PhrugalPhan
Recycles dryer sheets
Hello, I am a lurker of this site for the past few months, and decided to sign up and ask a question about Roth IRAs and rollovers. Hopefully this will start an interesting conversation.
A little background about me. I'm 52, currently planning to retire at 60 at my first opportunity when I can walk away from this job with a full pension (though maybe I will leave earlier if it makes sense). Its a local gov't job with a very stable county gov't, so I consider the pension very safe. If I stick with this job until I am 60 then my pension should be in the area of $45k/year. Additionally, if I can make it until then, I will also get a supplimental "Social Security Benefit" from the pension until I am 67, bascially paying me what I would get in SS benefits from retirement until my 67 birthday. The idea is (I think) to keep me from needing my SS benefits until then, so I can get them at a fuller amount for the remainder of my life. The last SS benefit report I received (from the government) estimated my benefits at around $2,300/mo., though the SS supplement I would get from my pension for those 7 years is about $2,500 per month (per their estimates).
With all that said, it looks at the moment I will be getting from age 60-67 the amount of $70,000/year (dropping to $45,000/year after). I am currently single (though happily in a relationship) and am putting not only $6,500/year in my Roth IRA, but I am also putting 1/2 of my yearly 457 plan contributions in as Roth-ified (post tax) contributions (which I am also maxing out). I would like to save as much on present & future taxes as possible (who wouldn't?) and am trying to see if it would ...
(A) be possible / practical / make sense to maximize my tax benefits today (that is - no Roth contirubtions in the 457 plan) and instead Roth-ify some of my 457 account yearly by taking out withdrawals and rolling them over into my Roth IRA when I retire. With this plan, I will wait until 70 to start taking SS benefits.
OR
(B) make sense to Roth-ify as much as I can today (that is - stay the course) as it won't make sense to try and take contributions out and Roth-ify them in the future when I am retired (due to too much pension income)? With this plan I would start SS benefits at 62 and invest them instead of waiting until 70. (Or will I be getting so much from the pension - $70,000 - that I should wait until 70 for SS payments due to tax issues?)
Last year's MAGI was about $63,000 using my current contribution ratio (about $18,000 saved as Roth - post tax, $11,500 went in as traditional - pre-tax). I am doing ok with the small paychecks as my expenses are extra small, and am even adding to my brokerage as my savings are increasing each month. I don't have a mortgage (house is paid off), and while I itemize, the benefit is only a few hundred over using a standard deduction. When I retire, I suspect a standard deduction will be the way to go.
Any ideas, or do I have it pretty well covered at this point? Thanks.
A little background about me. I'm 52, currently planning to retire at 60 at my first opportunity when I can walk away from this job with a full pension (though maybe I will leave earlier if it makes sense). Its a local gov't job with a very stable county gov't, so I consider the pension very safe. If I stick with this job until I am 60 then my pension should be in the area of $45k/year. Additionally, if I can make it until then, I will also get a supplimental "Social Security Benefit" from the pension until I am 67, bascially paying me what I would get in SS benefits from retirement until my 67 birthday. The idea is (I think) to keep me from needing my SS benefits until then, so I can get them at a fuller amount for the remainder of my life. The last SS benefit report I received (from the government) estimated my benefits at around $2,300/mo., though the SS supplement I would get from my pension for those 7 years is about $2,500 per month (per their estimates).
With all that said, it looks at the moment I will be getting from age 60-67 the amount of $70,000/year (dropping to $45,000/year after). I am currently single (though happily in a relationship) and am putting not only $6,500/year in my Roth IRA, but I am also putting 1/2 of my yearly 457 plan contributions in as Roth-ified (post tax) contributions (which I am also maxing out). I would like to save as much on present & future taxes as possible (who wouldn't?) and am trying to see if it would ...
(A) be possible / practical / make sense to maximize my tax benefits today (that is - no Roth contirubtions in the 457 plan) and instead Roth-ify some of my 457 account yearly by taking out withdrawals and rolling them over into my Roth IRA when I retire. With this plan, I will wait until 70 to start taking SS benefits.
OR
(B) make sense to Roth-ify as much as I can today (that is - stay the course) as it won't make sense to try and take contributions out and Roth-ify them in the future when I am retired (due to too much pension income)? With this plan I would start SS benefits at 62 and invest them instead of waiting until 70. (Or will I be getting so much from the pension - $70,000 - that I should wait until 70 for SS payments due to tax issues?)
Last year's MAGI was about $63,000 using my current contribution ratio (about $18,000 saved as Roth - post tax, $11,500 went in as traditional - pre-tax). I am doing ok with the small paychecks as my expenses are extra small, and am even adding to my brokerage as my savings are increasing each month. I don't have a mortgage (house is paid off), and while I itemize, the benefit is only a few hundred over using a standard deduction. When I retire, I suspect a standard deduction will be the way to go.
Any ideas, or do I have it pretty well covered at this point? Thanks.