Domestic first class worth the $?

We recently did a 3+ hour domestic flight and booked first class tickets. The basic fare would be about $250 and the first class costed about $750 each.

The pluses are that you get on first and have plenty space for your carry-on. Nice in flight hot meals and extra leg room.

On the other hand, you don't get admission to the airport lounge.

Talking to DW, we could have brought some very fancy food for $400. And we are not very tall and extra space is nice but not necessary.

We had done first class international flights where you could lay flat for the 10+ hour flights. The lay flat feature and access to the lounge could justify the 5~7X price, IMHO. The food and the drinks are not because one could buy some really nice food items for the $5000.

We are projected to have $15K a month to spend in our retirement (still working as of today). In theory we should have $ to cover first class travel. But we will think twice for short domestic flights. What are your experiences and options?
I was thinking the same thing, is it worth it for domestic flights, but then I said what the heck, you only live once. We too have a $15K a month spending budget, and I'm six years into retirement. DW and I will be celebrating our 45th wedding anniversary soon and will be flying first class to a domestic destination and only a 1 1/2-hour flight. So, I say if you want and can afford, go for it.
 
It’s always worth it for me nowadays. I will happy pay through the nose to board first and be assured of overhead bin space and extra leg room. Besides, compared to international flights, domestic first class is rather inexpensive.
 
We have a very special privilege of flying standby and it's free for within US and INT it's like we only pay the taxes ~200/. ...
...This is the 20% off price for us...
My daughter has these perks with her job (I'm on her "list" so I do, too). I'm still working to figure out the rules.
 
Is it worth it? It’s your choice. You’ve worked hard and earned the ability to do as you please.
 
I've never flown first class and thought about it, but knowing my luck I'd get stuck next to some village idiot with a screaming brat next to or behind me and making it a total waste of time and money. IMO you should have to be at least 16 to fly first class.
 
I've never flown first class and thought about it, but knowing my luck I'd get stuck next to some village idiot with a screaming brat next to or behind me and making it a total waste of time and money. IMO you should have to be at least 16 to fly first class.
I've always thought there should be a section for those with young kids. The kids section should have plexiglass around it to keep the sound inside. I've sat close to kids who screamed for 5 hours on a flight. At first I felt sorry for them (thinking perhaps they couldn't clear their ears.) Before the flight was through, my thoughts were much darker. May God forgive me.
 
We just experienced an international business class redeye with I think 8 toddlers and/or babies. 30 seats, so 15 pairs of seats and 8 of them had little kids! Screamed and cried and ran around the aisles all the way from DC to Jeddah. Thankful for the provided noise canceling headphones and ear plugs.

The leg from Jeddah to Jakarta had no kids in a smaller cabin.
 
We recently did a 3+ hour domestic flight and booked first class tickets. The basic fare would be about $250 and the first class costed about $750 each.

The pluses are that you get on first and have plenty space for your carry-on. Nice in flight hot meals and extra leg room.

On the other hand, you don't get admission to the airport lounge.

Talking to DW, we could have brought some very fancy food for $400. And we are not very tall and extra space is nice but not necessary.

We had done first class international flights where you could lay flat for the 10+ hour flights. The lay flat feature and access to the lounge could justify the 5~7X price, IMHO. The food and the drinks are not because one could buy some really nice food items for the $5000.

We are projected to have $15K a month to spend in our retirement (still working as of today). In theory we should have $ to cover first class travel. But we will think twice for short domestic flights. What are your experiences and options?
This is one of those expenses that's difficult to come to a conclusion about because it's so entirely subjective. My opinion is that it's absolutely not worth it, but I do it anyway. I like this logic because it helps me make cleaner decisions and keeps me away from believing my own bs. For example we have a standby generator at our house. And we have those mini split heat pumps for air conditioning and backup heating. I don't believe that either one of those isn't intelligent use of money, I think we've spent $5 for every $1 in value and for a first class ticket we're spending $10 for every $1 and value, but we can afford it, and there are benefits that we appreciate. That's the problem with articulating and coming to a rational judgment about some of these luxuries. When we ask ourselves is it worth it, all sorts of crazy circuit breakers go off in our head. I will first class because I'm 6'4, and I appreciate being treated like royalty from time to time. It makes me feel rich. And I think it's good for a person to feel rich because they'll attract will be attracted to paths toward more richness. That's a little metaphysical but I think there's some truth wrapped up in there somewhere.
 
This is one of those expenses that's difficult to come to a conclusion about because it's so entirely subjective. My opinion is that it's absolutely not worth it, but I do it anyway.
+1. My dad always said about owning a big boat: "If you try to rationalize it by putting a dollar figure to it, you'd never do it. You do it because you love doing it".

Whether boating, skiing, luxury cars, flying First or other expensive ventures, it has little to do with what it costs. It's about understanding the value of something vs the cost of it.

Used to go skiing with a guy who'd divide his ticket price by the number of runs he made. "I did $X per run today" . I always wanted to slap him!
 
Last edited:
Is it worth it? We can’t tell you. In this context “worth” is completely subjective.

For me, flying isn’t worth it. If I absolutely have to fly, it will be first class.
 
For domestic, I do economy plus and then use my points to attempt an upgrade. Exception being Hawaii where I just purchase first.
 
Each to their own. We can afford first class seats but can't see the value.

If we really wanted more room we'd just book 3 economy seats together.
 
If we really wanted more room we'd just book 3 economy seats together.
I don't think that works though. Most airlines require a passenger name to book a seat, and don't allow duplicates.

Even if they do, if oversold, they can and will take that empty seat and give it to someone else.
And I think we've all had our pre-assigned seats snatched at some point.

Anyway, it might work sometimes, but not most of the time.
 
I don't think that works though. Most airlines require a passenger name to book a seat, and don't allow duplicates.

Even if they do, if oversold, they can and will take that empty seat and give it to someone else.
And I think we've all had our pre-assigned seats snatched at some point.

Anyway, it might work sometimes, but not most of the time.
Most airlines require those with special physical needs or who might be severely obese to book two seats. JetBlue has a tick box you can check to purchase and exrea seat for any reason. "Check here if this is an extra seat". This insures that your name is assigned to both seats.

I know one guy who not only buys the entire row on both sides,but also the row in front of him if possible on flights without first class seating. BIL did it a few times and when someone tried to grab the open seat as the doors closed, the FA removed them.

Even in First I've flown with a few celebrities (in the days before everyone flew private) and they always bought the seat next to them. (One exception: I sat next to a member of the band Slipknot from Narita to Minneapolis...interesting flight)
 
Last edited:
I don't think that works though. Most airlines require a passenger name to book a seat, and don't allow duplicates.

Even if they do, if oversold, they can and will take that empty seat and give it to someone else.
And I think we've all had our pre-assigned seats snatched at some point.

Anyway, it might work sometimes, but not most of the time.
It does, musicians with larger instruments do it all the time. You do need to check in for both seats or they may give it away to standbys.
 
I don't think that works though. Most airlines require a passenger name to book a seat, and don't allow duplicates.

Even if they do, if oversold, they can and will take that empty seat and give it to someone else.
And I think we've all had our pre-assigned seats snatched at some point.

Anyway, it might work sometimes, but not most of the time.
You can buy an extra seat on all US based airlines.

Usually there is a special designation on the ticket so it doesn't have an exact duplicate name and there are endorsements to connect them so the airline doesn't accidentally separate the seats if they change aircraft (that doesn't always work, but they do try). For most airlines, this is not something you can do yourself by booking online. You generally have to call and do it over the phone.

For example, here are Delta's instructions for how travel agents should code this: Extra Seat - Personal Comfort
 
Each to their own. We can afford first class seats but can't see the value.

If we really wanted more room we'd just book 3 economy seats together.
Knowing my luck, they'd have people trying to get on an overbooked flight and try to use my seat. But if I paid for it, a very heated debate would ensue...

I get not seeing the value as well, but at least once in my life I'd like to, esp if its a long flight. Although really I hate the idea of flying in general and it's almost all because I have the worst luck with idiot passengers with brats that don't behave.
 
Knowing my luck, they'd have people trying to get on an overbooked flight and try to use my seat. But if I paid for it, a very heated debate would ensue...
See posts #116, 117 and 118.
 
Each to their own. We can afford first class seats but can't see the value.

If we really wanted more room we'd just book 3 economy seats together.
Now there's an idea that never occurred to me. I kinda like it. What "name" do you apply to the seat when you buy the extra ticket?

But if you buy the extra seat, can they put someone in that seat? In theory, flight crews CAN move people around against their will. I don't know that it's done that often, but flight crews have virtual autonomy in the sky. Just wondering.
 
Now there's an idea that never occurred to me. I kinda like it. What "name" do you apply to the seat when you buy the extra ticket?

But if you buy the extra seat, can they put someone in that seat? In theory, flight crews CAN move people around against their will. I don't know that it's done that often, but flight crews have virtual autonomy in the sky. Just wondering.
I'm not sure, but has my question been answered above? Anybody with "real world" experience been able to "keep" their extra seat when someone else wanted to take it? What about overbooking - when someone wanted to take it away from you just because it was empty?

Inquiring minds want to know. Sounds like lots of opinions but not sure we know for certain how this w*rks in reality. Thanks.
 
I'm not sure, but has my question been answered above? Anybody with "real world" experience been able to "keep" their extra seat when someone else wanted to take it? What about overbooking - when someone wanted to take it away from you just because it was empty?

Inquiring minds want to know. Sounds like lots of opinions but not sure we know for certain how this w*rks in reality. Thanks.
See posts #116, 117 a 118. As noted in 116, there's often a "check here if this is an extra seat" tick box when making a reservation. As noted in 118, some airlines you have to call, but all US airlines allow this.

I always fly up front but know a few people, BIL is one, and an other acquaintance, who do this regularly. You bought the seat, you own the seat.

FAs have a list and will remove anyone who tries to sit there who isn't you. (Recent lack of respect and decorum on airplanes-- fighting-- could create interesting situations however)
 
Last edited:
Interesting to know that could work - but for someone "normal"? No instrument, not obese, no medical conditions? Just book at pay for the row of 3 seats when there's just two of you? I had read a story of someone doing this but getting the seat taken by the FA.

I might give that a try one of these days on a domestic fight. Give us a little extra room, no 3rd person in the way.
Knowing my luck, they'd have people trying to get on an overbooked flight and try to use my seat. But if I paid for it, a very heated debate would ensue...
That is never a good idea, easy way to get yourself kicked off the flight.
 
Back
Top Bottom