always_learning
Recycles dryer sheets
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2017
- Messages
- 267
A while back, I asked for info on converting dh's 401k to an IRA and you all were very helpful. We are planning to do this soon-ish and today I am back with more questions, now that I've looked into the pro rata stuff.
1. I read on Ed Slott's page that one should not do a rollover and conversion in the same year because it messes with the pro rata number since the conversion isn't based on the date of conversion, but the balance at the end of the year. What? Why, then, do I keep reading blurbs about converting when the market is low? Does that only have to do with 100% balance conversions?
2. When we move dh's 401k to an IRA, we planned to convert some almost right away, so the above will affect us because he already has a ROTH IRA, correct?
3. How does the company stock come into play here if we roll it all? Is that removed from the pro rata amount since at the end of the year, it will be real stock and not in an IRA?
4. If we wait to roll the 401k and decide to convert within the 401k (which is an option), is the company stock added to the total for pro rata reasons?
5. If you had a small ROTH IRA and a large 401k with a mix of mostly pre tax & small post tax and company stock with significant NUA, would you roll it all to an IRA and convert or leave the 401k and convert to 401k ROTH?
I'm still leaning towards rolling it & taking the NUA, and just dealing with the small ROTH in the pro rata number, but I wanted advice from those who have walked before me.
I do hope this post isn't confusing. I wrote and rewrote it several times.
1. I read on Ed Slott's page that one should not do a rollover and conversion in the same year because it messes with the pro rata number since the conversion isn't based on the date of conversion, but the balance at the end of the year. What? Why, then, do I keep reading blurbs about converting when the market is low? Does that only have to do with 100% balance conversions?
2. When we move dh's 401k to an IRA, we planned to convert some almost right away, so the above will affect us because he already has a ROTH IRA, correct?
3. How does the company stock come into play here if we roll it all? Is that removed from the pro rata amount since at the end of the year, it will be real stock and not in an IRA?
4. If we wait to roll the 401k and decide to convert within the 401k (which is an option), is the company stock added to the total for pro rata reasons?
5. If you had a small ROTH IRA and a large 401k with a mix of mostly pre tax & small post tax and company stock with significant NUA, would you roll it all to an IRA and convert or leave the 401k and convert to 401k ROTH?
I'm still leaning towards rolling it & taking the NUA, and just dealing with the small ROTH in the pro rata number, but I wanted advice from those who have walked before me.
I do hope this post isn't confusing. I wrote and rewrote it several times.