Meniscectomy Vs Knee Replacement

[Chuckanut]

I think there’s a difference between a lateral and medial injury and effects with medial being both the more common and worse impact.

That said, I’m 42 years past a lateral removal and hanging in there. No running since. Lots of walking. I do use a treadmill at times with its cushy surface. Had to give up ski trips a few years back as recovery from pain and stiffness became too much. Still hit the local hill for a half day few times a year.

At the time of removal, was told I would need a KR sooner or later. Three years ago I had it re-examed for the first time as it was acting up more severely than it ever had. Told I was 2-5 years out yet, but today it’s not as bad as then. Did learn I’m not a PKR candidate because of poor bone alignment - bow legged. So TKR is what it will be.

That was my story until about two years ago. About that time my knee’s ability to function OK started down a much steeper slope. Thankfully it lasted long enough that one TKR should be good for the rest of my time on this planet.

 

[RunningBum]

Of course you want the best surgeon available if possible, but a meniscectomy is not a difficult procedure. I would not travel far or wait long if a competent surgeon is available locally and sooner. A friend who just had one done and her top choice was not available for months was advised this by her sports med doctor, I think.

 

[Livefree]

This procedure came out a few years ago for people that were too young for knee replacement


https://newyork.cbslocal.com/2016/04/29/knee-replacement/#.VyY_Mg6CQgo.twitter

 

[mabuhay]

My knees are a mess too, from years of running, but PT to strengthen, then regular cycling has saved them. I can only walk a few miles max, but can bike for two hours. I also use a newer powdered Glucosamine Sulfate product that apparently helps renew the cartilage. No problems since last tear 3 years ago when I rehabbed it with a exercise program and ramped up the cycling.