Finding a new financial advisor

Happily Retired 2019

Dryer sheet aficionado
Joined
May 25, 2024
Messages
31
Location
Long Island
I have Wells Fargo handling my investing. My Financial Advisor is a "no show". Although we have told him we would like to touch base with him quarterly, he never does. We call him and he just tells us all is good. I am going to be 70 in 2 months and would like to know the strategy for RMD's but he tells me do not worry about it because we have until 73 years old. He moved to Florida (I live in New York) and it seems he teamed up with another advisor but both remain with Wells.
Anyway, I am looking for a new financial advisor. I was thinking of going with Mercer Advisors but have not pulled the trigger. Can anyone give me the names of some of the good companies and has anyone dealt with Mercer. Also what are the most important questions to ask a new financial advisor?
Thank you all. Happy New Year!
 
HR, I have a very good advisor that I use (and have used for the past 6 years). He is a small independent (not part of a large firm) and is accessible and responsive whenever I need to reach him. In fact, we’re meeting him for dinner tonight which will be more of a social get together than to talk finances.

I think the most important things to ask/ discuss with a FA is that their investment and wealth strategies are aligned with yours. We retired 2 1/2 years ago and were well set up for retirement having worked with him for 3-4 years prior.

He is located in NJ and would be happy to meet with you if you’re interested. Please send me a private message so we can talk further and I can give you his contact info.
 
I have Wells Fargo handling my investing. My Financial Advisor is a "no show". Although we have told him we would like to touch base with him quarterly, he never does. We call him and he just tells us all is good. I am going to be 70 in 2 months and would like to know the strategy for RMD's but he tells me do not worry about it because we have until 73 years old. He moved to Florida (I live in New York) and it seems he teamed up with another advisor but both remain with Wells.
Anyway, I am looking for a new financial advisor. I was thinking of going with Mercer Advisors but have not pulled the trigger. Can anyone give me the names of some of the good companies and has anyone dealt with Mercer. Also what are the most important questions to ask a new financial advisor?
Thank you all. Happy New Year!
How are your fees currently set up? Is it a percentage of assets?

If you feel you need an advisor, I strongly suggest you find one that charges by the hour. Anybody charging something like 1% is robbing you blind.
 
If your broker isn't calling on you like you asked him to, just switch your account to another Financial Planner. He'll call you right away.

On a serious note, I would look into Vanguard. I know they charge well under 1% AUM and I think they could provide you with service you are looking for.
 
For $400/yr PlanVision will set you up with some basic index funds, give you access to e-Money that will let you look at things like asset allocation and have a meeting with the advisor.
 
For a long time, I thought I needed an "advisor." Then I discovered Do-It-Yourself. It's not that complicated, really. Most of the time, my funds are on auto-pilot and more or less manage themselves at Vanguard (no advisor - so no .3% fee).

The biggest issue you probably face is deciding what your Asset Allocation should be. From there, choose two to maybe five Mutual Funds with equities and bonds and play those off against each other with a decent cash-like fund. It's not rocket science. Lots of help available right here (though keep in mind that we take no responsibility for advice).

Set your financial goals and start managing yourself. If you aren't perfect at it, that's okay. Neither is your advisor - and you are always there to consult with yourself about YOUR money. You don't need to depend on someone to tell you what to do.

Best luck!!
 
We have used Evanson Asset Management since about 2007. Evanson charges a flat fee. I have paid $2,000 per year since I started with them but I believe their minimum annual fee is now $2,500, paid quarterly. Unless you have a crazy amount of accounts and/or trusts, that should be your annual cost. We started with a 1% fee advisor in 2006 (I think) and paying that fee got real old real quick. The % fee concept made no sense to me because the effort by the advisor is the same no matter the actual numbers being used. Luckily, I found Evanson and have been with them ever since. They use primarily DFA mutual funds so if you like to do a lot of buying and selling, this won't work for you. I've never met my planner. We communicate (infrequently) by phone and email. The company doesn't even send out Christmas cards. Bare bones. He's a super-smart nerd and I enjoy talking to him. My husband has to take RMD's so someone from Evanson makes sure we take them every year. He will tell us which account he thinks it should come out of.

As I learned more about managing our portfolio, I debated not using an advisor but my husband would definitely need help if I pre-deceased him so I've kept Evanson. When I was still working, I asked my advisor to review a list of mutual funds from which we had the opportunity to add a fund to the 401(k) line-up at the smaller family-owned business I worked for. He gave some very good advice and I made a nice chunk of money that defrayed the annual fee for about 10 years! All our assets under management are held at Schwab.

My neighbor inherited a couple million dollars from her father when he passed. Both she and her father had been using Wells Fargo advisors and paying their ridiculous fees for years. She showed me her dad's statements a couple of times before he passed and I saw some very shady stuff going on. She is 100% clueless about managing a portfolio and gets freaked out when I ask her questions. One day, we called her broker and she put the call on speakerphone so I could ask some questions. They had no good answers for my questions. They made one move that cost her dad $100,000 in taxes and raised his Medicare IRMAA. I was livid and tried to get her to at least do a call with my planner but she's afraid to change. At least Wells Fargo dropped the fee from 1% to .6% because they were afraid they were going to lose the account because of the questions they were getting. It still raises my blood pressure when I think about them still managing her money.
 
Quit messing around with this guy. He obviously has no interest in keeping you as a client. I would either request a new advisor or move your money to another brokerage.
 
Not of fan of socializing with an advisor. This should be a business arrangement so that
if the results are poor, it's easier to cut ties and move on. The advisor knows this and will
most of the time try to be your friend, makes it harder to leave him/her.
This is good time to look at hourly advisors and save some AUM money.
 
Only advisors any normal person should use are hourly advisors that have no tie in to any of the financial transactions anyone does. They are there for advice, not to profit off ones portfolio.
 
Not of fan of socializing with an advisor. This should be a business arrangement so that
if the results are poor, it's easier to cut ties and move on. The advisor knows this and will
most of the time try to be your friend, makes it harder to leave him/her.
This is good time to look at hourly advisors and save some AUM money.
This. Selecting an advisor is very little different from selecting a lawn care company. You want someone you at least like and that you trust to do a good job. If the job is not done well and/or if the relationship becomes unpleasant, move on. Same-o if the price becomes unacceptable due to lower competition or to price increases.
 
Beyond a certain level of net worth ($1M tops, perhaps even lower) an advisor charging a % of net worth is not worth it. Not even Vanguard at 0.3%. Flat fee, hourly or DIY is the way to go. I wouldn't touch Wells with a 10 foot pole.
 
Most people here are against FA's. I have 2 humble suggestions to the OP: 1) Solely as a short term stop-gap measure, immediately move all your funds from this FA, 50% to an equities index fund and 50% to a conservative Index Bond fund (or cash). 2) Then look for a new FA at leisure, or decide to DIY. You are paying this FA for service, and you're not getting service.
 
Beyond a certain level of net worth ($1M tops, perhaps even lower) an advisor charging a % of net worth is not worth it. Not even Vanguard at 0.3%. Flat fee, hourly or DIY is the way to go. I wouldn't touch Wells with a 10 foot pole.
Agreed. I did this for a while some years back. I gave a FA part of my NW to manage. After about 7 years, his rate of return was lower than mine (before the fee) and I took the money back.
 
For a long time, I thought I needed an "advisor." Then I discovered Do-It-Yourself. It's not that complicated, really.
Yes, I feel as though we have been slighted, we aren't good enough for him! /s/ :cool:
 
For $400/yr PlanVision will set you up with some basic index funds, give you access to e-Money that will let you look at things like asset allocation and have a meeting with the advisor.
Exchme, you have given an awesome recommendation and it seems too good to be true with Plan Vision. I am going to give them a call since I am all over the place and hitting the magical date when I need to start getting serious about Retirement Planning, Estate Planning and also organizing my financial life! Thank you SO MUCH.

Sunrise Ray
 
What are you looking for the FA to advise you on? AA and what to invest in are so simple to answer with a little help from the internet that carrying an advisor just for that is worthless.

Where they earn their keep is estate planning, tax advising, and withdrawal strategies. Even those are easily handled by yourself except for the estate planning, in which case I would probably consult an estate attorney rather than a financial advisor.

Now if you want help with specific items you are unsure about, those would be the exact questions I would ask a potential advisor. Like others have said, AUM fees are a ripoff, you need to find someone that can do hourly or flat fee planning. Tell them what you have invested, and what estate planning you already have in place. Then ask them what advise they would give you going forward. If you get brushed off move on. If you find someone willing to engage, that's your guy.
 
I decided to tag on to the post instead of stating anew one since I m looking for similar answers.

My wife and I went to a retirement seminar last night. It is a small independent (2 person) office. They did the typical "what happens when the market turns". They feel they have an algorithm that allows them to move in and out of the market before large losses (They agree no one has a crystal ball). We are meeting with them on Monday. If we do decide to use them, it will only be for. portion of our accounts. This portion would normally be 100% in stocks. One question I have for him is When he thinks money needs to come out, where does he put it? I will also find out about fees. Any other questions?
 
I decided to tag on to the post instead of stating anew one since I m looking for similar answers.

My wife and I went to a retirement seminar last night. It is a small independent (2 person) office. They did the typical "what happens when the market turns". They feel they have an algorithm that allows them to move in and out of the market before large losses (They agree no one has a crystal ball). We are meeting with them on Monday. If we do decide to use them, it will only be for. portion of our accounts. This portion would normally be 100% in stocks. One question I have for him is When he thinks money needs to come out, where does he put it? I will also find out about fees. Any other questions?
I wouldn't believe anyone who thinks that they can move in and out of the market before large losses.

Buy a stock index fund with VG, Fido, CS and let it ride.

I hired a FA 30 years ago. I would have twice the money (or more) today if I had just invested consistently in the VG Total Stock Market Fund and never made a trade.

Oh, other questions. Ask him about taxes. Especially short term sales. Commissions and front end loads would be another good question, as would AUM fees and the internal fees on the funds he may put you in. If it is sleeve of individual stocks.....walk.
 
They feel they have an algorithm that allows them to move in and out of the market before large losses
Yes, as Stormy mentioned, there are many more questions. Like how does their alleged algorithm work, and what are the tax effects of all those in and out moves.
 
Back
Top Bottom