The perpetual conflict over a service like ValueLine is why they bother to sell their analysis when they could just [-]eat their own cooking[/-] invest and grow rich on millions without having to waste their time picking up subscription pennies.
You would also think that the mutual funds based on ValueLine analysis would outperform some appropriate index.
If you insist on using newsletters, I'd suggest evaluating ValueLine against the rest of the crowd by reviewing Hulbert's Financial Digest. Hulbert's not free, but he's a lot cheaper than ValueLine and much more objective.
MarketWatch.com