My "exit interview" I request HR to be there

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fiddler

Recycles dryer sheets
Joined
Jul 6, 2016
Messages
56
In my company, every retiree gets an exit interview. I have had a great career working in production. For almost three decades I have been a valued productive employee. I was not a problem employee. I never abused sick time or was a problematic employee.

Two years ago my father (over 80) became sick. He lost one kidney, then the second kidney became diseased and he had an operation on a tumour on his remaining kidney. Half of the kidney was removed. He was on dialysis for months..but now, surprisingly for his doctors and everyone else..he is off dialysis and managing his blood creatine with diet. The man is tough!

At the time my father had his health crisis (I am the only child that lives close, my sister lives in another province) I asked to be put on 12 hour shifts, to accommodate the many trips to the hospital (three hours away from our rural home).

This was not an unreasonable request. I work in production and we work 24/7 my "day job" was considered a perk. For a person to request transfer from the day job (that only high seniority people hold) to shift should have been an easy.

Thing is-- I worked for a well managed production team, but when the former boss retired, it went to shambles. I was very vocal (being over 50 and saying what I want) and I made the point how previous management was successful, but the same team under new management was failing drastically. This, of course, did not win me favour with the new manager. And , in fact, the company recognized his ineptitude and moved him to a different role.

My bad luck, he was moved to manage production resources ie transfers. When he saw my request to move to 12 hour shifts he summarily denied it. I then asked for a two month sabbatical to support my father in his health crisis. His doctors thought he would die soon.

I had a meeting with HR with my request for either a sabbatical or a move to 12 hr shifts to accomodate my family situation.

The HR representative denied my request and chastised me for asking for special treatment. He spoke loudly like a bully. I suppose I was asking for special treatment. But in HR "speak" it is called accomodation. He did not ask me about my specific situation ..he had his mind made up. And it was obvious the manager who I offended by being vocal about how the team had failed under his mismanagement, was able to extract his vendetta against me from Human Resources.

I finally got transferred. I have worked the 12 hour rotating shifts for the last two year. My father has recovered. My new boss respects and appreciates me as a good employee who has experience and maturity.

And now I will soon retire.

But I am going to ask the same HR person who treated me like dog **** on his shoe to be at my exit interview.

Because it was not fair. How I was treated.
 
Eh, there are so many ways to get revenge. The shrimp in the curtain rod trick. Leaving a "special surprise" on someone's desk. Drop a guppy in the radiator and every time the heat comes up they will remember you. And so on.


What are you hoping to do or say in the exit interview? These things are usually pro forma and check the box.
 
Brewer
What I want from the exit interview is to hold HR accountable, so what happened to me does not happen to someone else.
 
Brewer
What I want from the exit interview is to hold HR accountable, so what happened to me does not happen to someone else.


Wishful thinking.... but if it makes you feel better.... because nobody else will care... (well, the HR might get pissed and do whatever he can to cause problems with your retirement.... you know, lost paperwork or not checking a box that is needed....)
 
If you are in a position where you 100% KNOW you can burn the bridge, I say light that flamethrower.
 
Brewer
What I want from the exit interview is to hold HR accountable, so what happened to me does not happen to someone else.

I am not sure how that is possible. HR usually cnducts these interviews and they generally do not care what you say.
 
Rather than expend time and effort on what will almost surely be a wasted and frustrating endeavor, move on with your life and trust karma to even the score. Life is short...
 
My husband's exit interview was with his immediate supervisor from the production team (we worked at the same place). There was no HR representative present. I am going to formally ask not only my immediate supervisor, but the Vice President of Production...and two HR people ..the guy who treated me like dog s**t on his shoe...and his boss..the vice president of HR.
 
What I want from the exit interview is to hold HR accountable, so what happened to me does not happen to someone else.
Good luck with that. Exit interviews are invariably an exercise in going through the motions. Frankly, no one will particularly care about a bitter and soon-to-be-ex employee's complaints: especially regarding an issue that happened over two years ago.

If I were in your shoes, I would listen to REWahoo's advice. Why spend life looking in a rear view mirror? Instead, focus on the good things, e.g. your father's unexpected recovery and the fact that your current boss appreciates you.
 
I am not going unprepared for the interview. In fact, I am so profoundly disappointed about how I was treated by HR, I have educated myself. I am going to this seminar. It is expensive, but when I look back..HR treated me so badly I wanted to quit (my husband, thank God, talked me out of it).
It has been over two years since this happened..Yet I am still dismayed and angry.
So I am going to this seminar...Yes it is expensive..but I will be SO prepared for my exit interview with HR and my production team members..who, in my opinion are not being given professional support from our HR organization https://www.hrpa.ca/pages/hrpa-meet...3-1f43-e611-9f7b-00155d320a0d&cm_medium=email
 
Make your exit interview a 30 second meeting. " Adios! It's been nice and have a good life."

At this point, they don't care what you think. No retirement party, no Seiko watch, no nothing. That's the way current business is.

At my MegaCorp, an exit interview consists of two big outside security guards showing up at your desk giving you a box and five minutes to pack your things. And don't you dare take any "company pencils." Fortunately, I was 300 miles from home in a company car and told tomorrow was my last day.

It was the best thing to happen to me--and all the other 55+ workers--to be ushered out this way. They paid a big price to send us to the house too.
 
Milton/ReWahoo
I believe you give good advice. There is a part of me ...a BIG part of me..that wants to just ride off into the sunset.
But where does that leave the workers like me I leave behind...I have a unique position..I can SAY THE TRUTH...without worrying about ramifications..because I will retire.
Part of me..yes I dearly want..to just let it go. However...this HR person did not help me..did NOT help the production team (that makes the $$$) he did not act professionally.

After the interview I will be registering a complaint against the HR "professional" who treated me badly...Yes I could just forget about it and retire..But what about the others that turn to HR for help and are treated badly? I have to do something....Or it will happen to someone else. https://www.hrpa.ca/professional-regulation/submit-a-professional-complaint
 
"If you seek revenge, first dig 2 graves"

Forgetaboutit
 
Thing is-- I worked for a well managed production team, but when the former boss retired, it went to shambles. I was very vocal (being over 50 and saying what I want) and I made the point how previous management was successful, but the same team under new management was failing drastically. This, of course, did not win me favour with the new manager. And , in fact, the company recognized his ineptitude and moved him to a different role.

Sounds like you burned a bridge that you then tried to walk over?
 
RobbieB
I think you give good advice..But this is bigger than just me and HR. It is about accountability. If I forgetaboutit it will happen to someone else. I have to do this. For the workers that come behind.
 
clobber
I definitely burned a bridge with the incompetent manager. Thing is for over 2 years I have been a valued employee with production since I finally got the transfer I needed. The incompetent manager?...he was removed totally from production and now works in "training" where he cannot screw up the bottom line.
Since I have good relations with my new production team..I am pushing for accountability with HR..because they failed our team..the production team..the team that makes the money.
 
clobber
I definitely burned a bridge with the incompetent manager. Thing is for over 2 years I have been a valued employee with production since I finally got the transfer I needed. The incompetent manager?...he was removed totally from production and now works in "training" where he cannot screw up the bottom line.
Since I have good relations with my new production team..I am pushing for accountability with HR..because they failed our team..the production team..the team that makes the money.

Everything in work and life is about relationships. Even if I accept your position that this particular situation was 100% the bad managers fault, it sounds like you did learn there were things you could have done to prevent the pain you experienced. However, it does not sound like you are willing to apply what you learned?

More specifically, my interpretation is that you wish to attack this person some more. This could come back to haunt you in ways you cant currently imagine? Just like you did not imagine it would haunt you in the previous situation.

Time to leave it alone?

@RobbieB provided a good quote above.
 
I suggest you make that point to an executive in operations, managers above HR who keep tabs of the bottom line. Structure your meeting from the standpoint of profitability. Talk like an Executive.
 
clobber
glad to get the HR perspective from you. Yup the HR guy clobbered me. I was not prepared. I thought (naively) he would listen to my situation before saying NO....I was not prepared for the bully boy HR person. It was only AFTER the experience I learned from the https://www.hrpa.ca/ Human Resources Professionals Association...that I understood the HRPA mandate regarding Accomodation. I joined the association and paid the fee. Now I know the professional standard. Which the HR person I delt with disregarded.
 
clobber
I definitely burned a bridge with the incompetent manager. Thing is for over 2 years I have been a valued employee with production since I finally got the transfer I needed. The incompetent manager?...he was removed totally from production and now works in "training" where he cannot screw up the bottom line.
Since I have good relations with my new production team..I am pushing for accountability with HR..because they failed our team..the production team..the team that makes the money.

Honest, the healthiest thing for you to do would be to let it go. You are leaving for good. Whatever goes on in this meeting with whoever the company chooses to send (and you won't get to choose who shows up), will not make any difference. The company will run things the way they wish to, HR will bury any complaints you lodge, and if anything all you will accomplish is burned bridges.

There really is nothing you can do. Let it go. As they say, living well is the best revenge.
 
Here is the thing clobber..about the "pain I experienced"...by speaking my mind. I alerted top management to the problem, knowing full well about the consequences alienating the incompetent manager.

If I stayed silent..yup..I would "prevent the pain" I experienced. And stayed silent. as our production team got sucked into the vortex of incompetence.

I said the truth and I knew I would feel the consequences.

And I am glad I did.

The fact that my father was close to death should have allowed me accommodation. The aggrieved manager used it punitively against me. I have since educated myself with HRPA.
 
As several have mentioned you should put it behind you and move on. It sounds like this is more about yourself than them? Their company, their game and their rules.
 
I was once in a similar situation and used Compassionate Care Leave. The money was irrelevant; what mattered was the acknowledgement that being there for my mother was important.

Once again I am grateful to live in Canada.

https://www.canada.ca/en/employment...ms/ei/ei-list/reports/compassionate-care.html

Fiddler.....

Why did you not take advantage of the "Compassionate Care Leave" benefit as Meadbh did? When you simply ask for a sabbatical, as you did, management must consider the fact that they will be setting precedent in granting it and similar cases going forward must also be granted. That's why govt's establish benefits such as "Compassionate Care Leave." So that a standard, common to all, set of rules and definitions exists for HR dept's to follow without having to make judgments on individual cases.
 
Last edited:
The time the manager did his actions to punish you is when you should have gone to whomever is in charge of ethics for your company. The time has passed and it's too late for an investigation now. A departing employee just sounds like he's venting and they won't take any action now. Best to let it go and move on to the next phase of your life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom