Minimizing taxes on high wage income

Time2

Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
Joined
Oct 3, 2019
Messages
3,701
I'm trying to get my newly graduated Dentist daughter educated on how to minimize taxes and maximize savings. I expect between her and he husband they will gross $250k a year and it will increase. I was never in that ballpark and all I know are using IRAs and maximizing her HSA. They have 12 year old so could do some type of tax deductible educational account, but I only see a maximum of $2,000 a year can be invested.

So my question is, Are there any methods a couple with high wage income can minimize taxes?
 
Best method: get a good accountant.
 
Best method: get a good accountant.


That may be a good idea, but I think they should have a good understanding of things, so they can a least have a bit of understanding about whether the accountant they hire has any sense.
I had an accountant for years, but all he ever did was my taxes. Never once did he tell me I should put money in Roths instead of tIRAs. Now I'm furiously doing Roth Conversions because the up coming Dividends, SS, and RMDs will put me in a higher tax bracket. I learned to late, pay the taxes due when you tax bracket is low. Our wage income was much lower than our retirement income will be. Unless, we have a real market surprise.
 
I made over $300k for many years. The first thing they need to know is they are the target for high taxation. Anyone earning big bucks, will take a tax hit.
We maxed out all deferred accounts.
We used the right investment in the right account. Index ETFs, muni’s in taxable. Managed funds, corporate bonds, dividends, etc in deferred.
Start a giving trust like they offer at Fidelity. Good way to move capital gains into donations.
If they still need more deferred contributions, maybe consider a deferred annuity. Another way to shelter assets from taxes. Just don’t annuitize the income.
They could also look at incorporating as a professional so they can get additional deferred account options with higher contribution maxs.
 
If your high income is W-2 earnings then there isn't much that you can do other than suck it up and pay the tax bill. You can do maximum contributions to tax-deferred 401ks, tIRAs, HSAs, etc but not much else. Very few levers to pull to reduce taxes.

Investing taxable account money in municipal bonds can help lessen the tax bite. Also, investing taxable account money in domestic equities results in qualified dividends and LTCG being taxed at preferential rates.

I've never been very keen on 529 plans but some people love them. For our GK I'm thinking of a Treasury Direct account where the taxes will be deferred but there are fewer restrictions than 529 plans and if GK decides not to go to college then the money isn't hung up in the 529 plan.
 
Last edited:
Best method: get a good accountant.

Better method is to understand taxation so they can be proactive. I did all my own taxes throughout my high earner years using TurboTax. It got easier every year and I thought I was a good planner. I used an accountant for a year and most of the time I ended up pointing out his mistakes because I understood my position far better than he did.
I also had a full service broker. Ditto - bad mistake.
A more recent example with not trusting a professional is when I signed up for our ACA policy. I had to point out to the broker that tax free income is included when considering subsidies. His response to me was “we normally don’t have people with muni bonds”.
So in summary, professionals don’t always know what you think they should know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jj
I made over $300k for many years. The first thing they need to know is they are the target for high taxation. Anyone earning big bucks, will take a tax hit.
We maxed out all deferred accounts.
We used the right investment in the right account. Index ETFs, muni’s in taxable. Managed funds, corporate bonds, dividends, etc in deferred.
Start a giving trust like they offer at Fidelity. Good way to move capital gains into donations.
If they still need more deferred contributions, maybe consider a deferred annuity. Another way to shelter assets from taxes. Just don’t annuitize the income.
They could also look at incorporating as a professional so they can get additional deferred account options with higher contribution maxs.


She is starting with an established Dental company having many offices. so she is an employee for now. They are just getting established and don't need to be concerned about donating, she needs to build a net worth for when she starts her own business. If she decides to stay with the company, than at least start saving for retirement.
 
