Horrifying

B

brewer12345

Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
Joined
Mar 6, 2003
Messages
18,085
I don't know what the hell is wrong with FEMA, but it really seems like little or nothing is being done to get the poor unfortunates in NOLA out. People are dying on the street of dehydration, ferchrissakes! The national guard and the police seem more interested in driving around in armored vehicles than actually doing anything to get the survivors out. How hard could it be to commandeer a bunch of helicopters within 12 hours of the storm impact and drop supplies off and lift people out? Is this some kind of sick urban renewal program? The clown allegedly in charge in the White House is doing the hurricane version of reading "My Pet Goat" except that it is going on for days.

Unvelievable. I guess everyone knows that those too poor to get out before the hurricane struck probably weren't Republicans.
 
Agreed, I was getting really angry while watching CNN during lunch today. And this news about snipers now? WTF? Get some frickin helicopter gunships in there and unload the gat guns on those damn snipers! Seriously, even airdropping MREs and water would go a LONG way to help people out until the situation gets under control. The images I saw on TV did not look like they should be coming out of the USA.

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/050830/480/capm10208301856

Note the date that was taken... way to take charge of the situation!
 
This has been a total disaster, and better come as a wake up call. For all the talk about homeland security, and how much we've done to prepare for another disaster/terrorist strike, the fact they can't even get more than a couple hundred national guard to the outskirts of town is pathetic. It's my understanding the only government help seen on the streets is local (police, fireman, doctors etc.). I'm having real difficulty in understanding what people see in W. at this point. :mad:
 
"In early 2001, the Federal Emergency Management Agency issued a report stating that a hurricane striking New Orleans was one of the three most likely disasters in the U.S., including a terrorist attack on New York City. But by 2003 the federal funding for the flood control project essentially dried up as it was drained into the Iraq war. In 2004, the Bush administration cut funding requested by the New Orleans district of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for holding back the waters of Lake Pontchartrain by more than 80 percent. Additional cuts at the beginning of this year (for a total reduction in funding of 44.2 percent since 2001) forced the New Orleans district of the Corps to impose a hiring freeze."

Remember that political capital that Bush liked to talk about earlier this year? I think that account is overdrawn now.
 
Marshac said:
Note the date that was taken... way to take charge of the situation!
Click to expand...

With the commonly held opinion by W's non-supporters that he is a dufus, why would you want him anywhere near the gulf coast right now? ;)

REW
 
Brett Hume on Republican News Network (otherwise known as Fox News) spent a long time last night painting anyone who critisized the President over this in a bad light, at the time I thought, "who is saying what?" But now I see the political machine is trying to hit the news cycle first, so that any exposure of grevious mistakes leading up to this looks like partisan politics. Craven, disgusting. I'm done, I'm re-registering as independent. This is the last straw.
 
I hate to be Mr. Critical but the news was out days in advance about a cat 5 hurricane headed for Nawlins yet nothing was ready to go the day after :confused:
 
This thing has now gone all political, so it is best to watch ,but not listen.. Of course the next phase will be the Hollywood  types moving in for their take.
Oh yes, can you guess the next disaster movie??
This ordeal deserves a serious investigation.  From what I am seeing, I'm thinking maybe this operation went to hell early cause there never was any local leadership at the early stages.  I think maybe the ship was adrift without a rudder when FEMA moved in. With no established command it makes it tough to get established when you are invited guests from the outside.
BTW, FEMA and NOLA just did a drill on this same senario about a year ago.
Hate to be one of many Monday morning quarterbacks, but it sure feels like the locals lost control which led to future chaos.  I watch a lot of TV cause I sit at the desk pushing stocks all day and I'd have to say I really never saw a LA official step up and take charge.  We shall see.
It is interesting to check out craigslist for NOLA.  Lots of missing, lots of interesting offers of assistance.

I think about 75K coming to Texas. Mostly Houston, SA, and Dallas.  I believe they will have internet access so maybe we will hear from unclemick.
 
Marshac said:
Agreed, I was getting really angry while watching CNN during lunch today. And this news about snipers now? WTF? Get some frickin helicopter gunships in there and unload the gat guns on those damn snipers!
Click to expand...

Jesse Jackson and the Reverand Al would surely approve of that.

Ha
 
Hollywood types, Jackson and his ilk, other yata yattas, I could give a hoot.

The bottom line is executive management and resources.  The current team hasn't executed.

If my dear departed Father (COE Engineer) predicted this 20 years ago, this risk was well known for years why weren't resources pre-positioned?

I don't care if you are R or D, this is a management issue.  The current administration can't claim that they didn't have time to properly staff and evaluate the risk.  This is a screw-up of major proportions that was predictable as to place and the weather service gave fair warning.  

What do you think would have happened if it were a WMD terrorist attack at an unpredictable place and time?

Praying for UncleMick
 
I posted a question yesterday, I think, about what this all meant and what lessons could learn about staying with one's home and assets vs getting the hell out of Dodge if something like this happened to us.  

I now see the biggest lesson of all -- don't be poor.

JPatrick points out that "this operation went to hell early..."  I'd say that is exactly right -- about 20 YEARS early.  I mean, I can remember a very interesting and entertaining PBS show about hurricanes -- a BIG part of it described New Orleans' dilemma in very clear detail -- there were computer simulations of the levees, what it would be like if they were to break, etc.  

Nobody can say they didn't know this could happen.  So... where were the busses and the national guard and the airlifts BEFORE this thing hit?  Why are we reading in the newspapers about people piling their families into their rust buckets and driving until they run out of gas... and not having a dollar in their pockets to buy any more because this hit the day before payday?  Why weren't these people in Houston four DAYS ago?

OK... sorry for rant...  I'm just really shocked to see little old white-haired ladies sweltering in the heat and tiny children running around in the "sewage soup" waiting for someone to help them.  The morning newspaper featured an 85-year-old man pausing to rest -- up to his knees in water.

This turns my stomach.  

The only tiny consolation I see in this is Lawrence becoming an independent.  Another few years of the same administration and he'll be solidly over here in the liberal camp.  I'll keep the light burning for you, Lawrence.

caroline
 
This isn't a liberal or conservitive issue, it is a management issue.

Our current CEO has a MBA from an Ivy League University.  It should be subject to recall, even if he isn't!
 
Now this is weird- - -
I'm on a mailing list for jobs requiring high security clearances.. I've lost interest long ago, but I stay on the list so I can pass the info on.
So anyway, while I'm reading all the posts about how screwed up the management was on this disaster- - -an email comes in for a job with the following description; I deleted the agency name.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S an scientific research and development firm serving the national security community, is seeking a mid to senior level emergency planner at its Arlington, Virginia headquarters. This individual will develop emergency planning and management plans, policies, and procedures; and will provide expert advice and recommendations on all aspects of emergency planning and management at both the tactical and strategic levels. They will also be called upon to develop and assist with emergency planning training, education, exercises and drills.



Requirements for the position include a minimum of five years experience in emergency preparedness, emergency management, disaster management or related fields. U.S. citizenship and secret security clearance desirable. A relevant bachelors degree and a thorough knowledge of the operational aspects of emergency communications preferred.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Maybe someone is expecting heads to roll?? :-\
 
REWahoo! said:
With the commonly held opinion by W's non-supporters that he is a dufus, why would you want him anywhere near the gulf coast right now? ;)
Click to expand...

I say get him out there. When he sees with his own eyes how miserable people are, perhaps he gets to thinking about those choppers etc that are always the background to his speeches. A chinook can carry 20000 lbs, so why aren't they using even just one to ferry water and food to the people who are stuck? And his speech about how we should all donate cash pisses me off too. We're spending $80b in Iraq each year, but we can't afford $1b for an emergency at home? Being just a little creative with that awesome army of ours could go a really long way. Do I need to go to the streets to protest in favor of spending this time?

Tim
 
If my dear departed Father (COE Engineer) predicted this 20 years ago, this risk was well known for years why weren't resources pre-positioned?
Click to expand...

Yes, I remember a story one of the news mags. a few years ago on NOLA and I think the risks were well known. My experience with FEMA (from a few tornadoes in our area) is that they just give people checks and sit on the phone. The one FEMA rep. that I spoke with was really clueless. There really should be a local command and control. All I hear is the NOLA mayor. That is not the person that should be handling this. You need a military style hierarchy to get things done.
 
I'm not clear on the physical layout of things.  Is it currently possible to drive a normal car to the area of New Orleans where most of the people are, or are the roads totally blocked?

In other disasters around the world, you often see a long river of refugees walking away from the disaster area.   I haven't seen that on the news.
 
TromboneAl said:
In other disasters around the world, you often see a long river of refugees walking away from the disaster area.   I haven't seen that on the news.
Click to expand...

At least from what I have seen of new orleans, you pretty much need a boat to get around. :-\
 
"W" was busy at the time, taking time out from his 5 WEEK VACATION to talk about how his war is comparable to WW2.
Maybe his reference to WW2 is linked to FDR, he is after all also trying to dismantle Roosevelts great societal net.

I'm sorry, but when you check the box for "Leader Of The Free World" I would assume that job means 24/7/365. Hell, I'm only raising 2 kids and am lucky to get 5 DAYS off a year.

Meanwhile the many thousands of troops (many I'm sure from NOLA) and billions of dollars are away in Iraq, when they could be here, saving lives, property and the economy.

I'm pretty stupid but not stupid enough to blame a natural disaster on a politician. But I sure as hell expect leadership of the commander in chief. More than grabbing a bullhorn for a camera op (ala 9/11).

W cares only for himself, his rich cronies, and the christian right that placed him in power.
 
Bad time for partisan politics, but something went very wrong here and things will get uglier politically as the reality of New Orleans unfolds. (EDIT: I mean I don't see this as a partisan issue and dislike when some 'leaders' try to make it into one, but bashing those in charge is fair game IMHO.)

The following is a blog of some network tech guy who's staying in New Orleans maintaining computer equipment. My first thought was there must be something better to do, but I read a bit and this raw news is very intriguing (and horrifying).

http://www.livejournal.com/users/interdictor/


I made a donation to the A.R.C. relief fund today. It was a tough decision for me as I've spent so much time getting into the position I'm in and I'm not FI yet, but I'm certainly more capable of handling financial setbacks than many--maybe even most--Americans.
 
TromboneAl said:
I'm not clear on the physical layout of things.  Is it currently possible to drive a normal car to the area of New Orleans where most of the people are, or are the roads totally blocked?

In other disasters around the world, you often see a long river of refugees walking away from the disaster area.   I haven't seen that on the news.
Click to expand...
If you are coming from out of town you can drive to the SilverDome.  Problem is, most of the cars that were already in town,  are now aquairiums :(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

FiveDriver
What exactly does FEMA Flood Insurance cover?
Replies
5
Views
448
FiveDriver
FiveDriver
P
Condo common area cleaning dilemma
2 3
Replies
50
Views
1K
Teacher Terry
Teacher Terry
PaunchyPirate
What is a good site for UK politics viewable from the US?
Replies
18
Views
604
fosterscik
fosterscik
aja8888
Show off your dog..or other pet..and how well he/she is treated (and fed)!
2 3
Replies
57
Views
2K
Gotadimple
Gotadimple
folivier
Scam artists
2 3
Replies
51
Views
3K
Koolau
Koolau

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom