ferco said:
This is all very confusing ! If I bought 100 shares of XYZ mutual fund or stock in 1999 @ $32/share and bought 10 shares per year at different prices('00-'05) and decided to sell 75 shares in '06, I would need to calculate the cost basis for EACH of the years purchases to report to the IRS.....? You've got to be kidding....There has to be an easier way.
ferco,
There is an easier way, but it isn't available to everyone. IF your MF company provides an average cost basis for your shares that covers the entire time you've been investing with them, then you can simply use that figure when you sell shares. This is the simplest way to do things. But:
-- Your MF company must have the purchase data for the entire time you've been purchasing funds in that account, and must use all the years of data in computing your average cost. I think most MF companies only started to do this within about the last 10 years.
-- Using the "average cost" method will not allow you to minimize your taxes through use of more sophisticated techniques. For example, if you use the "specific shares" method (identifying exactly which shares you sold, by the purchase date), you can do "tax loss harvesting" if the share price has declined when you sell. Example: You've been buying a few shares every month over a period of 5 years, and the share price has been rising over the whole time, until just this month, when share prices dropped. The average price you paid for the shares over the whole period was $8.00, the price at the beginning of last month was $12.00, but now the shares are worth just $6.00. Say that today you sold 100 shares and received $600. If you use the "average cost" method, your loss (for tax purposes) would be $200 (you bought the 100 shares for an average price of $8 and sold them for $6). But, if you use the "specific shares" method, you could identify the shares you bought at the highest prices (in this example, probably the ones you bought just before the price drop) and show a bigger loss for tax purposes. Two caveats:
--- Once you use this method, you can never go back to using the simpler "average cost" method. You're now stuck with the need to identify which specific shares you are selling as long as you have that account.
--- When you do this tax loss harvesting, all you are doing is deferring taxes (you have to sell those shares you bought cheaply someday, after all). Most people hope they'll be in a lower tax bracket or have offsetting deductions when the cheap shares must eventualy be sold ( or they plan to gift/will the shares to others).
There are vaiations on this theme: You can use FIFO (First In- First Out), which means you sell the shares in the order you bought them. You can also use average costs by short-term and long-term holding periods.
As for me -- I use the average cost computed by Vanguard. I miss out on the ability to save a few bucks with more sophisticated strategies, but it is much simpler.