What does "Best Picture" really mean? Best made, best directed/acted, best story/dialog, most intense effect on the viewer, most memorable weeks/months later, most unique, most effective music/art direction/costuming, pushes an envelope in filmmaking?
I've never seen inner turmoil so well depicted in a movie as in Brokeback Mtn. The grandeur of the scenery juxtaposed with the personal problems of the characters and wider problems of society worked really well for me, enhanced by the spare and mysterious original music.
I saw Crash last night at home. Man, was it depressing and unnerving, but fantastic acting and editing. Both scenes with Thandie Newton and Matt Dillon left me shaking. Why wasn't Thandie Newton nominated for Supporting Actress? Terence Howard--amzing, Sandra Bullock--didn't knwo she had it in her so kudos to the director. also the 2 young guys playing the car theives--mesmerizing. I got sucked into almost every character--what a rare thing.
I watch the Oscars every year, hoping to see useful clips from the films I haven't seen--I often see a movie later based on these clips (not based at all on whether the film won anything). I can barely tolerate the speeches, presenter and emcee patter, the "required elements," the fashion crap--I often mute that stuff.