SPIA - CD Ladders vs Lump Sum Pension

courtjustshan

Dryer sheet aficionado
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
35
Location
Crystal River
I am new to this forum. I am 49 years old and recently left MegaCorp after 16 years of service. I was fortunate in that the received a substantial bonus payment (40% of my existing amount) to my pension for leaving. This had to with some sort of tax rule and was tied to the current interest rate environment where lower interest rates meant a higher bonus payment. Curious to know if anyone has run across this before?

Next, I looked at the total amount in my pension and then looked at what their offer was as a lifetime payment. They offered both an immediate payment as well as a deferred payment starting when I turned 55.

I don't need the money now and am retiring at 55, so I did consider the deferred amount as a lifetime monthly payment which included joint survivability when I turn 55.

However, in looking at the numbers on immediateannuity.com, the quotes I was seeing for both immediate and deferred annuities were 20% higher than what was being offered by my company.

I decided that I could set up either a SPIA or CD ladder at 55 with 72T payments from my IRA and wind up in better shape than the company pension offer. I will also be consolidating 2 houses into 1 and will take the equity from my primary residence and use that in either a SPIA or CD ladder. I liked having the flexibility in deciding how much of my future value pension could be used.

I hope all of that made sense. My second question is, has anyone else turned down a pre-55 immediate and deferred pension offer in lieu of a self directed SPIA / CD ladder strategy?

One of the reasons I left MegaCorp was because of the 40% bonus payment by the way.

I'm sure many people have talked about this before, looking for some feedback.

Thanks!
 
In comparing the numbers, are you sure that you are comparing your pension benefit to a joint life annuity starting at age 55 but purchased at age 49 and deferred for 6 years?

The reason that I ask is the $100 today compounded for 6 years at 3% ~ $120 so the 20% difference that you are noting may be due to growth of your pension balance between now and when you turn 55.
 
good question, yes, I compared my pension benefit at starting at 55 with a deferred annuity purchased at 49 and deferred for 6 years.
 
So what are you alternatives at this point? Start taking monthly payments now, take a lump sum now and take monthly payments commencing at age 55?
 
Back
Top Bottom