PhrugalPhan
Recycles dryer sheets
Hi, I am a local government worker with about 8 years left until I can get off the golden handcuffs (that is - retire with full pension benefits). For background: In the past few years (about 7) I have been maxing out my 457 plan defined contributions at the rate of 50% pre-tax and 50% post tax (AKA - Roth). I also max out my Roth IRA (balance is currently close to 100K). Combined they are in the range of 15 years of current expenses.
I'm not FI, but I do have very low expenses, currently saving in the area of 75% across all savings vehicles. Since paying off the house in 2012 I have started a brokerage account to invest the excess that previously went to the mortgage (It has a balance that is a year of my current expenses). My savings balances (savings / checking / CDs) are well over 1 year of expenses as well.
With that all said, here's my question. I have read on other sites (as well as on here) where people expound the virtues of investing in a brokerage accounts (versus defined contribution plans). Benefits mentioned are usually: No/Low dividend taxes, immediate access to the funds in case of need, and low cost fund availability. I was considering cutting back on my 457 deposits this coming year to invest more in my brokerage account, but then I started to consider if this made any sense for me. And here is what I came up with.
I'm not FI, but I do have very low expenses, currently saving in the area of 75% across all savings vehicles. Since paying off the house in 2012 I have started a brokerage account to invest the excess that previously went to the mortgage (It has a balance that is a year of my current expenses). My savings balances (savings / checking / CDs) are well over 1 year of expenses as well.
With that all said, here's my question. I have read on other sites (as well as on here) where people expound the virtues of investing in a brokerage accounts (versus defined contribution plans). Benefits mentioned are usually: No/Low dividend taxes, immediate access to the funds in case of need, and low cost fund availability. I was considering cutting back on my 457 deposits this coming year to invest more in my brokerage account, but then I started to consider if this made any sense for me. And here is what I came up with.
- With either (Roth v. Brokerage) I have to pay taxes up front, so there is no tax benefit today with both, but a definite tax benefit in the future for the Roth over the brokerage.
- Defined contribution plans have much better legal protection from lawsuits, etc... than a brokerage account has.
- There is no limit on the Roth amounts I can save (I can do 100% Roth in the 457 plan if I want).
- This is a very large employer, and some of the funds have extremely low expense ratios, so I am happy with my current choices.
- As long as I am employed I don't need to access the 457 funds (my house and car is totally paid off and I have no known major expenses coming up), and as soon as I leave employment I can access the 457 funds with no penalties if needed (a great benefit of 457 plans).
- If I want to play with individual stocks, the 457 plan has a brokerage window.
- Given my expected pension and SS benefits, I doubt I will ever be able to have dividends taxed at 0% in my brokerage account (though if I leave this job earlier than my full pension date that could change).