While looking at my 2016 taxes I noticed a rabbit hole I didn't know about.
If your in a state without income tax you could well be itemizing and taking the sales tax deduction. Part of the calculation that you can see in the sales tax worksheet is the calculation of a special AGI.
The tax s/w I was using put quite a small value in my AGI because it removed the conversions I did from IRA to Roth IRA despite these not being part of AGI in the first place (it removed total conversion amount rather than just the gain). I had to enter the conversions differently to avoid this.
It's worth looking at this AGI since somebody who is retired could have quite a few adjustments and it's quite vague about whats allowed:
From schedule A instructions
Your 2016 income is the amount shown on your Form 1040, line 38, plus any nontaxable items, such as the following.
Tax-exempt interest.
Veterans' benefits.
Nontaxable combat pay.
Workers' compensation.
Nontaxable part of social security and railroad retirement benefits.
Nontaxable part of IRA, pension, or annuity distributions. Don't include rollovers.
Public assistance payments.
So things you might had are the exclusion for the sale of a primary residence, actual capital gains rather then those offset by losses (see how they calculate total income in form 1116), non-dividend distributions, capital gains distributions offset by losses, maybe even principle of asset sales (though I won't go this far). My tax s/w already adds in municipal bond interest and tax exempt dividends.
The basic idea is this is an estimate of your spending power and that's used with a table lookup to determine how much tax you might have spent. The IRC seems silent on this issue except to pass it off to the IRS to determine how it works.
Fixing the bug and adding in some extra stuff pushed me up two slots in the table.
If your in a state without income tax you could well be itemizing and taking the sales tax deduction. Part of the calculation that you can see in the sales tax worksheet is the calculation of a special AGI.
The tax s/w I was using put quite a small value in my AGI because it removed the conversions I did from IRA to Roth IRA despite these not being part of AGI in the first place (it removed total conversion amount rather than just the gain). I had to enter the conversions differently to avoid this.
It's worth looking at this AGI since somebody who is retired could have quite a few adjustments and it's quite vague about whats allowed:
From schedule A instructions
Your 2016 income is the amount shown on your Form 1040, line 38, plus any nontaxable items, such as the following.
Tax-exempt interest.
Veterans' benefits.
Nontaxable combat pay.
Workers' compensation.
Nontaxable part of social security and railroad retirement benefits.
Nontaxable part of IRA, pension, or annuity distributions. Don't include rollovers.
Public assistance payments.
So things you might had are the exclusion for the sale of a primary residence, actual capital gains rather then those offset by losses (see how they calculate total income in form 1116), non-dividend distributions, capital gains distributions offset by losses, maybe even principle of asset sales (though I won't go this far). My tax s/w already adds in municipal bond interest and tax exempt dividends.
The basic idea is this is an estimate of your spending power and that's used with a table lookup to determine how much tax you might have spent. The IRC seems silent on this issue except to pass it off to the IRS to determine how it works.
Fixing the bug and adding in some extra stuff pushed me up two slots in the table.
Last edited: