Koolau
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
Hopeful,
Not really a suggestion, but something to think about: The Coming Generational Storm by Scott Burns and Laurence Koltikoff (SP?) suggest at least considering the following:
DO put in enough to get your 401k match.
Then, you need to think about the effects that your eventual withdrawals will have on your tax situation. We don't know what future tax rates will be, but, Obama's promises aside, Burns/Koltikoff make a convincing argument that future tax RATES must go up to cover the roughly $60 trillion in unfunded but promised SS and Medicare/Medicade.
Also, since SS is currently partially taxed (for some) and the taxation is based on total income, and the limits are not indexed, it is likely that most of us will eventually be fully (well at least 85%) taxed on SS. My point, it's not a slam dunk to take tax deferral. It's one of the great "unknowables" of our time, but my bet is that tax rates will only go up in the future. I'm guessing it's better to pay the taxes now.
If I had it to do over (FIRE'd in '05). I'd skip anything past the employer match in a 401k and go with a fully taxable account. (I'm just assuming you're already doing your Roth to the max.) As it is, I'm currently "Rothising" as much of my traditional IRA's and 401k as I can and keep myself in the 25% tax bracket. I'm also holding off on SS (at this time) in order to "Rothize" as much deferred money as possible before my income "leaps" with the advent of SS.
YMMV, so talk to someone who knows more about this than I do. But YOU will have to make the "guess" on whether you think tax rates will increase.
Honestly, I hope I turn out to be wrong on this!! But, read the book. Scary, but well researched stuff. I think this is probably going to bite us big time. Especially you younger folks!!
Not really a suggestion, but something to think about: The Coming Generational Storm by Scott Burns and Laurence Koltikoff (SP?) suggest at least considering the following:
DO put in enough to get your 401k match.
Then, you need to think about the effects that your eventual withdrawals will have on your tax situation. We don't know what future tax rates will be, but, Obama's promises aside, Burns/Koltikoff make a convincing argument that future tax RATES must go up to cover the roughly $60 trillion in unfunded but promised SS and Medicare/Medicade.
Also, since SS is currently partially taxed (for some) and the taxation is based on total income, and the limits are not indexed, it is likely that most of us will eventually be fully (well at least 85%) taxed on SS. My point, it's not a slam dunk to take tax deferral. It's one of the great "unknowables" of our time, but my bet is that tax rates will only go up in the future. I'm guessing it's better to pay the taxes now.
If I had it to do over (FIRE'd in '05). I'd skip anything past the employer match in a 401k and go with a fully taxable account. (I'm just assuming you're already doing your Roth to the max.) As it is, I'm currently "Rothising" as much of my traditional IRA's and 401k as I can and keep myself in the 25% tax bracket. I'm also holding off on SS (at this time) in order to "Rothize" as much deferred money as possible before my income "leaps" with the advent of SS.
YMMV, so talk to someone who knows more about this than I do. But YOU will have to make the "guess" on whether you think tax rates will increase.
Honestly, I hope I turn out to be wrong on this!! But, read the book. Scary, but well researched stuff. I think this is probably going to bite us big time. Especially you younger folks!!