DD has an unfriendly neighbor (couple with kids) with a driveway basketball hoop. In a storm last week it fell onto her car and damaged the roof. The estimate to repair is $490.
DD took pictures of the hoop laying in the driveway and her car. She attempted to discuss it with the women, who has refused to come to the door (sends her young kids). Her ex-husband coincidentally stopped by at that moment and did offer to help. Once acknowledged, the current husband promised to pay for repair. Today, when DD informed him of the estimate, the response was one of aggression (but no threat) and denial, and the phone call ended in an argument and refusal to pay. The ex wants no further involvement.
My question is, does DD have any recourse, or is she out $500? Can she involve the police or is this a civil matter? Is her only recourse small claims court, and if so, is she likely to prevail in the face of a complete denial of any responsibility? I told her I’d ask and get back tomorrow or Sunday. Looking for advice.
DD took pictures of the hoop laying in the driveway and her car. She attempted to discuss it with the women, who has refused to come to the door (sends her young kids). Her ex-husband coincidentally stopped by at that moment and did offer to help. Once acknowledged, the current husband promised to pay for repair. Today, when DD informed him of the estimate, the response was one of aggression (but no threat) and denial, and the phone call ended in an argument and refusal to pay. The ex wants no further involvement.
My question is, does DD have any recourse, or is she out $500? Can she involve the police or is this a civil matter? Is her only recourse small claims court, and if so, is she likely to prevail in the face of a complete denial of any responsibility? I told her I’d ask and get back tomorrow or Sunday. Looking for advice.