Katsmeow
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2009
- Messages
- 5,308
I have a car conundrum where I am really uncertain about what to do.
Primary choices right now are to either (1) buy a Volvo XC40 right now knowing that we will have to pay around MSRP, (2) buy a Volvo XC60 right now and get a "normal" discount off MSRP, or (3) wait until prices come down on the XC40 eventually and buy then but this option requires first repairing the car we are planning to sell so we can drive it in the meantime. I don't really like any of those choices.
Here is the situation.
DH and I had planned to buy a new car right about now. We have 2 cars right now. We plan to keep as our second car our Ford Explorer that we bought 7 years ago. We will probably keep it another 3 years or so.
We prefer to most likely buy a new car. We keep our cars a long time and I like to have the latest features.
The plan was to buy an SUV, but it did not need to be as large as the Explorer (197 in. long). I was focusing mostly on the 5 seaters that are around the mid 180s in length.
I've been researching it and we've test driven a number of cars in that price range. We found some that we liked (2019 Hyundai Santa Fe) but nothing that really made us feel enthusiastic like we really wanted the car.
We decided to test drive the Volve XC40 which is about 175 in. long. We had not planned to buy a car that size but I wanted to see if I felt it was large enough. We both loved the car. It was night and day how we feel about it as compared to anything else. Right now MSRP for that car with the options we want is between $42k and $43k. If we could get our exact options it would be around $41k but there are none like that to be found.
The probably is that the XC40 is an extremely popular car right now. Inventory is very low. The car is selling around list price (sometimes over). I think I could get it for list price but not significantly below.
I do think that at some point the car will be discounted normally. I don't know when that will be. It might be 6 months or more.
While this car is more that what we had originally budgeted, DH and I both agree that we can up that budget. Buying at MSRP, it is more over budget although we could do it without a lot of angst. The bigger issue is simply knowing that eventually we would be able to buy it well below list price.
While at the dealer we looked at the XC60. Some years ago we almost bought one but at the time there was no inventory to be had (a wait of about 6 months). It is larger than we really need now, but is still smaller than the Explorer. I like it and the XC40 very similarly.
An XC60 with the options that I want is about $52k. I would not feel it was worth it to pay $10k more for an XC60 than the XC40. But, the XC60 is a normally discounted vehicle. I can probably get one for $4k to $5k more than the XC40 right now.
The third option is to simply wait until the XC40 comes down in price. That in some ways is my preference. But -- there is an issue. On the car we plan to sell, it needs a repair to the front end which is causing excess wear to the tires. It is driveable but if we don't repair it, then we might need to soon replace tires. For the last couple of months we haven't been driving it as we planned to sell it when we got the new car. It didn't seem to make sense to spend money on a repair.
DH absolutely hates us only having one car to drive. He doesn't like it when I go somewhere and then he can't go anywhere until I get back. He doesn't like having to arrange his errands to when I am home. So if we are going to wait months to buy a car he wants to get that car repaired. At this point, I have no idea what it will cost to do the repair. The car is worth around $8k so I don't want to spend a lot of money on a repair and then sell the car in 3 to 6 months (thereby using up all or part of the savings that we got from waiting to buy the XC40).
I am having a hard time deciding what to do. We don't know how long it will take for prices to come down on the XC40.
I don't like the idea of paying MSRP on a car just on general principle, knowing the price will come down eventually. The car salesman was very clear that prices will eventually come down.
I slightly prefer the larger size of the XC60 from a safety standpoint, but I really don't need the larger vehicle since we have the Explorer for when we need a large vehicle. So, I am not enthralled with going that much over our budget although we could do it.
I don't feel any of the choices are great. Yes, we could switch cars to something else. But, this are the only cars we have been enthusiastic about so that would also be a compromise.
Right now, I am inclined to find out how much the repair on our existing car will cost. If it is exorbitant then we just go ahead and get a car now (not sure which). One issue with that is that there are a couple of XC40s available now that are acceptable to me. That might not be true by the time we could get that information. At that point, we might have to wait due to lack of supply. On the other hand, if the cost to repair is not great, then repair the existing car and wait however long it takes for the prices to come down. One issue with that is that by the time we wait it may be late enough in the model year that we would then want to wait until the 2020 came out.
Primary choices right now are to either (1) buy a Volvo XC40 right now knowing that we will have to pay around MSRP, (2) buy a Volvo XC60 right now and get a "normal" discount off MSRP, or (3) wait until prices come down on the XC40 eventually and buy then but this option requires first repairing the car we are planning to sell so we can drive it in the meantime. I don't really like any of those choices.
Here is the situation.
DH and I had planned to buy a new car right about now. We have 2 cars right now. We plan to keep as our second car our Ford Explorer that we bought 7 years ago. We will probably keep it another 3 years or so.
We prefer to most likely buy a new car. We keep our cars a long time and I like to have the latest features.
The plan was to buy an SUV, but it did not need to be as large as the Explorer (197 in. long). I was focusing mostly on the 5 seaters that are around the mid 180s in length.
I've been researching it and we've test driven a number of cars in that price range. We found some that we liked (2019 Hyundai Santa Fe) but nothing that really made us feel enthusiastic like we really wanted the car.
We decided to test drive the Volve XC40 which is about 175 in. long. We had not planned to buy a car that size but I wanted to see if I felt it was large enough. We both loved the car. It was night and day how we feel about it as compared to anything else. Right now MSRP for that car with the options we want is between $42k and $43k. If we could get our exact options it would be around $41k but there are none like that to be found.
The probably is that the XC40 is an extremely popular car right now. Inventory is very low. The car is selling around list price (sometimes over). I think I could get it for list price but not significantly below.
I do think that at some point the car will be discounted normally. I don't know when that will be. It might be 6 months or more.
While this car is more that what we had originally budgeted, DH and I both agree that we can up that budget. Buying at MSRP, it is more over budget although we could do it without a lot of angst. The bigger issue is simply knowing that eventually we would be able to buy it well below list price.
While at the dealer we looked at the XC60. Some years ago we almost bought one but at the time there was no inventory to be had (a wait of about 6 months). It is larger than we really need now, but is still smaller than the Explorer. I like it and the XC40 very similarly.
An XC60 with the options that I want is about $52k. I would not feel it was worth it to pay $10k more for an XC60 than the XC40. But, the XC60 is a normally discounted vehicle. I can probably get one for $4k to $5k more than the XC40 right now.
The third option is to simply wait until the XC40 comes down in price. That in some ways is my preference. But -- there is an issue. On the car we plan to sell, it needs a repair to the front end which is causing excess wear to the tires. It is driveable but if we don't repair it, then we might need to soon replace tires. For the last couple of months we haven't been driving it as we planned to sell it when we got the new car. It didn't seem to make sense to spend money on a repair.
DH absolutely hates us only having one car to drive. He doesn't like it when I go somewhere and then he can't go anywhere until I get back. He doesn't like having to arrange his errands to when I am home. So if we are going to wait months to buy a car he wants to get that car repaired. At this point, I have no idea what it will cost to do the repair. The car is worth around $8k so I don't want to spend a lot of money on a repair and then sell the car in 3 to 6 months (thereby using up all or part of the savings that we got from waiting to buy the XC40).
I am having a hard time deciding what to do. We don't know how long it will take for prices to come down on the XC40.
I don't like the idea of paying MSRP on a car just on general principle, knowing the price will come down eventually. The car salesman was very clear that prices will eventually come down.
I slightly prefer the larger size of the XC60 from a safety standpoint, but I really don't need the larger vehicle since we have the Explorer for when we need a large vehicle. So, I am not enthralled with going that much over our budget although we could do it.
I don't feel any of the choices are great. Yes, we could switch cars to something else. But, this are the only cars we have been enthusiastic about so that would also be a compromise.
Right now, I am inclined to find out how much the repair on our existing car will cost. If it is exorbitant then we just go ahead and get a car now (not sure which). One issue with that is that there are a couple of XC40s available now that are acceptable to me. That might not be true by the time we could get that information. At that point, we might have to wait due to lack of supply. On the other hand, if the cost to repair is not great, then repair the existing car and wait however long it takes for the prices to come down. One issue with that is that by the time we wait it may be late enough in the model year that we would then want to wait until the 2020 came out.