I find it hard to believe nobody on this site has used it. Interesting, though!
I have. I didn't blindly follow their advice but used their recs as a starting point to do my own due diligence. I bought Netflix at $34 on their rec, so you know that worked out well for me. I still hold some of the MF recs I bought
I haven't been a subscriber in years, can't really remember but it's probably been 10 years? So you could do a back test on some of the stocks I'll mention. After the first year they were offering me re-ups at $49 which I felt was worth it. They are very much buy and hold, almost never sell.
Winners I had off the top of my head that I got from them:
Netflix which was huge
Activision Blizzard also huge
Cintas CTAS which is up 1600% since 2009
RGEN made 300% and sold shouldn't have
GOOG
Intel INTC
Mastercard MA huge for me 1000%?
Texas Instruments
Apple
Some others I owned and made a few bucks on before selling:
Polaris PII
Aflac AFL
Cndn Natl Railroaqd CNI
Gilead GILD
Gartner IT
MSM
Nike NKE
Robert half RHI:
Losers: National Oilwell Varco NOV great for awhile
Borg Warner BWA maybe not a loser but a laggard
Kinder Morgan KMI
Under armour UA high flyer for awhile, I think I still was up a bit when I got out
Others that I made a little on : PEP, HAS, FDX
So they did pretty well for me. I sell my losers quickly and hold my winners so I have no complaints. I should try them again to see where they are today, but I'm not really buying equities anymore now that I'm retired.
Edit to add: Costco was also a rec as was BWLD Buffalo Wild Wings and I think FB. I'll add more if I think of them. They definitely had some losers, most of which I never invested in thankfully. David Gardner was more of the home run guy while Tom was the more conservative guy.