Ugh, just looked on Google, and Pie Town Cafe was said to be permanently closed. A victim of Covid, no doubt.
PS. No, Pie Town Pies is what we talked about, and it is still open. There's also a Pie-O-Neer Pies, which is also permanently closed.
Hmmm... I recall that when I made a stop there, there was only one place, not three.
PPS. Both Pie Town Pies and Pie-O-Neer Pies are on the north side of the road, and that rules out Pie Town Cafe as the place I visited. From the look at photos of the interior, I think I stopped at Pie-O-Neer and not the other place, which might not exist then.
Now, which one is the original? From a Web research, I think Pie-O-Neer is (the one now closed). It also served only pies, and nothing else. It was established in 1920. Too bad that Covid killed it.