioned financial things or their retirement goals, other than some tacit acknowledgement of the traditional expectation they would work until 65-ish when they would tap their 401ks that they had rarely given any serious thought to during their working years. I don't know how I would have reacted if a friend or colleague had tried to open a conversation about saving for retirement or related issues. I probably would have either said with a shrug or wave of the hand that I have always contributed to a 401k and figured there was nothing more to discuss until 65. I may have been more receptive to a family member, but in my family they all worked to 65 if not beyond and/or died while working.
 
I see this in a couple of days. One, the topic of money, finances is often a personal topic and many people to not wish to talk about their financial situation openly. Two, for others the topic of money, finances is a boring topic.

I can imagine the OP exciting about having a deep conversation money with family and friends. But to the family and friends, that's like showing baby pictures or pictures of a vacation. Some may be interested while others may not be.

My approach is if a family member or friends wants to have an money talk with me, my door is open. But I let them approach me first. Otherwise it's them: How's was your day?" Me: "Not much. How as your day?"
 
I see this in a couple of days. One, the topic of money, finances is often a personal topic and many people to not wish to talk about their financial situation openly. Two, for others the topic of money, finances is a boring topic.

I can imagine the OP exciting about having a deep conversation money with family and friends. But to the family and friends, that's like showing baby pictures or pictures of a vacation. Some may be interested while others may not be.

My approach is if a family member or friends wants to have an money talk with me, my door is open. But I let them approach me first. Otherwise it's them: How's was your day?" Me: "Not much. How as your day?"
+1. "Hey everybody, guess what? I made $52,500 this week in the market", (how was your week?!). Doesn't really go over well for long term friendships.....
 
Why is this important to you (especially if your personal financial situation is in order)?

Fair question. Without presuming to the speak for the OP, or anyone else, here are some possibilities:

1. We desire companionship and compatriots, along our own financial journeys. Whether one is fabulously successful or an abject failure, it's lonely to be saving, planning and investing. One would like to bounce-off ideas, and if appropriate, to share one's wisdom. Which brings us to...

2. Desire for validation. Am I doing the right thing? If Jones over there is impressed with my progress, then yes, I'm doing the right thing. This need not be selfish. It can morph into a genuine desire to help others. But also:

3. In tough times, such as declining markets or missed opportunities, we seek communal solace. This has a darker side:

4. By delving into the muted progress of others, we feel better about ourselves, even if we genuinely are trying to offer good and actionable advice.

I've noticed discussing financial planning is harder as we get older because now we're talking about outcomes rather than life activities. Its one thing for one family member to "plan on quit smoking one of these days" while another family member gets to the gym 3x per week for 20 years. Its the grist of life and differences.
Indeed. As our human capital dwindles, compared to our invested-capital, conversations about money become more of a locker-room comparison, than mutual tutoring of how to improve. It becomes less of collaboration and more of contest. Those left behind, resent their betters. Those who are ahead, feel license to gloat... even if they're outwardly humble in their demeanor.
 
Comparison is the thief of joy, so I try hard never to do it. There are simply too many variables that go into any individual's success or lack of success, so that we neither can nor should take any comfort that we currently are doing better than others. Nor, for the same reason, can we or should we lament that we have not achieved what others have. Further, we should always remember that fate can turn on a dime and he who is on top today can be below tomorrow. As for affirmation about my choices and plans, if I am right, I am right, and it matters not whether others agree or disagree. Or, in other words, the mere fact that something is popular doesn't make it correct or good.

My mother taught me to do what is right, not popular, and to mind my own business. She was a very wise woman.
 
Last edited:
When I was starting to invest in the mid 1980's I approached a very successful person in my home town. He grew up in the depression and started with Maybe $0. He encouraged people to save and invest, and also to be generous and give. He read the Wall Street Journal while others read the Sporting News. He was very successful and the most generous person I've ever know. His motto was "Money is to help people" He was my bus driver when I was a kid. I'll bet he was the most wealthy bus driver in Minnesota. The kindest too.

I solicited his advice and he took me in. He encouraged me to buy stock in companies you believe in and still want to own if the market tanks. One day it did, October 1987. He looked me up the day after Black Monday and told me "Don't Panic and don't sell, you own a part of good companies and they'll be worth what they were and more if you hold on". I was 22. I remember his words often. He was right.

I was the one to approach him and followed his advice when he was asked. Otherwise, he'd never have offered it.
 
I think for most people financial discussions about retirement are just as much fun as talking about health care directives, life insurance, and funeral arrangements. They know they should do something about all that but not just now. So they don't do anything until they absolutely have to and their options are more limited because they waited so long.
 
I think for most people financial discussions about retirement are just as much fun as talking about health care directives, life insurance, and funeral arrangements. They know they should do something about all that but not just now. So they don't do anything until they absolutely have to and their options are more limited because they waited so long.
Agree. Not everyone is like most of us when it comes to talking about finances!! :LOL:

Flieger
 
Agree. Not everyone is like most of us when it comes to talking about finances!! :LOL:

Flieger
I agree. But still a lot of folks want to retire wealthy at an early age without a plan. Kind of like eating and drinking whatever you want and staying fit into your later years without dieting and exercising. You got to put in a little effort to get what you want. Financial health is a lot easier, and less important than physical and mental health.

Most people know what it takes for both, but won't do it.
 
Most of the posts here imply that their friends and families have less money than them and are less savvy about investments. It is not the same in our situation. We used to work in high tech and the lowest paid staff was making 6 figures. Everyone who worked with us maxed out their 401K. Now that we are retired, we look around at our friends in the (retirement) community, from our estimation, based on their homes, lifestyle and past careers, 90% have way more money than us.
It's hard to say, based on obvious spending, how much $$$ one has.
A lot of it can be borrowed money, even in your latter years...
 
It's hard to say, based on obvious spending, how much $$$ one has.
A lot of it can be borrowed money, even in your latter years...
I am talking about living amoungst $100+M and billionaires in our community. People who own multiple homes in the range of $5M to $20M in several states, spending a few months in each home depending on the seasons. We are their poor friends whom they would not feel comfortable discussing finances with. :)
 
Last edited:
Talking finances with anyone but your absolute closest friends and family (and I mean super close), is a bad idea. No matter what you might think you have in common, it's rarely a good topic. OP is right, it is almost taboo.

At best, it's a party foul. It's inevitably going to reveal who has more, who is doing better, etc., and that's just not good conversation for friends.
That's likely true with your contemporaries.
But if you are coaching your offspring /nephews/nieces, then it can be a different story...
 
I've mentioned this before. When I was a w*rking stiff, I had a very smart colleague who, on her 55th birthday, went down to HR and signed up for the 403(b) benefit (nonprofit equivalent to a 401k)! She said, "I guess I have to start thinking about retirement now."

I couldn't that believe she had wasted her first 25 years at the university not only failing to invest her own money, but also effectively turning down a 12% annual match (IIRC).

-BB
I had a MANDATORY 5% contribution to my 403(b) when I started employment at age 23. This was "matched'" by a 10% employer contribution.

This made a big difference to where I am today...
 
It's worse than that, actually. Not only do people not want to engage when asked about personal finance and retirement, they don't want to truly engage even when they ask YOU about it.

Case in point: a dinner party I attended a few months ago. At some point, while we we all gathered in the kitchen casually talking and chatting as a group, I was asked "And what do you do for a living?". When I mentioned that I was happily ER and had been for some number of years, their eyes opened wide with amazement and they asked me how I did it. But the second I began explaining the power of LBYM and methodically investing in low-cost, passive index funds, everyone's eyes started to glaze over. People really just don't want to hear the boring truth about how to get rich slowly. They really, really don't.
Perhaps you should have focused more on the current day rather than the years that led up to it.
"I focus on managing my investments to keep from paying even more income tax .."
 
My approach is if a family member or friends wants to have an money talk with me, my door is open. But I let them approach me first.

That's my approach as well. Rarely does someone ask.

But it happens on occasion. About 5 years back a colleague asked about retirement (didn't know his exact age, but at least 62, and he'd worked at megacorp for decades). I gave him the 5-minute version: know your spending, subtract SS and pension, and pull 4% from nest egg. I also bought him a copy of A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel.
 
This morning, I am heading over to DD's house with my updated "When I am Gone" book which includes everything she needs to know and do when I go to the other side (I'm 81 now). It includes a big section on finances and copies of account summaries. No surprises is the intent. I trust her and why not?
I've done the same with my two kids, very detailed. Even though they are in their early 20's, they have better money management skills than I did at their age. The more they know, the better off I am when I start to decline or die. In the meantime, I can tweak the dial if I see changes in them that mean trouble in the future.

I have a will with a trusted executor, but we're both in our mid-60's. The family is just the three of us now, and I need people I trust on the "inside".
 
One general question I've asked my friends who are my age (58) is, "Have you started thinking about when you will be retiring?" The general response has been, "I'll probably retire when I'm 65ish" - which seems to be the generic retirement age assumption. No follow-up questions or discussions ensued.
This is not surprising. The majority of people are not good at long term planning, which is required for retirement. Many tend to take more of a "I do not need to think about this, some miracle will occur to allow me to retire". I have seen survey on retirement where more than half of the respondents expect SS to cover half or more of their retirement expenses. Some also assume that they will sell their house and downsize, and that will be enough. In addition, many think once they are on Medicare, the Medicare Part B premium alone will cover their health expenses, and they do not plan ahead for what the actual situation would be.

Long term execution is boring. That's why you'll get folks more excited about playing the lottery (and too many who do play it see that as their retirement plan 😲) that planning for retirement.Even though, as the saying goes, "the 8th wonder of the world is compound interest" :).

A lot of people do not want to admit to making mistakes. I can remember, before the great recession, when day trading was the rage, buying houses with no money down was big, and those was the hot topic in many of our social circles. Both men and women were talking about those being easy ways to build wealth. those things made me too nervous. Then along comes the Great Recession - and soon they became taboo, "hurtful" topics to mention in the same social circles, few wanted to admit it was a mistake, even as they suffered the consequences.

When I was in my 20s, It took several older co-workers a year to convince me to open a 401K account. I was not thinking of retirement at the time, and besides Megacorp had this great pension that would cover all my expenses, right? Fortunately I finally listened - and, about 15 years after opening my 401K, when Megacorp changed the retirement plan so that pensions were reduced and retiree medical pretty much dropped, I at least had a foundation that I could start being more aggressive with my retirement savings (both taxable and non0taxable). But that was not the case with a lot of my co-workers who were in my age range.
 
I've only ever had a successful discussion once. One of my brothers had almost all his money in crypto with FTX. He asked for advice and I helped him create a Vanguard account and move everything to a 3 fund portfolio. This was a few months before the FTX collapse.

That was the only time anyone has listened to me and I'm sure it's because he came to me for advice rather than me trying to start the conversation. Years ago I quit trying to discuss investing with friends and coworkers. Even when people ask me how I retired so young I just smile and say "good luck I suppose". There's no reason to say more - they won't listen and they won't change what they're doing (or not doing).
 
I am talking about living amoungst $100+M and billionaires in our community. People who own multiple homes in the range of $5M to $20M in several states, spending a few months in each home depending on the seasons. We are their poor friends whom they would not feel comfortable discussing finances with. :)
Can be a major temptation to keep up with the Jones, but it sounds like you have your stuff together and are enjoying your lifestyle.
 
Can be a major temptation to keep up with the Jones, but it sounds like you have your stuff together and are enjoying your lifestyle.
I don't think keeping up with the Jones's is RetiredHappy's neighborhood. With 100MM+ and Billionaires as neighbors, I don't even think keeping up with RetiredHappy would be in my realm of possibility.

Flieger
 
Talking finances with anyone but your absolute closest friends and family (and I mean super close), is a bad idea. No matter what you might think you have in common, it's rarely a good topic. OP is right, it is almost taboo.

At best, it's a party foul. It's inevitably going to reveal who has more, who is doing better, etc., and that's just not good conversation for friends.
Yes the taboo subjects for parties is religion, politics and money!
 
Can be a major temptation to keep up with the Jones, but it sounds like you have your stuff together and are enjoying your lifestyle.
Yep, we attend their functions/dinners when we get invited. We golf and hang out together. They are regular people, same humor etc. We are "comfortable" and they are rich! :)
 
1736694811100.png
 
Back
Top Bottom