BigMoneyJim
Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
Donner, my last remark wasn't constructive at all. You are insightful and welcome at the board. I disagree with a lot of your points of view, but the goal here I think is informative conversation and not to create a personality cult or cheering squad.
As far as taking action to intervene in discussions when they turn ugly, the biggest problem is that no one can agree when the right time to take action is. It's very subjective and inherently biased. Intervention would shift the griping to discussions of moderator policies; I've seen this at other boards.
The good news is that this board in general self-moderates better than anywhere else I've been. Unfortunately it's still been heated enough that some users have either stomped off or faded away. All I can offer is that we are now actively splitting out off-topic arguments from threadjacked topics so it's easier to ignore marginally related hotbutton arguments while discussing a financial/ER topic.
As far as taking action to intervene in discussions when they turn ugly, the biggest problem is that no one can agree when the right time to take action is. It's very subjective and inherently biased. Intervention would shift the griping to discussions of moderator policies; I've seen this at other boards.
The good news is that this board in general self-moderates better than anywhere else I've been. Unfortunately it's still been heated enough that some users have either stomped off or faded away. All I can offer is that we are now actively splitting out off-topic arguments from threadjacked topics so it's easier to ignore marginally related hotbutton arguments while discussing a financial/ER topic.