We have one rental property, but it is our former home. We did not buy it as an investment property but decided to relocate and want to preserve the opportunity to live in it again down the road if we choose. So far the return hasn’t been great and our income is too high to get any tax benefit, so financially we would be better off in the stock market for sure.
We also have about 20% of our portfolio in hard money loans. The return hasn’t been nearly as good as the market, but we view it as a diversification tool. The return is way higher than bonds so we have most of the rest of our portfolio in equities. These loans are held in my IRA, and could be a good source of cash flow if we wanted or had to take IRA distributions. However the return is variable over time (when a loan pays off the cash may sit idle for a month or more before reinvestment) so I wouldn’t want to count on it as a required part of our cash flow.
Generally real estate has not performed as well as the stock market over time. Unless you really crave being a landlord, or you like the idea of hard money loans, a diversified REIT can give you exposure to the category without the headaches.