Welcome, BanDit1! Regarding your original question, you first. But in the meantime I thank you for getting me to think outside my usual 4% box (which was once 8% because I was raised on Terhorst). The first thing you got me thinking about is that the amount to be withdrawn from my portfolio overlaps with my pension/profit sharing stream due to lump sum rollovers mixed with my IRA and the fact that my Keough with my current employer is under my control; not to mention a small pension payout that wasn’t rolled over.
I see little reason to break it down as you suggest. More interesting things to contemplate might be: 1) what percentage is deferred income?; this is so important because of difficult-to-determine tax consequences; 2) is the pension stream inflation-protected? (mine is not); 3) consider the synergy of it all-–I work for current income and future pension and SS pay outs, the income increases the amount I can put into an IRA and regular savings; 4) _______; 5) _________ ; etc. Like Jack Benny, I’m thinking it over.