ERD50
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
Sounds like virtually all your refrigerator trouble have to do with water/ice maker dispenser. This is why I got rid of my ice makers (including in all my rental properties) a long time ago. Just not worth the effort to us (we use very little ice and can easily deal with ice trays for what we use). Very few refrigerator repairs since....
I never connected the ice maker that came with our previous fridge. These things take up space, and are a repair problem, and potential leak.
The place we moved into had a nice new fridge with all the in-the-door water/ice. I hate it. I just look at all the room that takes up. And then DW gets ice, and the thing starts making racket at 3AM when it completes a cycle, and I wonder what the heck, is someone trying to break in?
I did find the shut off valve in the dropped ceiling in the finished basement, so I have a tag hanging from that so I can find it in an emergency.
I'm really tempted to rip it out. Not sure I could free up any space inside the fridge, it's all part of the construction.
Since the invention of plastic ice trays, I just don't see the fuss over an ice maker. Fill the tray, take it out and twist and the cubes pop out (not like those aluminum trays with the lever - what a pain!). I put the cubes in a sealed container so they don't pick up odors or dry out through sublimation. Quick and easy.
Oh, and when we had company, we ran out of ice! So how do you know how much is in there? With the manual method, I just look at my container, and can make some ahead of guests coming over.
Oh, and they are energy hogs as well. They actually use heat to melt the cubes from the container so they pop out. Hmmm, heating up your freezer - does that make sense? Oh, and to add insult to injury, guess what - the Energy Labels for refrigerators don't take into account the energy use of the ice maker, it's off for the test - doh!
-ERD50