I voted for the income/dividend portfolio yet I have both. My DW and I have Roth accts which consist of Wellington, Wellesley, Reit Index and High yld Corp bond and High Dividend yield. Our IRA's and 401k consist of a mix of stock and bond funds, mostly index, with a planned total return distribution in retirement.
This goes against the conventional wisdom of placing your highest potential growth investments in a Roth account. However our objective is to draw only dividends from the Roth with no RMD down the road. This can then be passed on to our heirs.
The IRA's and 401k will be drawn down at approx a 4% rate using a TR method with rebalancing to maintain the AA.