Better method is to understand taxation so they can be proactive. I did all my own taxes throughout my high earner years using TurboTax. It got easier every year and I thought I was a good planner. I used an accountant for a year and most of the time I ended up pointing out his mistakes because I understood my position far better than he did.
I also had a full service broker. Ditto - bad mistake.
A more recent example with not trusting a professional is when I signed up for our ACA policy. I had to point out to the broker that tax free income is included when considering subsidies. His response to me was “we normally don’t have people with muni bonds”.
So in summary, professionals don’t always know what you think they should know.


That was in my comment, I want the kids to know enough to see when the account is clueless. Then hopefully they won't need one.
 
We maxed the 401ks, IRA's & HSA. A couple of years, DW was designated a "Highly Compensated Employee" which allowed up to 50% deferred income for federal & state taxes into a Vanguard account (separate from the 401k).

You may want to research this. Our experience with it worked great. We had to pick a payout duration (lump, 5yr or 10yr) and when she quit, it activated the payments quarterly in our case (we did 5yr). We took some time off and practically paid no federal tax on the payout & got a tax refund for the state tax from California.

YMMV
 
If your high income is W-2 earnings then there isn't much that you can do other than suck ot up and pay the tax bill. You can do maximum contributions to tax-deferred 401ks, tIRAs, HSAs, etc but not much else.

Exactly. While working, DH and I were in the same situation, no kids, in the 35%ish bracket (forget exactly, and it kept moving). Not much you can do, we typically had nothing other than the standard deduction, charity, basic stuff, simple taxes. No roths even. Max the 401k and HSA, and then pay up.
 
She is starting with an established Dental company having many offices. so she is an employee for now. They are just getting established and don't need to be concerned about donating, she needs to build a net worth for when she starts her own business. If she decides to stay with the company, than at least start saving for retirement.

Donations can reduce taxes though, your original question.
 
Exactly. While working, DH and I were in the same situation, no kids, in the 35%ish bracket (forget exactly, and it kept moving). Not much you can do, we typically had nothing other than the standard deduction, charity, basic stuff, simple taxes. No roths even. Max the 401k and HSA, and then pay up.
+1. That was my conclusion while making big bucks, along with being very careful with capital gains/excessive trading. But that’s just deferring taxes - not necessarily “minimizing” as the OP asked. Now that I’m retired I’m doing huge (worthwhile) Roth conversions optimizing tax rates throughout retirement and I’m also sitting on huge LTCGs - though I will take them in small bites in the decades ahead so not a mistake IMO.

Future tax rates could be a big factor in [-]minimizing[/-] optimizing after all as well, but none of us can predict the future. I know what I’m planning on though…
 
Last edited:
Assuming they have inquired of employers and determined that there are no deferred compensation programs available, there aren't a lot of good options for W2 employees.
 
Donations can reduce taxes though, your original question.

Agreed! Plus, I think it is very important for the younger generation to start appreciating charitable giving once they get into a position where they have the means to do so.
We have tried very hard to raise our kids with some sense for community and charity. In general, they turned out well, but I have to say, they are still not in a very charitable mindset even at near age 30. In fact, so much so that DW and I are in the process of changing our estate plans so that when we pass, half of our estate will go to charities we select. The other half will be split between our two kids. Chances are that they will still get a very nice inheritance and this way, we can make sure charity doesn't get short-changed. YMMV
 
Donations can reduce taxes though, your original question.

The OP's OP did not mention donations at all... you were the first to mention donations.

I'm trying to get my newly graduated Dentist daughter educated on how to minimize taxes and maximize savings. I expect between her and he husband they will gross $250k a year and it will increase. I was never in that ballpark and all I know are using IRAs and maximizing her HSA. They have 12 year old so could do some type of tax deductible educational account, but I only see a maximum of $2,000 a year can be invested.

So my question is, Are there any methods a couple with high wage income can minimize taxes?
 
The OP's OP did not mention donations at all... you were the first to mention donations.

Right, but the OP was looking for "ways to reduce the taxes", and charitable donation are one way to reduce taxes.
 
^^^ Only if you itemize and most people do not.

If the donation is large enough, it may make sense to itemize even for someone who doesn't typically itemize. Note, the OP did not specify that he was looking only for ways to reduce taxes without itemizing. Whether you like it or not, COcheesehead's answer was a legitimate response to the OP's question.
 
Last edited:
^^^ Only if you itemize and most people do not.

If the donation is large enough, it may make sense to itemize even for someone who doesn't typically itemize. Note, the OP did not specify that he was looking only for ways to reduce taxes without itemizing. Whether you like it or not, COcheesehead's answer was a legitimate response to the OP's question.
Over 85% do not...so a qualified response seems appropriate.
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2022-06-25 at 1.22.16 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2022-06-25 at 1.22.16 PM.png
    351.3 KB · Views: 60
$250k AGI for MFJ isn't too bad taxwise but as you mention, it should get quite higher year after year.

Have Dentist Daughter check with the HR dept to see what options are available.
Hopefully they do a full match on all 401(k) contributions...
 
OP, one thing that your daughter first needs to have an idea about is her overall life plan and income trajectory. Tax planning is quite different depending on whether she (a) wants to work and have a high income for the next 40 years and retire with two vacation homes and a boat, or (b) wants to work the next 5 years then barista FIRE and live on $30K.

This is because probably the biggest and best overall tax planning idea is to shift income from high tax years to low tax years, either by deferring income (retirement contributions) or accelerating income (Roth conversions). One first needs to have an idea of what is "high" and what is "low" to be able to make decisions.

Maxing out retirement accounts and HSAs are the main thing for W2s. There are also a number of education tax benefits that she can educate herself about - 529s, ESAs, AOTC, LLC, etc. 529s can come with a decent state tax benefit depending on where she lives, and the money isn't stuck there if the kid doesn't go to college; there are a number of ways to get the money out with little to no tax impacts.

*If* she is charitably inclined, she can be tax-efficient with her donations. Donating appreciated long term securities is one way - she'll avoid CG taxes. DAFs are helpful for bunching, which enables itemizing, which can provide a tax benefit. QCDs down the road are very helpful.

Oh, another big thing. There are people on this board who end up having taxation issues because they own actively managed funds in taxable accounts. These actively managed funds can throw off large and sometimes unexpected distributions, which can mess with tax planning. I've read about people who are sort of stuck because they've accumulated these funds over years and therefore have large unrealized CGs. The tax bill to switch is painful, but so are the distributions. So you might suggest she invest in low-distribution investments in taxable, like BRK.B or index funds.

Agreed! Plus, I think it is very important for the younger generation to start appreciating charitable giving once they get into a position where they have the means to do so.
We have tried very hard to raise our kids with some sense for community and charity. In general, they turned out well, but I have to say, they are still not in a very charitable mindset even at near age 30. In fact, so much so that DW and I are in the process of changing our estate plans so that when we pass, half of our estate will go to charities we select. The other half will be split between our two kids. Chances are that they will still get a very nice inheritance and this way, we can make sure charity doesn't get short-changed. YMMV

As an aside, you might look into charitable remainder trusts if you're at risk of exceeding the estate tax exemption (which is dropping to about $6M in a few years).
 
Over 85% do not...so a qualified response seems appropriate.

Actually, your own table would suggest that the vast majority of >250'000 per year earners (such as our OP's DD) DO IN FACT itemize deductions. No?
 
If the donation is large enough, it may make sense to itemize even for someone who doesn't typically itemize. Note, the OP did not specify that he was looking only for ways to reduce taxes without itemizing. Whether you like it or not, COcheesehead's answer was a legitimate response to the OP's question.

Actually the OP was looking to minimize taxes and maximize savings. Since no matter how nice a tax benefit you get contributions are a net outflow I think doing donations to reduce taxes is not a good idea... it doesn't maximize savings which was one of the OPs objectives.

Make donations bacause you want to and like the cause, and the tax benefit is nice, but at the end of the day it is still money out the door.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom