ERD50
Give me a museum and I'll fill it. (Picasso) Give me a forum ...
.... I do understand the skepticism. But if people are telling the truth, there is more than we understand going on in these incidents. YMMV again.
For me, it's not about anyone "telling the truth" or not. Everyone talking about these events seems serious, I'm sure they are telling the "truth". I put "truth" in quotes, and I'm serious about it, not trying to be funny or condescending. If you experience something, and that something is now embedded in your brain, that becomes "your truth". What else do we have? Here's an example to illustrate (no pun intended):
There's a famous drawing, an optical illusion of a checkerboard with an object casting a shadow on part of the board. Square A and Square B are the same shade, though Square A appears much darker. Even when I know this, I can't 'see' it w/o using a piece of paper with a hole in it to view the squares w/o the surrounding shades (or use a color picker on the computer!). Without the explanation, my 'reality', my 'truth' is that A is darker than B. I'm not lying, I'm not crazy. It's what I believe.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Checker_shadow_illusion
Now if you observed that outside of the context of being an optical illusion, and lets say you had a reason to study it for a while, and embed it in your memory. I'm certain that you would remember Square A being darker than Square B. It's your 'truth' even though it isn't so.
There is no way to disprove something 'mystical' about what people have described, you can't prove a negative. All I'm saying is, I see some pretty rational explanations for all of it.
It's impressive that Qs Laptop's wife heard and then (edit, maybe this was a weird example, but I typed 'ten' instead of 'then' and didn't catch it until I re-read my post - see the '10' in the next phrase - was my mind 'seeing ' ahead?) saw his premonition, but with a lifetime of 10 events (but only a very few witnessed?), I lean towards thinking that he's had many of these, and remembers only the ones that came to pass. That is human nature. I could be wrong, we can't settle this here, but that's my leaning. I've definitely had the experience of suddenly noticing a certain model car after buying one, or considering it. Those cars were there all the time, now I notice, only my perception changed. Same way with a new vocabulary word, never heard that word before that I can recall, then I hear it three times in two days. Certainly, this is just a perception thing.
.... Maybe there is some connection between people. Telepathy? I don't know. But, why not? ... But there seems to be a connection that we don't fully understand. Why not some connection between people that not everyone has or has noticed. Just spit balling here, so YMMV. ....
Perhaps there is. I can't rule it out. But so far, any scientific study of it has failed to uncover anything. Doesn't mean it doesn't exist, but...
-ERD50
Last edited: