Right, unless someone does an excessively large Roth conversion and gets into the 32% Federal tax bracket whereas if they had just done RMDs later on, they would be in the 22% or 24% marginal bracket.Huh? Odds are you’ll pay higher taxes now or later, so it’s a legit spend whenever. If your taxes are among your top spending categories now (and/or later), and it’s certainly mandatory per the IRS…
Presumably they would have been in a higher tax bracket later if they had not converting into the 32% bracket. And the OP didn't ask whether spending was mandatory or not...Right, unless someone does an excessively large Roth conversion and gets into the 32% Federal tax bracket whereas if they had just done RMDs later on, they would be in the 22% or 24% marginal bracket.
In that case, the extra Federal tax certainly wasn't mandatory...
But it's N/A to this thread as you're not "spending" it....really I meant more personal/"fun" expenses, what are you doing with the money you have options with, not mandatory expenses.
I'm kind of a stickler on the point of separating this. I "get" that if it's money that leaves your fist, it's "gone", but how gone is it?Every dollar that flies out of my grasp, never to return again is an expense.
That was my point. If the money flies out and has no way back, it is an expense. Everything else is rearranging the chairs, as they say.I'm kind of a stickler on the point of separating this. I "get" that if it's money that leaves your fist, it's "gone", but how gone is it?
When I see "spend", I think not just money out of your hands, but money that's no longer on the balance sheet.
So a kitchen remodel. Hmm. I'm afraid that's not quite "gone" enough for me. That expense increased the size of one of your biggest assets...your house. So while it's fuzzy, it's not quite as "gone" as money you spend on travel or something. This is personal, and your opinion is as valid as any other. Mine has cars in the "gone" category, because cars are depreciating assets. But if you have a collectable car, that might be considered an asset, for instance. If that's your hobby, a new collectable could be anywhere from "gone" to "invested", but that has an emotional component...it's about what it would sell for today, not "what it's worth"
The thread was supposed to be about fun expenses, but as noted, that wasn't made very clear, and thread drift is what we do here. We're retired, what else do we have to do, hehehe! So we have another dimension to split out: whether we "have to" incur some expense, like taxes and other mandatory expenses, along with whether it adds to the balance sheet. I would have liked to make this an interactive app, where you could write your own post it notes and move them around, but I took ideas from the thread and pasted them in the quadrants. Things like house renovation can span invested and gone because if you, say, added a deck yourself, and the buyer falls in love with your place because of the deck and pays full price, you probably made money on that spend (positive return on your investment). If you made a questionable home renovation just because you wanted it, and buyers could take it or leave it, you probably got a poor ROI, so at least some, maybe all of that money is gone. Some may argue an RV has a bit of investment, but anything that depreciates that fast, I'm putting in the "gone" quadrant.
View attachment 52168
Good chart. However, I would think Home maintenance might fall between invested and gone. It seems to be more of a gray area. We replaced our roof. That’s maintenance, but it keeps the value of our house. Some people may look at is the moneys gone, but the new roof increased or should have increased our home value.I'm kind of a stickler on the point of separating this. I "get" that if it's money that leaves your fist, it's "gone", but how gone is it?
When I see "spend", I think not just money out of your hands, but money that's no longer on the balance sheet.
So a kitchen remodel. Hmm. I'm afraid that's not quite "gone" enough for me. That expense increased the size of one of your biggest assets...your house. So while it's fuzzy, it's not quite as "gone" as money you spend on travel or something. This is personal, and your opinion is as valid as any other. Mine has cars in the "gone" category, because cars are depreciating assets. But if you have a collectable car, that might be considered an asset, for instance. If that's your hobby, a new collectable could be anywhere from "gone" to "invested", but that has an emotional component...it's about what it would sell for today, not "what it's worth"
The thread was supposed to be about fun expenses, but as noted, that wasn't made very clear, and thread drift is what we do here. We're retired, what else do we have to do, hehehe! So we have another dimension to split out: whether we "have to" incur some expense, like taxes and other mandatory expenses, along with whether it adds to the balance sheet. I would have liked to make this an interactive app, where you could write your own post it notes and move them around, but I took ideas from the thread and pasted them in the quadrants. Things like house renovation can span invested and gone because if you, say, added a deck yourself, and the buyer falls in love with your place because of the deck and pays full price, you probably made money on that spend (positive return on your investment). If you made a questionable home renovation just because you wanted it, and buyers could take it or leave it, you probably got a poor ROI, so at least some, maybe all of that money is gone. Some may argue an RV has a bit of investment, but anything that depreciates that fast, I'm putting in the "gone" quadrant.
View attachment 52168