Secondcor521,
Thank you for sharing and the words of wisdom. You gave me an idea. I think I will give them each $5000 plus a coupon to match 100% of any Roth IRA contribution they make up to $3000.
So they can choose to use $3000 of the $5000 gift to put in their Roth and get $3000 more for a total of $8000. Or they can opt to use the $5000 for something else and not contribute to their Roth. At least I’m thinking of doing something like that.
Like anyone I’m just wanting to encourage wise decision making and avoid enabling poor decision making.
This sounds like a great idea, and assuming they leave it in the Roth it satisfies your intention. However, contributions can be withdrawn.
I funded both of my kids Roths through college when they had modest earnings. They are now in their 30s with good sized Roths for their age. One of them lives in a HCOL in Southern CA). He has owned a home for almost 7 years, made a decent return and built equity thanks to low interest rates. Downpayment was gifted from us and his inlaws. His DW, who is an artist with no income producing skills, wants him to take out his Roth contributions and invest in more Southern CA real estate. She thinks they will make a killing. I happened to find out by accident, he had no intention of sharing. His DW is a very domineering person who always needs to get her way, so I won't be surprised if it happens even if he doesn't think it's a great idea.
Aside from where the real estate may or may not be going as an investment, I explained that a dollar in a Roth is worth more than a taxable dollar, and to exchange them is not a prudent move. I suggested they save up a downpayment on their own, since they will need to save money for retirement any way. He doesn't even want to manage it, says he can hire someone to manage it and still come out ahead. He's never even cut his own grass. I was cutting my grass and changing oil, generally being frugal in many ways, to have money to put away in my accounts as well as theirs.
I agree with you about trying to encourage good decision making, but he has changed a lot since moving to CA and getting married. They make fun of where I live "flyover country" and I've told them the money that got them in a house came from living in flyover country.
Reading this thread with interest, because I don't want to see my money squandered, and am seriously considering limiting how much I leave as inheritance to my 2 kids. Would like to leave some to my 1 grand kid, but am concerned about when and how much. I've watched my sister go through her mid 6 figure inheritance and arguably create more problems (didn't try to get a job in her mid 50s, thought the money would last forever, substance abuse, now in her early 60s and apparently broke - we don't know for sure because she has cut off contact with family, just know that there are tax liens on her modest paid for house, says her cell phone and computer both died she hasn't gotten around to replacing, so won't take calls or e-mails, doesn't respond to snail mail, sad situation).
Best situation for me would be to live long enough to see my grandson become a young adult and decide how much to leave him at that point. I am fearful for his future being raised in the manner he is. I'd always planned to spend money on vacations/experiences where I would pick up the tab, but the CA boy's wife doesn't show up (which means not seeing the grandson), or if she does she throws tantrums and pretty much ruins the stay for everyone. One trip where I specifically paid extra money for accommodations for them and she wouldn't get on the plane because she didn't sleep well the night before. Very narcissistic.
Not trying to be a negative nelly, but this is where we're at. One thing that has come out of all this is I'm more comfortable spending money on the two of us!