Light mayonnaise?

O

Orchidflower

Thinks s/he gets paid by the post
Joined
Mar 10, 2007
Messages
3,323
I have some recipes that ask for light mayonnaise. When it first came out I bought a jar and it was horrible.:( In fact, I threw the entire jar out after tasting it. It was the first brand that came out, so I assume it was Kraft's as I know it wasn't Hellman's?
Has light mayonnaise improved at all over the past years?
Or is there a cooking substitute for mayonnaise that isn't so fat laden I could use in this recipe? I'm coming up with zip myself, so figure someone here might know.
Any ideas?
 
What are you cooking? If it is a once-a-year holiday treat I would just use the regular mayo. I rarely use mayo myself but once in a while buy tiny jars of Miracle Whip for tuna or chicken salad. I use a small amount and put in other stuff like mustard and relish as less caloric "binders".
 
Years ago I used to make my own light mayo, but I stopped doing that about 20 years ago and I don't remember the recipe. Anyway, maybe you can find a recipe to try, online. Mayo is one of those things that tastes SO much better when made fresh, for some reason.

I don't buy mayo any more, light or not, so I don't know a brand to buy.
 
DW likes Best Foods light mayonnaise which, I think, is a reduced fat version of the original. I guess I can't the difference. There's also another type (fat-free?) that she doesn't like.
 
I would just use regular mayo, Orchid. And I agree with W2R that homemade is really good (I've not made a "light" homemade, however), and it's surprisingly easy to make.
 
I'll check into making some myself then. Frankly, that didn't even occur to me to try and make my own light, so thanks!
Has anyone tried the light type lately and does it still taste horrible?
 
Orchidflower said:
I'll check into making some myself then. Frankly, that didn't even occur to me to try and make my own light, so thanks!
Has anyone tried the light type lately and does it still taste horrible?
Click to expand...
I got a pack of it in a McDonalds. Yes, it was horrible. I refuse to eat it. Just buy some real mayonnaise (I use Trader Joe's canola oil real mayonnaise). It's good and it's pretty cheap.

Ha
 
Just say no to lite mayo.
Maybe you could use less of the real stuff? Depending on the [-]application[/-] recipe, you might be able to substitute something that tastes good but isn't bad for you e.g. plain yogurt.
 
I use yogurt as mayo, and it works for sticking tuna together for tuna sandwiches.

I have no idea how it would work for a real 'recipe.'

And there you have the heights of my culinary abilities...

ta,
mew
 
Last edited:
The nonfat greek yogurt (a common brand name around here is Fage) would work really well as a mayo replacement for things like tuna salad, egg salad, and ranch dip. It has a substantial and very creamy texture that a lot of other yogurts lack, and it's not as tart as most plain yogurt. I'm planning on mixing it with ranch dressing mix to make a nonfat ranch dressing that is still thick and creamy.

For cooked items, I have no idea how it would work.

I also really like Veganaise, which tastes exactly like regular mayo to me, but is vegan. It's not "lite" mayo, and has the same number of calories per same serving size as Best Foods, but it has a gram less of fat and one gram less saturated fat.

I have no idea what the light version tastes like.
 
I use light mayo (Kraft) all of the time on sandwiches. Tastes fine to me. I was never a real mayo addict. Could be I just don't really know what I'm missing.
 
I've used Hellman's Light for years. However dh2b grumbled about it :rolleyes:, so I buy the real stuff now. I have no cholesterol problems. He does genetically, but I keep his consumption of eggs and egg products very minimal at home.
Moderation is key here. :D
 
Goshs, if that light mayo tastes like it did when it came out...blech! God bless you if you can choke it down as I couldn't...and I surely am no picky eater.

Yogurt is a great idea! I'll definitely try it, and, if that doesn't work for cold tuna-type salads, I am off to make it myself. There has to be more than one way to skin this cat.
 
Dukes is the best mayo - regular (even the "light" did not make me gag) I have my ex ship some up to me periodically...only the little jars since I am not a big mayo freak.
 
Yeah, "light" in market-speak means less fat and much more sugar (and salt) -- same or more calories, however. (Another name for Lite mayo is that terrible tasting "salad dressing" by Best Foods.

Anyway, the trick is in getting the "right" fat. I, sometime ago, switched to Best Foods Canola Mayonnaise. They even claim it has half the fat but I can't taste any difference. In any event, I feel good mentally while using it.
 
It's all what you're used to.

I'm a mayo nut. I've made my own, but usually I am content with Hellman's regular. (Best Foods is the same brand, sold out west.) I bought a jar of Duke's when I was in North Carolina last month and didn't like it. I do sometimes substitute Fage yogurt in salads and instead of sour cream on taco's, baked potatoes and latkes.
 
RonBoyd said:
Yeah, "light" in market-speak means less fat and much more sugar (and salt) -- same or more calories, however. (Another name for Lite mayo is that terrible tasting "salad dressing" by Best Foods.
Click to expand...
True about the sugar and salt, which I did not realize. Thanks for pointing that out.

But the light versions of the Hellman's mayo or Kraft Miracle whip are definitely lower in calories. The nutrition labels are online.

I try to just use less of whichever I buy. Don't glob it on thick, and I just spread it one one side, and basically only wipe my knife on the other side.
 
RunningBum said:
True about the sugar and salt, which I did not realize. Thanks for pointing that out.

But the light versions of the Hellman's mayo or Kraft Miracle whip are definitely lower in calories. The nutrition labels are online.

I try to just use less of whichever I buy. Don't glob it on thick, and I just spread it one one side, and basically only wipe my knife on the other side.
Click to expand...

I, of course, meant "Miracle Whip" and not "Salad Dressing." And what I was referring to was the taste factor not the calories. Yes, the "Lite" mayos taste exactly like "Miracle Whip" -- very sweet and completely lacking that "tang" that Lemon and egg yolk adds. In any event, lower calories at the expense of taste didn't seem like the OP's goal to me.
 
"Light" is relative when it comes to mayonnaise. "Light mayonnaise" may be an oxymoron. Personally I can tolerate Hellmann's ligt mayonnaise. But I once bought some "fat free cheese" and it tasted so gross I had to throw it out.
 
I've heard of Best Foods, but realize now it's something that sells probably west of the Rockies. Shoot..I'm in Illinois now.
Never even heard of Duke's brand until now. Would like to try it.
Not much diversity here in foods and other things (altho the area isn't politically conservative much at all), so maybe the best thing for me is to try the Greek yogurt (which I have seen here in a grocery store) and, if that doesn't work, try and make some myself.
I guess I'm a Hellman's gal at heart...if they would only lower the fat content.
 
Orchidflower said:
I've heard of Best Foods, but realize now it's something that sells probably west of the Rockies. Shoot..I'm in Illinois now.
Click to expand...

See post #18: "I am content with Hellman's regular. (Best Foods is the same brand, sold out west.) "

(As well as my previous post.)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Kitchen Light Mystery
Replies
21
Views
1K
JoeWras
JoeWras
O
Installing LED headlights on older vehicles?
Replies
22
Views
1K
wolf
W
P
So disappointed with my Honda experience
2 3 4
Replies
77
Views
5K
Koolau
Koolau
skyking1
I gave notice about starting my pension today!
Replies
21
Views
952
skyking1
skyking1
FlaGator
Direct Marketing Incompetence – A Vexing Problem
2
Replies
35
Views
930
athena53
athena53

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom